Re:They Studied Dishonesty. Was Their Work a Lie?
by bee_rider on Saturday September 30, 2023 @02:02PM
(#37718041)
That somehow loops around to becoming an interesting 8’th grade science project.
Do an easy experiment once correctly, then again with falsified data. Present the results side-by-side. Ask people if they can tell you which is which. Present have a bit on what sort of statistics could catch your faked data set.
Re:They Studied Dishonesty. Was Their Work a Lie?
by bombcar on Saturday September 30, 2023 @02:20PM
(#37718240)
Yeah, I did the simplistic thing of decide a question and an answer that sounded good; ran five or so tests, and then extrapolated additional sets based on that.
In my defense I would have run more tests had I started when I should have :)
Re:They Studied Dishonesty. Was Their Work a Lie?
by bonoboTP on Saturday September 30, 2023 @02:26PM
(#37718306)
Except the "it" in "getting it" is a significant of even bombastic and sexy finding. There's no reliable way to generate those, it's not just about hardness. The more correct and meticulous you are with your data, the more it will generally tell you that the bombastic claim is false. The more meticulous and effortful you are about faking, the likelier it will slip by.
Your suggestion only works in the simulated science, like school projects where you are retracing the footsteps of past successful scientists, to verify an already known result. There putting in more work will reveal that effect more and cleaner, because your teacher already knew how the thing works in the first place. This is totally unlike real science where we confront the frontier of the unknown.
Re:They Studied Dishonesty. Was Their Work a Lie?
by tqi on Saturday September 30, 2023 @06:07PM
(#37720377)
Yeah that is fair, but it's mind bogglingly lazy/brazen. How much more effort is it have taken to just take an average of a few RAND calls to get a normal distribution instead of a uniform one? Did they not know the central limit theorem??
Faking data realistically is almost as hard as getting it honestly. I know, I “expanded the data pool” for my eight grade science project.