There has certainly been more sticker price growth than real price growth due to scholarships/aid but this article is the first I've read to assert that the real price growth isn't there. And I definitely know many people who paid the full sticker price at elite schools (they were lucky to have families who can afford it, so not too much pity necessary).
Here's an older but very good article around why colleges raise prices to levels they know they'll need to subsidize: https://www.conradbastable.com/essays/the-uncharity-of-colle...
These subsidies were for sellers of college, not for the buyers of college. In fact, it was the students subsidizing the school and beneficiaries of the school such as the staff and school’s vendors, via the students’ future income, underwritten by US taxpayers.
There’s basically no reason they should have a say at all about what someone else wants to do with their own property.
It’s also not like there’s nowhere else on earth to put a school campus either. They’d hardly be the first school with multiple campuses that are separated if they didn’t insist on building it where they currently are.
Telling people what they could use their land for (within building code) is only legal in the US because the SCOTUS said it was legal to in order to keep Black people out of neighborhoods. It should be unconstitutional, and would be if not for racism!
The idea is to put pressure on the locals - if you don't shape up we will move. A significant number probably like the college nearby overall.
Aka inflation.
Let's consider another example. Consider that security situation of your country worsens and the government suddenly needs more grenades. So they start to buy them at expense of something else, like school lunches. Are you claiming that the market supply won't try to match the demand?
If it's true, then screw the free market. It's a bad economic system, if it can't do this. The problem is markets are treated as an article of faith rather than tools, so people don't want to admit their shortcomings.
The free market is not an article of faith, it has been tested and proved worthy countless times.
> don't want to admit their shortcomings
I do admit the shortcomings of the free market.
No, I don't need to assume that. Although of course short-term, production is a zero sum proposition.
> I do admit the shortcomings of the free market.
Maybe, but you don't admit it in this case (to provide access to university education), otherwise you wouldn't try to blame the government.
What should have government done, if it wanted to allow people get more education, and avoid the market failure?
I don't buy that.
> What should have government done, if it wanted to allow people get more education, and avoid the market failure?
Before, say, 1980, the US built the best university system in the world without government subsidy. After then, the universities became dependent on government subsidy, and the government began all sorts of regulations on them in exchange for the subsidy.
Before 1980, college was affordable. A student could pay for it with a full time summer job and a part time job after school. I know this because I did it.
I'm not asking rhetorically, by the way. I really don't know why "regular" colleges (besides the ones specifically targeting veterans) didn't drastically raise prices to soak up the G.I. Bill money.
A few years ago I tried to find historical tuition data but only found it online for a couple schools, Stanford and some state school that I don't remember.
For Stanford what I found is that a plot of log(tuition) vs time [1] for the last 100 years is almost linear. I think I got similar results for the state school.
In both cases the government provided massive subsidies in the form of loans and tax breaks.
That does wonders for the demand side. However the government didn’t find a way to increase supply (esp of the good stuff) at the same rate nor did they find a way to prevent the excess profits generated from falling into the same few hands.
So what did we get? A seemingly endless cycle of price growth.