News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by shwaj on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:15PM (#37694300)
How do we know it’s gravely immoral? I’m guessing according to some interpretation of some religious text?

Otherwise, what is immoral about a couple using their own sperm and egg to conceive a child that they otherwise would not have had? I suppose you could say there are many children who need to be adopted, but that reasoning also applies to the decision to have children without IVF.

Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by Muromec on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:29PM (#37694541)
It's immoral in the same way abortion is immoral. If you subscribe to idea that 1) human life is sacred and 2) life starts from the moment egg is fertilized, then both abortion and IVF are immoral.

The actual reason religious people are mad at IVF is undefensible in somewhat secular society -- i.e. creating life is domain of god, thus fertilizing those embryos in the first place is bad. But with IVF there is a straw to hang on -- it's never just one egg, it's one (or two) eggs used and the rest discarded after fertilization. Which you can kinda defend as murder.

Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:55PM (#37694901)
> life starts from the moment egg is fertilized

That is very much a religious idea and not something universally held. I certainly don't believe a jar of fertilized embryos is deserving of any special respect.

Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by Muromec on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:39PM (#37695501)
You can in theory hold such belief without being religious, but yes of course it is. The problem is -- you need to draw a line somewhere, otherwise sacred act of creation isn't sacred anymore, it's just a bunch of phenomena you can apply science to and reason about separetely. Which is of course bad.
Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:19PM (#37697241)
> otherwise sacred act of creation isn't sacred anymore, it's just a bunch of phenomena you can apply science to and reason about separetely. Which is of course bad.

"Which is of course bad" - all these people thinking their personal opinions are universal, unwavering truths...

Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by lamontcg on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:00PM (#37698035)
Or there never existed a "sacred act of creation" and its always been something we could apply science and reason to. Which is of course entirely natural.
Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by justrealist on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:11PM (#37695131)
When you really dig into it, nobody actually believes this. If there was a burning building with a cooler of 10 embryos and 1 baby, and they could only save one, every single one would grab the baby.

But it's the only clean line they can draw about when human life becomes human life, so they nominally stick to it even though they don't hold by any of the logical consequences of doing so.

Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by tivert on Friday September 29, 2023 @01:52AM (#37699755)
>> life starts from the moment egg is fertilized

> That is very much a religious idea and not something universally held.

How so? From an entirely secular standpoint, it's the moment a distinct individual life starts (e.g. viable new organism with its own unique DNA).

> I certainly don't believe a jar of fertilized embryos is deserving of any special respect.

And that's supposed to prove what? Someone else might believe a child who has not yet met some arbitrary developmental milestone as not deserving of any special respect. And that's not hypothetical, infanticide has been common in many cultures up to and including recent times.

Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by anon291 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:25PM (#37694458)
> I’m guessing according to some interpretation of some religious text?

Alternatively, an interpretation of Aristotelianism and Platonism. There's this weird presumption that religious people mainly use texts, despite the fact that the largest denomination of the largest religion in the world, Catholicism, often ignores texts when even considering many modern moral qualms. There seems to be a real desire to reduce modern religions to some kind of magic cult, despite the fact that a lot of modern religions give great weight to secular philosophy.

In particular, the Catholic objection to IVF is rooted chiefly in Aristotle's concept of the telos, which is pretty secular. Any text in the Bible that goes along with that is just icing on the cake, not really the main objection.

Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by shwaj on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:22PM (#37695295)
Interesting. Can you elaborate on the relevance of the telos here?
Re:Japanese scientists race to create human eggs and sperm i... by anon291 on Saturday September 30, 2023 @12:15PM (#37716871)
Tried responding earlier but HN is in the habit of blocking me.

Basically... The telos of sex is reproduction. To separate reproduction from sex renders sex meaningless, and thus irrational from an aristotelian perspective.

The typical objection is that sex is also for pleasure. However, Aristotle considers base pleasures like sex not worth pursuing.

Now another typical objection here is that this could mean that ivf should be pursued while we don't have sex. This is I suppose where some religion may come in since Christianity typically sees sex within marriage as a good to be pursued. Nevertheless, I've not heard any modern argument that says we should eliminate sex and sexual desire and pursue only ivf.

So basically, separating sex from reproduction renders sex meaningless and irrational.