News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A policy of mass destruction by Torn on Thursday March 29, 2012 @10:27AM (#3771207)
Naomi Klein's 2009 film "The Shock Doctrine" (imdb: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1355640/), available on netflix, looks at similar subject matter.

In short, the 'chicago school' economics lead by Milton Friedman posit that as-free-as-possible markets, de-regulation and privatisation are economically beneficial. In practice (see: Argentina, Chile, etc) they only seem to further the gap between rich and poor, and the 'shock doctrine' way of destabilising the existing economy and government to achieve this is pretty disgusting.

Re:A policy of mass destruction by maratd on Thursday March 29, 2012 @11:28AM (#3771473)
> In short, the 'chicago school' economics lead by Milton Friedman posit that as-free-as-possible markets, de-regulation and privatisation are economically beneficial.

They are. You want a comparison? Let's compare Chile to North Korea, and the wealth gap in those nations. Free-as-possible markets aren't perfect. They may not even be good. But they're better than the alternative.

Re:A policy of mass destruction by EvilTerran on Thursday March 29, 2012 @11:58AM (#3771609)
"Free-as-possible markets ... are better than the alternative[, North Korea]."

That's a nice false dichotomy you've got there.

Re:A policy of mass destruction by maratd on Thursday March 29, 2012 @01:10PM (#3771980)
Wow. In the future, if you're going to put quotes around something someone said, make sure they actually said it. Re-arranging words that I used into new sentences doesn't count.
Re:A policy of mass destruction by EvilTerran on Thursday March 29, 2012 @01:35PM (#3772128)
I made no attempt to hide my editing. I stand by it, too -- I only stated explicitly what you were implying.

You followed the dichotomy "Let's compare Chile to North Korea" with the dichotomy "Free-as-possible markets [or] the alternative", in a context where the parent comment had already associated Chile with "free-as-possible markets". Are you now going to insist that you were not intending to associate North Korea with "the alternative"? Because I find that pretty unlikely.

Re:A policy of mass destruction by maratd on Thursday March 29, 2012 @02:19PM (#3772357)
I should have used a plural instead of the singular. There are, of course, many alternatives to the free market. Communism, socialism, feudalism, anarchism, capitalism, cronyism, and quite a few other isms. And free markets are better than all of those alternatives. You don't think so? Examples, please, instead of non-existent dichotomies.
Re:A policy of mass destruction by EvilTerran on Thursday March 29, 2012 @05:21PM (#3773180)
Indeed, the mention of North Korea as an alternative only got under my skin owing to its proximity to the implication that there was only one alternative - I probably wouldn't have bothered grumbling if only that "the" had been an "any".

A market that was "as free as possible" would have no government regulation at all - there's one of those in Somalia. How's that for an example?

Re:A policy of mass destruction by maratd on Thursday March 29, 2012 @05:49PM (#3773277)
> there's one of those in Somalia. How's that for an example?

First, I asked for an example of an alternative that works better. You gave me an example of what you think a free market system looks like.

Second, that's not even an example of a free market system. That's anarchy. Anarchism. An ism. A free-market system still has a functional judiciary, a respect for property rights, etc etc. Somalia has none of those.

Re:A policy of mass destruction by EvilTerran on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:28PM (#3773676)
Of course Somalia's not an example of something that works better. I meant it as (I guess the term would be) a co-example; there's no market regulation, & it's pretty obvious that pretty much anything else works better.

However, I do insist that, strictly speaking, anarchy is a free market system - it's the reductio ad absurdum of free-market-ism. It's only fair if you're willing to cite North Korea, a totalitarian dictatorship with absolute state power, ie the reductio ad absurdum of state regulation, as an example of such. North Korea also lacks a functional judiciary, a respect for property rights, etc etc.

I take it you at least consider justice & law enforcement to be sectors that benefit from state regulation - and I'd be surprised if there were no other such sectors as well.

To take less extreme examples:

* the (pre-Obamacare, as it's too early to judge the new setup) US healthcare system, which is less regulated than most developed countries', is the most expensive & least effective.

* In the UK, the cheapest & most reliable part of the rail network is the part in Northern Ireland... being the only part that wasn't privatised back in 1993. Everywhere else, costs have grown & reliability has fallen.

...

To try to find some common ground here: you believe in "as little regulation as possible", but that "as little as possible" is not none; I believe in "as much regulation as necessary", but that "as much as necessary" is not totalitarianism. I suspect these beliefs are, in the end, adjoint - opposite approaches to the same fundamental idea, although we may disagree on the details. Does that seem reasonable to you?

Re:A policy of mass destruction by maratd on Thursday March 29, 2012 @09:36PM (#3774100)
> Does that seem reasonable to you?

Actually, I can sum up my beliefs very simply. I am against big things. Big government, big business, big whatever. Big things breed corruption. I don't mind regulation or even government involvement, as long as it's happening on a very local level and I have the freedom to live someplace else.

Re:A policy of mass destruction by EvilTerran on Friday March 30, 2012 @04:58AM (#3775047)
Okay, I can get behind that. I feel a certain amount of government is necessary to stop big business, big gangs (mafia & the like), or whatever from getting out of hand -- but too much government has its own problems. As you say, corruption, whoever gets too big.

Similarly, a certain amount of unionisation helps keep big business under control, but too much leads to the workers holding the populace hostage.

And so on -- balance in all things, really. Although what constitutes "balance" will vary considerably depending on what you're looking at. (Law enforcement needs more regulation than most industries, for instance.)

Re:A policy of mass destruction by Symmetry on Thursday March 29, 2012 @10:42AM (#3771274)
Wait, how on Earth could you call Argentina an as-free-as-possible market? And I'd far rather live in Chile even in the bottom quintile than any other country in South America.
Re:A policy of mass destruction by bhb916 on Thursday March 29, 2012 @01:51PM (#3772211)
First, "The Shock Doctrine" was a book before it was a political documentary. Recommending the movie but not the book seems a little silly to me.

Second, I can't recommend it as a serious work. I've read a lot of Klein's work (two of her books sit here on my bookshelf) and I walked away each time rather unimpressed. In this particular case, she takes something that can be universally condemned (deliberately creating or taking advantage of disaster to pursue corporate interests) and uses it as a weapon against those who advocate free markets. This is a blatant misrepresentation of that ideology, the chicago school, and Milton Friedman. In short, Klein builds a great case against corporatism, rent-seeking, and government sponsored elitism and then beats those lobbying for freedom and equality over the head with it.