News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by jacquesm on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:16AM (#37657603)
I'm going to bet on an extension once they realize how much infra is still on 3G. Power, water, gas, sewage, lots of telemetry and control still uses it. That stuff has a design lifetime of 30 years or more and replacing it or parts of it is very costly.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by fguerraz on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:43AM (#37657846)
One of the main excuses for not deploying 5G at the moment is the alleged lack of access to "urban furniture". More precisely , they don't want to pay. Basically they want the people to pay for it with their taxes and the rack up the profits with contracts.

I'm sure this has something to do with that, it would be cheaper for them to replace 3G infrastructure with 5G.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by Nux on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:25AM (#37658254)
Number one reason 5G deployments are hampered in UK are the nimbys and the anti-5G crazies. Absolutely loads of council applications are turned down due to complaints from locals.. Some of which are not even local at all.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by jacquesm on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:25PM (#37665340)
Same here, the COVID thing really brought the madness to the surface, all kinds of complot theory pushers have found very fertile ground and suddenly there is an army of tin foil hatters prepared to commit crimes to put their worries to rest, such as burning mobile telecommunications infrastructure.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by helsinkiandrew on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:49AM (#37657915)
They've had a few years notice though.

2018: BT Aims to Switch Off 3G by 2022: https://www.lightreading.com/2g-3g-4g/bt-aims-to-switch-off-...

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by jacquesm on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:57AM (#37657981)
Yes, that's the point: it didn't work. It won't work again, right now (or in January). Until the cost is manageable, which I think we'll see in a decade or so. But right now I'd bet against it. They might actually go through with it in some remote location and claim victory, or, alternatively they might do it and then roll it back quietly. But 3G isn't going anywhere because some interests trump others. These messages are basically an attempt to convince their paymasters that they are running an efficient ship and to - hopefully - urge some 3G users to finally migrate. But lots of them will simply not be able to.

Infrastructure is always longer lived than it is intended. Next time you're in a London tube station have a look at the cabling and signalling hardware and take a guess at when it was made. 3G gear is brand new by comparison and just as critical to the parties using it.

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by helsinkiandrew on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:32AM (#37658343)
> Until the cost is manageable

But isn't that the problem - removing 3G will likely save or make BT money - the cost is born by the companies that have installed devices with 3G.

The turn off of 3G does look a lot more likely now (although could still slip):

https://www.ofcom.org.uk/phones-telecoms-and-internet/inform...

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by raverbashing on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:01AM (#37658014)
For real, I've always though such a switch to 5G was premature after the investment poured in 4G.

Why? Are people tiktoking that much to require an upgrade? Especially one that seems to break a lot of backwards compatibility

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by snickerbockers on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:27AM (#37658275)
I've never understood why anybody cares about 5G, what do people do on their phones where bandwidth is a bottleneck? 4G is clearly fast enough for video streaming at resolutions and bitrates that matter for small screens. Online gaming tends to get bottlenecked on lately moreso than bandwidth and anybody who takes it seriously will be playing on consoles and PC. I don't think it's unreasonable to assume most filesharing happens on PC also. So what's the point?
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by Shish2k on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:42AM (#37658447)
With sufficiently fast mobile internet, there is no more need to be digging and drilling to pull cables through roads and buildings

(I’ve been using a 4G/5G dongle as my primary internet access for the past 4 years because the council is perpetually “3-6 months away” from bringing a fibre connection to my street. 4G was pretty painful, but 5G is actually just-about-tolerable by my gamer-nerd standards, and the less-technical friends and family who visit my house don’t even notice. Maybe the 20ms pings with occasional 100ms spikes is too much for professional-level FPS competitions, but I’m happy to chill out in the silver leagues so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯)

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by rsynnott on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:33AM (#37658359)
In congested areas 5G should provide significant benefit. I was in London a while ago (using an old-ish 4G-only phone); in busy areas it's really not good, at all.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by jacquesm on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:09AM (#37658080)
My phone is capable of 3G (and 2G as well, but I haven't used that in a long time) and I've used it all over Europe. It is funny because sometimes I have bad coverage for newer bands and protocols but 3G always saves the day in those cases. In Latin America it was quite useful as well, especially rural areas.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by dbbk on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:20AM (#37658182)
If you turn off 3G it lets them repurpose that spectrum for 4G/5G is my understanding
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by snakeyjake on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:08PM (#37661427)
>Are people tiktoking that much to require an upgrade?

Yes. Total global wireless data traffic went from 58 exabytes per month in 2019 to 154 exabytes per month in 2022 and is predicted to surpass 326 exabytes per month by 2025.

4G cannot handle this. 5G probably cannot handle this rate of growth for much longer.

https://www.ericsson.com/en/reports-and-papers/mobility-repo...

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by Nux on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:16AM (#37658158)
Most of that is on 2G.. which is why 2G isn't getting killed yet.
Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by benj111 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:22AM (#37658210)
Yes. My first thought was smart meters.

I'm confused though because this [1] gives different timelines.

https://www.smartme.co.uk/smets-2.html

Re:BT confirms it's switching off 3G in UK from Jan next year by rsynnott on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:31AM (#37658330)
> Power, water, gas, sewage, lots of telemetry and control still uses it.

In the UK specifically? In Ireland at least, most of that stuff seems to be on GPRS; my impression is that it's always been assumed that 3G's days were numbered, so the infra stuff got left on 2G (the GPRS network seems unkillable).