News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by josephcsible on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:18PM (#37711671)
> I expect any sane network to do the same.

Why? Sane networks shouldn't block anything. Even super dangerous stuff like ports 135-139 and 445 are a morally gray area.

> The idea of uninspectable client traffic is somewhat unhinged, and is already heavily used by malicious actors.

How is privacy unhinged? Isn't that basically the same as the argument that we need to gut the Fourth Amendment because of terrorists and pedophiles?

Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by 4death4 on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:21PM (#37711699)
I don’t think morals factor in to the decision to allow / disallow traffic on a private network. That’s definitely morally neutral and to suggest otherwise is immoral.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by josephcsible on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:42PM (#37711802)
I didn't mean private networks. I meant the ISPs that do that.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by ocdtrekkie on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:43PM (#37711807)
ISPs are also private networks, unless operated by a government entity. And I would absolutely uphold the same expectation from an ISP as an organizational or personal network.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by d-z-m on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:27PM (#37712562)
> And I would absolutely uphold the same expectation from an ISP as an organizational or personal network.

No. ISPs provide internet service to customers who pay them for it. The entire situation is different. The ISPs are under no obligation to break and inspect encrypted traffic. Owners and operators of home and corporate networks have an entirely different(and justifiable) set of concerns.

Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by ocdtrekkie on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:24PM (#37711720)
I mean, considering the top users of many privacy focused apps is, in fact, pedophiles, I have a lot of issue with your absolute dismissiveness of the problem. (Hi, Session users!)

But beyond legal obligations which anyone permitting this over their network would be grossly negligent in meeting, there's simply no way to maintain a secure network with some idea what's going over it. If you want to notice mass exfiltration of private data (something you must do to protect people's privacy), you absolutely want to avoid making it impossible to distinguish different types of traffic and their destinations.

Whether it's a personal network, a corporate network, or a major backbone, it's ethically and morally obligatory to be able to classify behavior at least well enough to stop security issues and illegal activity. Cloudflare doesn't have this problem, or course, as it sees all the decrypted SNIs...

EDIT: In fact, before you go in defensive of this... answer this: Do you think Cloudflare will serve kiwifarms or switter over this? Or is this privacy and freedom strategy really just about centralizing control? Networks are supposed to be decentralized, each with different authorities. Perhaps the narrative of one big open Internet is one sold you to by people who are trying to be the only ones in control.

Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by josephcsible on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:45PM (#37711820)
By that logic, wouldn't every ISP have a moral obligation to MITM all of their customers' traffic? Obviously that's wrong.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by ocdtrekkie on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:53PM (#37711864)
SNI monitoring is a reasonable compromise, and I think a healthy one: Your ISP doesn't need to deep inspect your traffic to Microsoft because it accepts that Microsoft is doing something reasonable with it. It allows delegating authority which at least gives a path for investigation or blocking if necessary without seeking an extreme amount of transient information.

I would say if ECH is implemented the correct response would unfortunately be to MITM it if too many providers implement it to just block it entirely. I suspect large companies won't force it to maintain a wide customer base, and again, any reasonable network operator should just block anyone who does.

ISPs absolutely have all sorts of regulatory needs and network performance reasons to classify traffic. It's an unpopular view, but it's reality. (And I would encourage you to investigate who pays the people telling you otherwise, before someone links Mike Masnick here.)

Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by catiopatio on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:38PM (#37712343)
> SNI monitoring is a reasonable compromise, and I think a healthy one

No, it’s not.

ISPs have no right to know who I am speaking to or why.

Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by ocdtrekkie on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:07PM (#37712488)
I mean you have no right to use their networks either. You generally agree to terms as a condition of use of said networks.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by catiopatio on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:40PM (#37712598)
I didn’t agree to terms that require I provide them with plaintext traffic to analyze.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by madeofpalk on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:28PM (#37712036)
What is a "privacy focused app"?

Is Chrome, which aggressively supports and promotes HTTP a "privacy focused app"?

Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by jmprspret on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:06PM (#37712216)
> Why? Sane networks shouldn't block anything.

Huh? What? Ever had to administer a corporate network for non-tech staff? Malware is everywhere. People are stupid. AND my assumption on a corporate network has always been that you have no expectation of privacy - its a work network, don't use it for personal stuff! Pretty simple.

Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by josephcsible on Saturday September 30, 2023 @02:12AM (#37713149)
If it's really a corporate network, then the company will own the endpoints and can do the inspection there.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by 3np on Saturday September 30, 2023 @05:30AM (#37713907)
Not meaningfully so with ECH, the whole point of this subthread.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by capitainenemo on Saturday September 30, 2023 @08:19AM (#37714751)
Corporate networks often use MITM master certs that employee browsers must accept.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by josephcsible on Saturday September 30, 2023 @10:59AM (#37716057)
ECH only makes network-level monitoring harder. Monitoring on the endpoint is still just as easy.
Re:Encrypted Client Hello – the last puzzle piece to privacy by Aaargh20318 on Saturday September 30, 2023 @07:15AM (#37714356)
> my assumption on a corporate network has always been that you have no expectation of privacy

That certainly isn’t true in the EU. You cannot spy on employees computers without a cause.