News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now What?

I am a 24 year old guy who is the co-founder and CTO of a 1.5 Million dollar web / mobile software services company based out of Mumbai. Most of our clients are from the US. This was my first US visa interview and I got rejected.

The consul officer asked me how could I become a CTO a such an young age and it does not make any sense to her.

I was asked only four questions by the Consul Officer:

Officer: What do you do

Answer: I am a software developer and currently working as a CTO at XYZ

Officer: What is your age

Answer: 24

Officer: You are too young to be CTO. Whatever you just said does not make any sense. How long is your visit?

Answer: 1 month

Officer: Who will sponsor

Answer: My client is sponsoring my visit (I had relevant documents but she did not want to see them when I handed over to her)

Now I am confused that even if I re-apply, I will be asked the same question again right? Any suggestions from someone who might have faced a similar situtation earlier?

( 17 comments | 19 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by TheMegalomaniac on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:59PM (#3794545)
Having been through this process once and hoping to never have to do it again - my sympathies.

I have one piece of advice for next time. The visa interviewers are usually rushed and trying to move on quickly. Slow them down and address their concerns.

You response to Officer: You are too young to be CTO. Whatever you just said does not make any sense. How long is your visit? Answer: 1 month

is not enough. The officer mentioned a concern but didn't phrase it as a question. Nevertheless you need to address it head on and put their doubts to rest. Give them the full story on it.

Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by cgshaw on Thursday March 29, 2012 @08:01AM (#3770705)
I'm an attorney. I don't know a whole lot about immigration policy, but I know some fantastic immigration attorneys in the Boston area that I can put you in contact with. I'm sure there is a solution to this that won't have you hung up too long.

My email is Chris at LexSpot dot com.

Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by ohashi on Thursday March 29, 2012 @12:15PM (#3771686)
As an American, I am truly sorry. Depending on the size of embassy/consulate you may have lost the which person sees your case lottery. If you could find someone else there to talk to about the situation it might help. Also perhaps try going to the American Chamber of Commerce. I believe they help business people get visas (although you may need to become a member).
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by dkd903 on Friday March 30, 2012 @02:41PM (#3777457)
Thanks for the suggestion ohashi. I will give a 2nd shot at the visa interview. If they reject me again, I will probably approach the American Chamber of Commerce then!
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by Tzunamitom on Thursday March 29, 2012 @09:06AM (#3770884)
This is just one of many examples of how the global immigration system is completely failing to stay relevant to today's globalised society. I'm a global citizen...If I want to go on holiday, or a business trip, I don't want to have to apply for a Visa weeks before. I don't want to have to carry a physical passport about with me that expires when I have too many stamps. As a country, all you really care about is that I'm not a security risk, I'm not an illegal immigration risk, I'm not a criminal, and I'll pay whatever taxes are due. I'm ok with that, but surely there's a better way for both of us?
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by michaelochurch on Thursday March 29, 2012 @09:43AM (#3771024)
The problem is not the "global immigration system". The EU has extremely liberal policies with other EU countries, for example. It's the U.S. immigration system. It sucks balls.
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by Tzunamitom on Thursday March 29, 2012 @10:13AM (#3771140)
The EU (or at least the Schengen countries) are getting there, but there are plenty of other countries that are problematic as well as the US. I'm British, so the EU is easy (still need a physical passport though), the US isn't too bad for tourism, but was painful to get a work visa for. I live in the Middle East, and love travelling to India which means a mountain of paperwork and a 3-month freeze-out each time I go. I could visit east Africa for a weekend on a whim, but I never do because of the visa lead-times. It strikes me that the best thing some countries could do for development is streamline their visa processes.
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by _delirium on Thursday March 29, 2012 @08:23PM (#3773898)
The U.S. is among the worse ones, but the E.U. is not great either if you're an Indian national trying to get a visa that allows business activity.
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by michaelpinto on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:19AM (#3770580)
Answer: talk to a lawyer who knows the ropes
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by dkd903 on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:51AM (#3770674)
Thanks for your reply michael. But can you please elaborate how will consulting a lawyer help my case?
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by ra on Thursday March 29, 2012 @09:07AM (#3770888)
You were treated wrongly.

A good lawyer who specialises in immigration will know what to do next.

Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by michaelochurch on Thursday March 29, 2012 @09:46AM (#3771034)
Pretty much any foreign national who wants to do business in or with the U.S. needs to have an immigration lawyer. It will save you money. Lawyers are expensive but, trust me, a good one will save you money and hassle.
[deleted]
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by dkd903 on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:50AM (#3770673)
Thanks for the reply. And Glad to know I am talking to the Nasdaq CTO :-) Anyways, I thing the consul officer did not have much idea about how tech companies function and she must have expected a CEO, CTO to be an aged guy. In that case, is she not aware of Facebook, Pinterest, Twitter???
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by 46Bit on Saturday March 31, 2012 @10:24PM (#3782398)
An immigration worker isn't likely to have heard of Pinterest. They've probably heard of Facebook & Twitter but they're likely not entirely aware of the ages of people involved.
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by paulsutter on Thursday March 29, 2012 @02:08PM (#3772293)
Use an attorney for important requests such as visas. Immigration employees are overworked and underpaid, and sometimes rush through their decisions.

An attorney will help ensure that you have all the right papers in order, and give you important advice for the visa process. Now that you have one rejection on your file, it is especially important to get it right next time.

Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by true_religion on Thursday March 29, 2012 @11:20AM (#3771433)
The ridiculous thing is that he's only 7 years younger than the CTO of Facebook, and a mere 3 years younger than the CEO.
Re:Ask HN: Denied US Visa As I am too young to be a CTO, Now... by mmountford on Friday March 30, 2012 @02:24PM (#3777355)
#SiliconValleyProblems