News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A policy of mass destruction by EvilTerran on Thursday March 29, 2012 @05:21PM (#3773180)
Indeed, the mention of North Korea as an alternative only got under my skin owing to its proximity to the implication that there was only one alternative - I probably wouldn't have bothered grumbling if only that "the" had been an "any".

A market that was "as free as possible" would have no government regulation at all - there's one of those in Somalia. How's that for an example?

Re:A policy of mass destruction by maratd on Thursday March 29, 2012 @05:49PM (#3773277)
> there's one of those in Somalia. How's that for an example?

First, I asked for an example of an alternative that works better. You gave me an example of what you think a free market system looks like.

Second, that's not even an example of a free market system. That's anarchy. Anarchism. An ism. A free-market system still has a functional judiciary, a respect for property rights, etc etc. Somalia has none of those.

Re:A policy of mass destruction by EvilTerran on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:28PM (#3773676)
Of course Somalia's not an example of something that works better. I meant it as (I guess the term would be) a co-example; there's no market regulation, & it's pretty obvious that pretty much anything else works better.

However, I do insist that, strictly speaking, anarchy is a free market system - it's the reductio ad absurdum of free-market-ism. It's only fair if you're willing to cite North Korea, a totalitarian dictatorship with absolute state power, ie the reductio ad absurdum of state regulation, as an example of such. North Korea also lacks a functional judiciary, a respect for property rights, etc etc.

I take it you at least consider justice & law enforcement to be sectors that benefit from state regulation - and I'd be surprised if there were no other such sectors as well.

To take less extreme examples:

* the (pre-Obamacare, as it's too early to judge the new setup) US healthcare system, which is less regulated than most developed countries', is the most expensive & least effective.

* In the UK, the cheapest & most reliable part of the rail network is the part in Northern Ireland... being the only part that wasn't privatised back in 1993. Everywhere else, costs have grown & reliability has fallen.

...

To try to find some common ground here: you believe in "as little regulation as possible", but that "as little as possible" is not none; I believe in "as much regulation as necessary", but that "as much as necessary" is not totalitarianism. I suspect these beliefs are, in the end, adjoint - opposite approaches to the same fundamental idea, although we may disagree on the details. Does that seem reasonable to you?

Re:A policy of mass destruction by maratd on Thursday March 29, 2012 @09:36PM (#3774100)
> Does that seem reasonable to you?

Actually, I can sum up my beliefs very simply. I am against big things. Big government, big business, big whatever. Big things breed corruption. I don't mind regulation or even government involvement, as long as it's happening on a very local level and I have the freedom to live someplace else.

Re:A policy of mass destruction by EvilTerran on Friday March 30, 2012 @04:58AM (#3775047)
Okay, I can get behind that. I feel a certain amount of government is necessary to stop big business, big gangs (mafia & the like), or whatever from getting out of hand -- but too much government has its own problems. As you say, corruption, whoever gets too big.

Similarly, a certain amount of unionisation helps keep big business under control, but too much leads to the workers holding the populace hostage.

And so on -- balance in all things, really. Although what constitutes "balance" will vary considerably depending on what you're looking at. (Law enforcement needs more regulation than most industries, for instance.)