This time you're on the living side of the equation. How would you have felt if someone made the same argument for Nazi Germany?
Victims of those weapon sales had wholeheartedly agreed.
I don't think its a bad thing that the rest of the world has weapons that can't compete with the west, as a westerner I think this is a good thing.
The end justifying the means also needs some justified ends to demonstrate that the means were tolerable. In Saudi's case we've seen little signs of that. It's still one of the world's most repressive police states. It uses Western weapons in wars of aggression. It's happy to murder people in foreign consulates. There doesn't seem any sign of this improving.
Selling arms to Saudi stops a flow of cash to Iran and Russia, but we're just propping up one horrible regime with the supposed excuse of weakening others. This just seems like an excuse to make some cash.
> eventually the US selling weapons to Saudi Arabia will be viewed similarly to the US selling weapons to Germany
And where are the signs that Saudi Arabia is moving towards being a liberal democracy like Germany?
1. The US wants Saudi Arabia to become a liberal democracy (the end)
2. The US thinks that doing this can achieve that end (the means)
I see no reason to accept (2) and moreover no reason to accept even (1).
In your view, the best way is no way, then, given the state of endless war in the middle east a long time...
I don’t think that “more countries holding more weapons” is the thing that stops/prevents wars.
And I think people have to remember that cyber weapons are very asymmetrical. It is akin to nukes/bio/chem/nerve weapons, not just conventional weapons.
It is almost as though something happened in 1979 that shifted the government.
We really don't know if the war would have happened if the Shah hadn't been overthrown. As far as I can tell, Iraq thought Iran would be weak due to the revolution and took advantage of the situation. If the Shah stayed in power and the US continued to provide weapons, Iraq quite possibly would not have attacked.
To me this looks like the best way to bring other countries "into the fold" as well as bring peace to the middle east, until eventually the US selling weapons to Saudi Arabia will be viewed similarly to the US selling weapons to Germany.
Maybe I'm just naive, but I think in most cases applying "friendly pressure" is more useful than force, and I mostly agree with your take that selling cyberweapons should be treated similarly to selling conventional weapons.