News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kids these days: the quality of new Wikipedia editors ove... by simonbrown on Wednesday March 28, 2012 @03:39PM (#3767970)
Are you sure showing title bars isn't allowed? Almost all screenshots on Wikipedia include them, even for open source software. e.g.:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Firefox11.png

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Winscp_screenshot.png

Re:Kids these days: the quality of new Wikipedia editors ove... by neilk on Wednesday March 28, 2012 @10:10PM (#3769324)
Here's the full deal:

If you store your screenshot on English Wikipedia, non-free imagery is allowed when there's a rationale, which in this case would be "fair use". That's the decision of that community. I think you could store that screenshot as is. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Fair_use_screenshots

If you use Wikimedia Commons (a common media backend for all the Wikipedias and other projects), there are no exceptions; it's all free, all the time. Fair use is NOT allowed. The guidelines are here: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Screenshots

On Commons, in theory, title bars and other OS windowing widgetry are okay if and only if it's a fully open source operating system.

In practice, most Commons volunteers are not insane, and don't care. I don't know of any case where Microsoft has sued someone for a screenshot that included a title bar, where there was no intent to deceive people or otherwise misuse their work.

But, Wikipedia and Wikimedia Commons tend to attract and enable a kind of person that values extreme consistency and rule-following over all other considerations. Someone who makes it their mission to eliminate all screenshots with titlebars probably won't be reined in.

Re:Kids these days: the quality of new Wikipedia editors ove... by redthrowaway on Wednesday March 28, 2012 @03:52PM (#3768036)
I've had images with them included deleted before, which is why I modified the golly screenshot. To be perfectly honest, I'm not sure what's allowed, and I doubt many people who are not active commons contributors do, either.
Re:Kids these days: the quality of new Wikipedia editors ove... by flomo on Wednesday March 28, 2012 @05:03PM (#3768331)
Some editors went through and deleted a massive number of useful Mac/Windows screenshots several years ago, but I don't think there's ever been an actual policy stating these screenshots were a legal issue.

Also, the GPL only covers code, not program output (under normal circumstances), so I don't see how it applies to screenshots anyway.

Re:Kids these days: the quality of new Wikipedia editors ove... by redthrowaway on Wednesday March 28, 2012 @05:26PM (#3768446)
>the GPL only covers code, not program output (under normal circumstances), so I don't see how it applies to screenshots anyway.

It's an interesting question. The drawing of the window is, I would argue, indistinguishable from the code. It's like saying the HTML, CSS, and images on a site are GPL'd, but screenshots aren't. The rest of the program output is merely algorithmic, and thus not subject to copyright.

Re:Kids these days: the quality of new Wikipedia editors ove... by flomo on Wednesday March 28, 2012 @06:56PM (#3768778)
This discussion is wandering off into la-la land. The GPL isn't designed to cover things like websites or bitmapped images. There's other 'free' content-oriented licenses which should be used instead.
Re:Kids these days: the quality of new Wikipedia editors ove... by bane on Wednesday March 28, 2012 @05:20PM (#3768415)
It doesn't matter, the application of the "rules" (read: guidelines) is so arbitrary and capricious as to be entirely meaningless and unpredictable.