News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by fguerraz on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:24AM (#37657669)
They should think about switching on 5G as well.

The UK being one of the worst countries for 5G deployment, with totally fake coverage (shows the 5G logo but connected to LTE).

  - "On average, 5G users spent 10.1% of the time connected to a 5G network." Ofcom, July 2023
https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0018/264600/...
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by have_faith on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:46AM (#37657888)
There's a busy area down the road from me that I consistently get a couple bars of 5G signal but the internet is unusable in a 200 metre radius. Sucks for all the local businesses around.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by petercooper on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:29AM (#37658302)
Are you on a network that runs its own infrastructure or an MVNO? I've experienced the same thing a lot, especially on 4G in busy holiday spots, and have been told that apparently MVNO traffic is heavily deprioritised versus that of the primary carrier.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by have_faith on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @10:46AM (#37660205)
I'm on O2. The "busy" area is just a normal mini high street. Nothing out of the ordinary.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by gumballindie on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:46AM (#37657889)
> with totally fake coverage

In my region, maps shows full coverage with "excellent" outdoor signal, but I get at most two to three lines on my phone. It's basically a scam.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by fguerraz on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:08AM (#37658070)
The amount of "bars" is irrelevant. You need to check if you're actually connected to 5G and that's very well hidden. (##4636## on android. Anything but "connected" for "NR State" means you're actually connected to 5G)
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by sp332 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:52AM (#37657943)
I thought 5G was mostly about managing congestion. What's the improvement over 4G for most users?
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by rsynnott on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:28AM (#37658292)
I just got a 5G-supporting phone yesterday, and had previously thought the same thing. Then I did a speed test and got 600Mbit/sec.

To be honest, LTE was mostly _fine_, but this seems to be generally noticeably better.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by thom on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:33AM (#37658350)
Yeah, I thought 5G was a gimmick until I found myself somewhere with proper 5G speeds and downloaded Witcher 3 onto my SteamDeck through my phone. It was nice briefly living in the future.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by fguerraz on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:05AM (#37658045)
Well, I've been to Portugal recently, Porto to be precise, they have actual 5G which you can actually connect to, and despite roaming and the amount of tourists, it was night and day: everything loaded instantly, not a single hickup.

Back in the UK, I spent last weekend in London, 5G logo always on but not actually connected. I could not even send a message when I was in busy areas.

So yes, it helps with congestion, you just don't realise how congested the network is until you've tried the real thing.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by bananapub on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:17AM (#37658161)
> Back in the UK, I spent last weekend in London, 5G logo always on but not actually connected

on Three? They're famously garbage. I wouldn't suggest anything other than EE or - distant second - Vodafone in London.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by fguerraz on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:12PM (#37661474)
EE
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by edf13 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:11AM (#37658106)
The issue here could well be the backhaul... just because you can get 5g to the cell tower doesn't ensure you will have a fast connection from the tower to the core network.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by garblegarble on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:09AM (#37658082)
>The UK being one of the worst countries for 5G deployment, with totally fake coverage (shows the 5G logo but connected to LTE).

I read the linked PDF and did some searching but I didn't see in what instances networks use a 5G Logo for LTE (although I do recall hearing about something like that in the past)... could you give some more detail?

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by Nux on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:01AM (#37658649)
5G is currently NSA (not standalone), it can't be used without 4G/LTE. It needs a 4G connection to anchor itself on, to act as a supplementary band. This is also known as ENDC. This is an intermediary step to proper full blown, standalone 5G which will probably happen in a few years.

It's often the case that when connected to a 4G site which can act as a master or anchor to 5G bands (ie it advertises ENDC capability) your average smartphone will show you the 5G icon, but in reality you are only connected to 4G/LTE and there may not even be a 5G site nearby to aggregate.. This is probably why it's called "fake".

It is indeed very cheeky of the operators or manufacturers to show 5G when 5G is not actually in use. Marketing...

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by tentacleuno on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:11AM (#37658103)
We're very technologically backwards. Just look at the FTTP rollout, which has now been delayed to 2030.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by graemep on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:38AM (#37658404)
BT Openreach also seems to be getting away with an unjustified price structure too. ADSL established a precedent for upload speeds being far slower than download speeds, and this has been continued with FTTC and is being continued with FTTP.

There are a lot of good uses cases for faster uploads (backup to cloud, home servers, maybe things like video conferencing) and much less gain from faster downloads (except allowing websites to be even more bloated and more HD video to watch on smartphones)

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by flumpcakes on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:19AM (#37658174)
What's worse is that FTTP is the worst kind... time shared GPON. Not true FTTP in my book (a single fibre per premise back to the exchange).
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by Lio on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:51AM (#37658522)
Who's "we" in this context? Are you talking about a particular telco you work for?

FTTP was rolled out where I live by several providers almost 2 years ago. I don't live anywhere particularly urban.

I think we were at the back of the queue for this with FTTP available in UK cities for a few years now.

(For the avoidance of confusion I mean actual FTTP and not fibre to a cab/twisted pair to premises).

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by tentacleuno on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:38PM (#37661878)
> Who's "we" in this context? Are you talking about a particular telco you work for?

If that were the case, I would have said so.

I'm referring to the UK in general. The FTTP roll-out has been delayed to 2030 (which is, if I remember correctly, 5 years ahead of the original date).

The best I've ever had is Virgin with DOCSIS, which is an unfortunate situation -- in that space, you quite literally have no competition amongst providers. Surprised the regulator hasn't done anything about it.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by Lio on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:50PM (#37664923)
FTTP is already available in lots of places. I have a choice of two providers right now neither of which is Virgin.

So to say that FTTP is not going to be rolled out until 2030 doesn’t make sense unless you are talking about a specific provider in a specific place.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by tentacleuno on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:35PM (#37666094)
I'm referring to Openreach, which, according to their own statistics[0], cover 28.6m houses in the UK.

I'm unsure if you're being pedantic, as both the roll-out and Openreach are fairly well known here.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by Lio on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @02:54AM (#37671077)
No, I'm not being pedantic. If you mean just Openreach, just say Openreach, I did ask.

You're talking as if BT was still some wing of the government and the only ones allowed invest in UK network infrastructure.

This isn't 1995, they might be the biggest but they're not the only player.

As mentioned, City Fibre[1] and Trooli[2] have their own networks and there are others.

FTTP has already been rolled out in many parts of the UK, so saying "UK FTTP roll out has been delayed until 2030" is just not true.

I'm in the UK and using FTTP right now.

-

1. https://cityfibre.com/

2. https://www.trooli.com/

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by Gud on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @01:34AM (#37670596)
Not sure why this is getting down voted. I'm in the UK right now for work and it seems to me the country is riddled with bureaucracy. An army of bureaucrats making sure the actual doers has to bend over backwards to follow some ridiculous rules.

I am not surprised the 5G roll out is taking time in the UK.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by tentacleuno on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @06:25PM (#37682248)
Agreed, and not sure either; the 5G rollout is another great example. In most of the houses I've been in, you're lucky to have cable (for DOCSIS). Most are stuck on ADSL, with providers selling misleading "superfast fibre" products that, in comparison to the rest of the world, are not super fast in any sense of the word.

If you look at BT, they offer FTTP but a lot of the time you have pitiful upload rates (symmetric 1Gbps would be nice), like 1Gbps/100Mbps.

There's a lot of bureaucracy over here, which slows technological advances down. Couple that with the very outdated architecture we have over here (we've pushed ADSL to its limits), it's quite sad.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by Nux on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:30AM (#37658307)
There is a technical reason for that, 5G in UK (and 99% of the world) is NSA, ie not stand alone, it acts as a supplementary band, anchored in LTE. Your phone/router will only aggregate this 5G band under load, most of the time there is little load so 5G is not needed, it is also a power optimization issue, as 5G processing requires more battery.