News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by dccoolgai on Saturday September 30, 2023 @08:39AM (#37714861)
There was a lot of borderline propaganda on US news media during the war in the 90s that a lot of people swallowed whole without thinking about it too much: "Serbs are bad. Everything they do is bad. Albanians and Croats are just simple innocent victims." (To the point that even the reporter doing most of the coverage at CNN was Albanian and no one thought that was a conflict of interest).

The reality is, of course, a lot messier and more unpleasant: The region is filled with people who hate each other and tend to massacre each other along ethnic lines whenever one group gets the upper hand over the others. There's a reason every World War starts there. So NATO stepped in and basically said to Serbia "If there are non-Serbs in _your_ borders, they may form breakaway republics and you must let them secede. However, in Kosovo (your former state) Serbs may not do the same thing." Serbs were basically ethnically cleansed out of Kosovo under the "protection" of NATO Kfor. There are multiple accounts of NATO forces standing a few feet away and watching as Albanians burn and loot Serbian Orthodox churches and villages.

I'm not sure what "the way out" of this is, but I think US/NATO has a responsibility to treat all the sides equally, which they don't exactly have a great track record of doing.

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by surfingdino on Saturday September 30, 2023 @08:45AM (#37714902)
WWII started with Germany invading Poland. That's a few good kilometres North of Kosovo.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by timeon on Saturday September 30, 2023 @08:57AM (#37714973)
> Germany invading Poland

Germany and Russia.

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by klausjensen on Saturday September 30, 2023 @09:13AM (#37715117)
Outrageous!

The army of USSR just took a field-trip to Poland to protect Soviet minorities!

They then rounded up about 22,000 Polish military officers, took them to the Katyn Forest outside of Smolensk for a lovely picnic - as a show of good will.

How these thousands of Polish officers ended up in mass graves with bullet holes in the back of their heads remains a mystery.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katyn_massacre

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by cempaka on Saturday September 30, 2023 @11:32AM (#37716394)
Seems like lately HN threads are full of people trying to sketch some kind of moral equivalence between Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union. Stalin only resorted to the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact after spending years trying to convince the Western powers to help reign in Hitler, and getting nowhere because they were more interested in financing and accommodating him. The territorial gains they made were later crucial in halting the Nazi advance in Operation Barbarossa.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by greyw on Saturday September 30, 2023 @11:51AM (#37716637)
Can you elaborate what you exactly mean by that? The soviet union and nazi germany both invaded poland and it partitioned with a border agreement (1941). Before and during that they had a bunch of trade agreements (German–Soviet Commercial Agreement in 1939, 1940, 1941). Clearly, they got along just fine before operation barbarossa.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by helij on Saturday September 30, 2023 @12:52PM (#37717280)
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by alephnerd on Saturday September 30, 2023 @08:46AM (#37714908)
> I'm not sure what "the way out" of this is

An EU assension leading to a shared economic zone and open borders. This is what brought peace to North Ireland, Romania-Hungary, Greece-Bulgaria, etc.

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by rbanffy on Saturday September 30, 2023 @09:00AM (#37714990)
It didn't stop Brexit however. Europe might get nasty at some point, if we think of all the far-right posturing and their recent successes. These people are dangerous.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by alephnerd on Saturday September 30, 2023 @09:06AM (#37715050)
NI doesn't make or break elections in the UK. That's why brexit happened.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by rbanffy on Monday October 02, 2023 @03:53AM (#37735098)
UK still got bitten hard by the realities of Brexit, which were made very clear by EU officials (and everyone with an IQ above room temperature) over the whole process.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by leereeves on Saturday September 30, 2023 @08:55AM (#37714958)
> Serbs were basically ethnically cleansed out of Kosovo under the "protection" of NATO Kfor. There are multiple accounts of NATO forces standing a few feet away and watching as Albanians burn and loot Serbian Orthodox churches and villages.

I want to learn more about this, but I can't find a reliable source. For what it's worth, the Wikipedia article about the "2004 unrest in Kosovo" (AKA the "Pogrom against the Serbs") [1] has many accounts of Kfor protecting Serbs.

Where can I find accounts of NATO forces doing nothing?

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_unrest_in_Kosovo

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by ttyprintk on Saturday September 30, 2023 @09:46AM (#37715390)
I think that’s referring to one this week:

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/9/24/one-police-officer-...

And Zociste in 2009

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by selimthegrim on Saturday September 30, 2023 @09:56AM (#37715473)
But they weren’t looting the monastery this week
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by ttyprintk on Sunday October 01, 2023 @12:51AM (#37722670)
The article at present reads “The Serbian Orthodox Church also confirmed that gunmen had stormed the monastery in Banjska“
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by selimthegrim on Sunday October 01, 2023 @03:59AM (#37723778)
Serbian gunmen not the Kosovo police at that point.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by leereeves on Saturday September 30, 2023 @11:12AM (#37716188)
Again that doesn't support the claim that the Serbs lack protection. In that case the Kosovo police protected the Serbs and "the NATO-led KFOR mission said its forces were present in the area, “standing ready to respond if required”."
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by ttyprintk on Sunday October 01, 2023 @01:05AM (#37722762)
Let me know if you find reliable reporting toward the gp description.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by dccoolgai on Saturday September 30, 2023 @10:33AM (#37715812)
"Between the arrival of the Kosovo Force (KFOR) in June 1999 and the 2004 unrest in Kosovo, more than 140 holy sites were destroyed, about half of the historical ones from the 14th and 15th centuries"

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_of_Serbian_herit...

Among other things, this is just what's findable in 40 seconds on Wikipedia.

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by leereeves on Saturday September 30, 2023 @11:05AM (#37716122)
The claim above was that Kfor merely watches it happen - does your link support that claim?

It doesn't seem to. In fact, that source says "Due to vandalization, the need arose for the armed force of the UN to protect locations containing Serbian religious heritage in Kosovo."

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by dccoolgai on Saturday September 30, 2023 @12:23PM (#37716974)
Another 20 seconds using Google yields from HRW:

"In others areas, local KFOR units have been unable or unwilling to intervene to prevent displacement or destruction of property"

https://www.hrw.org/reports/1999/kosov2/

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by leereeves on Saturday September 30, 2023 @12:47PM (#37717216)
Even that source, while critical of the work of Kfor, acknowledges that "In some areas, such as Gorazdevac, Podujevo, and Kosovo Polje, KFOR is providing direct protection to at-risk Serb and Roma populations."

And I don't see where it supports your claim that "There are multiple accounts of NATO forces standing a few feet away and watching as Albanians burn and loot Serbian Orthodox churches and villages."

But thank you for that link. It seems to offer a balanced assessment of the situation.

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by dccoolgai on Saturday September 30, 2023 @06:29PM (#37720537)
I'm up to like a whole two minutes now. I'm done after this, but here's some more pretty direct quotes:

"French KFOR troops refused to come to the assistance of the Serb residents of Svinjare, even though their main base is located just a few hundred meters from that village. The entire village of Svinjare—all 137 homes—were burned to the ground within viewing distance of the main French KFOR base."

"In the large town of Kosovo Polje, only a few UNMIK police and no KFOR personnel came to the assistance of the besieged Serbs, leaving a handful of local KPS officers to protect more than one hundred Serb families scattered around the city. One Serb was beaten to death, and at least one hundred Serb homes were burned, as was the main post office, the Serbian school, and the Serbian hospital."

link: https://www.hrw.org/reports/2004/kosovo0704/6.htm

It goes on and on and on. For anyone who knows much about the region, this is pretty close to "common knowledge". But you won't hear much about it in the Western Media - which circles back up to my original point that "Maybe the Western media has been telling us the easy/policy-confirming story instead of the real but messy one".

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by nezirus on Saturday September 30, 2023 @11:16AM (#37716236)
Yeah, lets treat all "sides" equally, since they are all bad (sarcasm ends)

Go to https://www.icty.org/, read about cases, verdicts and pleas:

https://www.icty.org/en/cases/key-figures-cases care to search for the GENOCIDE word in there?

Serbia did bad the things in Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia, and was going to do the same in Kosovo until NATO bombarded them. (Kosovo was already critical in 80ies)

That doesn't absolve any party of the commited (war) crimes, but it is perfectly clear who was/is the regional bully and who commited aggression against neighbours.

I also don't buy tipical lines "they all hate each other", or this is the revenge for what " they" did to "us" in WW2, WW1, during Ottoman times, during Roman times ... Historical crimes are not excuse for new ones, vicious circle must stop somewhere.

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by from on Saturday September 30, 2023 @12:20PM (#37716934)
You are aware that Milošević and Tuđman both agreed to carve up Bosnia, right? And there was Varivode, "Operation Storm" where the Krajina Serbs who didn't flee quick enough were raped and pillaged, and a whole bunch of other cases. Milošević, the JNA, Srpska, or the Serb "volunteer guard" may have been the worst but there are plenty of contenders for second place. Not to mention the Bosnian mujahideen.
Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by C6JEsQeQa5fCjE on Saturday September 30, 2023 @12:22PM (#37716963)
Everything you wrote is correct, and I would just like to add that in all the wars during the 90s, all Serbia had to do in order to avoid war was to not attack other countries and support paramilitary groups inside other countries. They were not defending their territory, they were invading others. Same with this possible invasion that they might be preparing right now, all Serbia needs to do is not attack.

Trying to paint this as "all groups hate and massacre each other" is equating the motives of the attacker/invader/bully with the victim, and is just pure propaganda or invention of alternate reality in order to soothe one's guilty conscience. To draw a parallel with something more people might be able to more clearly visualise, Serbia is the armed robber that breaks into your house and starts stealing your stuff and beating you, your wife and your children. By the logic of the "all sides" propaganda here, you are engaging in "mutual hatred" if you try to defend yourself.

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by helij on Saturday September 30, 2023 @12:50PM (#37717248)
This reads like propaganda piece. Today we know it was not black and white like that. Balkans is relatively peaceful these days yet we see constant attacks on Serbs in Kosovo (primary school got demolished the other day which is pure fascism) and sometimes in eastern Croatia as well (not allowing the use of Serbian language/Cyrillic alphabet).

All in all when can we expect Serbs to have paid their 'debt' not to see attacks on Serbian children anymore for example?

You bring a lot of past into the debate and somehow try to portray that Serbs today are guilty and deserve it when they get oppressed, beaten or killed. Sounds like a witch hunt to me.

Just today three more Serbs were beaten by police in Kosovo.They accused them of illegally crossing the border, booked them and then let them leave. Those three people went home to their houses in, wait for it ... Kosovo. Fine, if they illegally crossed the border you book them. No need to beat them right. But unfortunately this is now standard procedure there.

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by C6JEsQeQa5fCjE on Saturday September 30, 2023 @01:07PM (#37717446)
If there are illegal attacks on Serbs (especially children, as you put it), then they should stop and no country should mistreat its citizens. Furthermore, it would be better for everyone to reduce tensions and promote unity and peace, obviously. So that covers that.

Now, Serbia needs to stop waging wars in other countries and stop promoting nationalism that has historically lead to constant violence. Serbia has its history and it earned its reputation by its own acts. It would be extremely foolish for Serbia's neighbouring countries to ignore that history.

Re:White House warns of ‘unprecedented’ Serbian troop buildu... by helij on Saturday September 30, 2023 @01:39PM (#37717819)
Why do you keep saying Serbia should stop waging wars when Serbia actually didn't wage any wars in the last 24 years at least? If you don't count Kosovo war (considering it's Serbia's territory as per the UN) then it's more like 28 years.

It would also be extremely foolish for Serbia to ignore hostilities towards Serbs from others. How long into the past can we go? 24 years, 20, 50, 100, 200, 300? Violence in 2004 on Kosovo? I mean you seems to be perfectly fine excusing current terror against Serbs by something that happened 25 years ago. The whole issue in the Balkans is lack of trust due to experience with each other, which is not really good. You can't have favourites here.

What you're writing is pure nonsensical propaganda with throwing out 'promoting nationalism, constant violence'. Show me an example of Serbia promoting violence in the last 20 years? I think they are quite pacified. Kosovo is a complex issue and you can't just expect a sovereign country to give a part of their internationally recognized territory away. I guess you equate Serbia not recognising Kosovo as independent country as promoting nationalism and violence. It's like saying Ukraine is promoting violence when they fight in Donbas. Serbia and Kosovo were on their way to peace and some kind of normality when EU negotiated the treaty 10 years ago. Guess who it is that didn't implement what they signed. What is happening today is a direct consequence of that.