News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by ehnto on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:34AM (#37654865)
It has been fascinating and demoralizing to watch monetization roll out. To younger generations like my brother, they don't know any different, it's just part if gaming for them.

But at least something like aesthetic loot crates are a sideshow to the actual game. Some games are good at keeping the separate and you can understand that it's just how they choose to fund the game. When the whole game is just a loot crate/gambling mechanism it's just a sad outcome.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by beebmam on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:04AM (#37655055)
If people are dumb enough to consentually waste time and money on casinos, they deserve to lose their time and money. Some might say the government should intervene; I personally don't care.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by peterlk on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:21AM (#37655138)
> If people are dumb enough to consentually waste time and money on casinos, they deserve to lose their time and money.

I find this to be a very naive perspective. It’s not how addiction works, and even people who want to stop sometimes cannot. And even if you buy into the belief that we shouldn’t help them, what about their kids? What about the communities around them that are worse for having addicts who are pouring money from their jobs into a black hole?

> I personally don't care.

I’m sorry to hear that, and I hope you can change your mind one day. We’re all going to die one day, and life is better if we care about each other

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by spondylosaurus on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:12AM (#37655565)
IRL casinos employ all kinds of tactics to get people in the door, too. Cheap food, "free" gifts, all in the hopes that you'll cave and start gambling once you're in. And then they have their claws in you.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by Ensorceled on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:32AM (#37656699)
Yes. IRL casinos are also bad.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by tetris11 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:35AM (#37656731)
Everybody and their dog has a vice of some kind. If casinos knew what your vice was, they would serve it up to you with a pretty bow and tell you that the first hit is free.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by squeaky-clean on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:21AM (#37655140)
One problem is a lot of those people spending that money (or should I say their parents money) are not old enough to be allowed into a casino or otherwise gamble. But since it's a reward of bytes and not dollars it's currently legally okay to take advantage of a child the way a casino takes advantage of adults.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by efitz on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:10AM (#37655086)
In a casino, you know what you’re there for and what you’re up against. Gaming commissions have curbed many of the worst abuses with inspections, posted odds, etc.

With mobile gaming you have a free for all that is intentionally exploiting the same neuroanatomy of addiction, but it’s wrapped up in pretty pixels and you can do it anywhere, privately. The industry is too big for gaming commission type controls to work.

I think that mobile game monetization is populated by morally deficient actors and we should consider banning the whole thing.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by anonymous_sorry on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:08AM (#37655538)
In a meatspace casino, if someone shows you 4 face down cards, asks you to pick one, and then turns them all up to reveal 3 prizes and 1 "you lose" card, you can be fairly sure you had a 25% chance of losing.

If the croupier used sleight of hand or secret e-ink cards to turn your card into the "you lose" card after you'd picked it, that would be fraud.

The dark patterns and dopamine manipulation are bad enough, but isn't it fraud in this case? They're using a visual metaphor that is a straight-up lie.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by meheleventyone on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:13AM (#37656052)
In that specific case sure, but Casino slot machines do a loooooooot to present distorted odds.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by kawhah on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:50AM (#37656862)
But they do it within, often, quite tight regulation on game mechanics. People compare loot boxes to slot machines, but often loot boxes are allowed to be much more manipulative than would be allowed for a casino slot machine in many jurisdictions. For example, slots can juice the number of near misses (two cherries, and the third reel has a cherry that's just offcenter), compared to what would arise naturally if the reels were independent. But they might not be allowed to vastly increase the likelihood of near misses just as the player gets to the last few spins before inserting more cash (each spin has to be essentially the same game). Mobile game monetization does stuff like this all the time.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by tetris11 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:09AM (#37655083)
If the main audience is the uninformed or the desperate, isn't that just predatory behaviour
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by keithalewis on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:15AM (#37655113)
Do you mean people should be held personally accountable for their actions? Next thing you know we might be living in a country full of responsible citizens. /s
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by pjc50 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:28AM (#37656164)
People probably should be held personally responsible for defrauding punters, yes.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by ehnto on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:54AM (#37656369)
They are accountable, they lose their money just like you'd expect. But I don't think we should let companies get away with exploiting people either. They have the upper hand, when it comes to exploiting psychology of the everyman.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by keithalewis on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:50AM (#37657367)
Like advertisers do? Every day. All day long. We might be in agreement about the pernicious effect those have on society. Education is the antidote, not more feckless laws.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by efitz on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:06AM (#37655066)
>something like aesthetic loot crates are a sideshow

No, they are very much a part of the experience. The anticipation of the reward and the tension build while the opening animation plays is an addiction mechanism. This is why we wrap presents and why “blind bags” are so successful (and also why toddlers will watch “surprise egg” videos for hours).

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by spondylosaurus on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:10AM (#37655545)
Aesthetic loot crates are for sure still predatory/addictive, but I think the point here is that they don't directly impact the core gameplay experience. You can still get fragged by a player who's wearing the default skin (and sometimes that's a flex in itself...).
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by Semaphor on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:50AM (#37655883)
> the tension build while the opening animation plays is an addiction mechanism

Is this why BG3 has this extremely annoying and unskippable dice-rolling animation (technically, the rolling of the dice is the only thing you can actually skip)? Because other people somehow enjoy this?

It’s so bad, that the dice thing popping up induces a feeling of dread and annoyance in me.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by meheleventyone on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:08AM (#37656021)
That’s there half because it’s a tabletop system and half otherwise there is a break in causality. Just having a random chance of success or failure isn’t very obvious and you don’t see near misses and so on. For most people showing the action is more satisfying.

The underlying system comes from D&D so is full of quite crunchy randomness where results are usually rolled in front of everyone so you get a much more social experience and failure isn’t quite so bad (usually).

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by Semaphor on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:16AM (#37656072)
My main complaint about BG3 is actually how far they changed it from D&D. My favorite games are owlcat’s two Pathfinder games which is a tabletop system far crunchier than the streamlined D&D 5e.

But you are missing what I said. The information is great, the unskippable animations are not.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by meheleventyone on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:23AM (#37656128)
Yeah I misunderstood where the dread and annoyance came from, apologies!
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by jacksontheel on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:50PM (#37662116)
At least on PC, you can click a couple times to avoid the animation. I tend to when the outcome is pretty likely (trying to roll above 10 with a +8 modifier for example) but the anticipation is exciting to my monkey brain if it's a tougher roll.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by Semaphor on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:59PM (#37662288)
Not all of it, it has about a second before and after that are not skippable. All I do is spam clicks during those damn dice-rolls.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by jacksontheel on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:26PM (#37664608)
Especially bad when trying to pick a lock ten times in a row haha
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by Semaphor on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @12:30AM (#37670161)
Which luckily rarely happens once you get the "advantage on sleight of hand" gloves.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by ehnto on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:38AM (#37656233)
I very much understand loot crates, I meant a side show to the rest of the game rather than tightly integrated into the gameplay. CS:GO for example, some people take the loot crates very seriously sure, but that's on them. The actual game of counter-strike doesn't change based the crates sideshow.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by numpad0 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:33AM (#37656706)
On that aesthetic, and promised satisfaction - I once read some offhand BBS post that catharsis works slightly differently in gambling and other entertainment, such that, the anticipation phase is built up the same, but the release phase is crippled. This is so that the player is only partially satisfied and left frustrated in seek for a deserved full gratification, which closes the loop.

One clear demonstration of this I have seen is the lootbox screen in a pay-once game Vampire Survivors[1], which developer has background in casino software. This one is rather absurd that I almost believe it's intended for cultural preservation.

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20pFsokokjo

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by flir on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:56AM (#37659380)
It's a Skinner box. If the pigeon never gets a reward, it'll lose interest in the key. If it always gets a reward it'll hit the key, but not that much because the reward is always the same and its boring. If the reward only occurs sometimes, the pigeon'll go nuts hitting that key. We're the pigeons, and the "randomness" is constantly being tweaked to make sure we never get bored.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by numpad0 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:00PM (#37665750)
The point is, if the reward not just occurs rarely but were actually-kinda-disappointing, the pigeon gets even crazier than it had been huge jackpots, somehow.

Discrepancy between perceived and mathematical expectation is a big factor in keeping us hooked. So techniques to exaggerate the former are used.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by dendrite9 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:20AM (#37655131)
I remember reading about Yanis Varoufakis studying the economics of games for Valve at a time when I played TF2 occasionally. Several years later I went back to play some games and it seemed like a wholly different world with loot crates and markets for cosmetics. My timing may be off, and I suppose the idea was already there. But hearing someone talk about markets inside popular games was a bit concerning.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:29AM (#37655194)
gamification?

No, this is illegal use of casino algorithms and payoff psychology / slot machine psychology, outside of regulation, restriction from exposure to children, without disclaimers for gambling problems and hotlines.

The middle-tier issues I have: the same issues that used to exist with gambling and introducing it officially: moral concerns over degeneracy, the family impacts of gambling addictions, the regressive cost nature on poor/middle class.

What I'm really concerned about: outright cheating. There is implied probabilities involved here, and the apps are not doing the implied distribution. Sure, go ahead and point to the fine print. There is a reason gambling is so heavily restricted and regulated. These games are acting like they aren't subject to these laws.

What I'm really really really concerned about: the use of gambling payoff/reward psychology/neurotransmitter biology in games that CHILDREN are being subjected to, or even worse, they are ACTIVELY targeted by the "free to play" games, by the "click/watch ad to keep playing" ads in the FTP games.

This is OUTRAGEOUS. This has to end. This has to be strictly regulated. Many of these free to play games, which even cursory experience educates you to a world where "whales" that are paying thousands of dollars a month or more. These games are among the most popular/heavily downloaded games in the app stores, with hundreds of millions of revenue, which Apple and Google are feasting at the trough on.

Absolutely outrageous. Apple and Google should be ashamed of themselves, and fined billions of dollars over this. Why Europe has not woken up to this, which is the only real hope in the short run for substantial fines, is beyond me.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by WA on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:45AM (#37655320)
> Why Europe has not woken up to this, which is the only real hope in the short run for substantial fines, is beyond me.

Thing is, regulations do exist but as long as Apple and Google are not forced to comply at least partially in these regulations, nothing will ever change.

Take the GDPR as an example:

- Europe says: "Your app must comply with the GDPR if you want to be in the European market."

- Apple says to app developers: "It's up to you to comply with local laws."

Obviously, Europe can only go after companies, which have a presence in the EU, such as the big tech ones.

Now how would anyone ever enforce regulation such as the GDPR for app devs from China, Indonesia, Brazil, South Africa, ...? There's simply no way. There is no one responsible for that. There is no customs office checking goods (apps) imported to the EU. And the same is true for casino apps.

So, the solution might be to force Apple/Google to comply with all local laws for all apps in the stores. Sounds like a lot of work, but that's the only way. After all, if you buy in-app-items, Apple/Google are the sellers, not the app developers. If you think about it, it's odd that Apple and Google get away with this, because they effectively "sell" these apps to end customers.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by hef19898 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:09AM (#37655541)
I think the logical conclussion is to force app store providers to do the enforcement. After all, the app store providers are monopolists in their environments. I guess, one day, if Apple, Google and company (all those crapware stores from e.g. Samsung) don't enforce it themselves, an EU regulation will come.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by throwaway290 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:11AM (#37655558)
Perhaps the effective solution will be per country app stores, the natural next step after alt app stores are made mandatory by EU.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by the_gipsy on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:42AM (#37656273)
You cannot just take payments from citizens of the USA or Europe into some unregulated country, forever. Sure, some fly under the radar, but most gambling-like games (including puzzle games) belong to some conglomerate.

See online casinos. They exist since the 90s, before apps. In the USA apparently you can only run a casino in Las Vegas or some places with a soecific license. Yet the online casinos still exist, but operate from jurisdictions that are off limits from the FBI or whatever (something like Cayman Islands or whatever). However the owners are identified and will be detained when entering US soil.

The internet is not some loophole to break the law. If you are taking a relevant amount of money, even in small payments, they can get back to you or at least block you.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by maleldil on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:38AM (#37656773)
> GDPR for app devs from [...] Brazil

It might be worth noting that Brazil has a law similar to GDPR: Lei Geral de Proteção de Dados (LGPD). It's not as strong as GDPR, though.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by rcarr on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:40AM (#37658426)
What would the counterpart be if a product was found not to be complying with hardware regulations, such as an electronics device that was found to be a fire risk? Who gets penalised/fined, the seller, the importer, the company who made it or all three? I don't know, but if it's the importer or seller then Apple/Google should absolutely be made to regulate this in some way seeing as though they are taking on that role in the pipeline.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by throwaway290 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:09AM (#37655540)
> Apple and Google should be ashamed of themselves, and fined billions of dollars over this. Why Europe has not woken up to this, which is the only real hope in the short run for substantial fines, is beyond me.

Perhaps EU hopes that sideloading would address issues like this.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by jonasdegendt on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:11AM (#37655554)
Some countries have taken steps to curb loot boxes, Belgium comes to mind and games like the Diablo mobile one aren’t even available to play there because of the regulations.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by robertlagrant on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:54AM (#37656373)
> What I'm really really really concerned about: the use of gambling payoff/reward psychology/neurotransmitter biology in games that CHILDREN are being subjected to, or even worse, they are ACTIVELY targeted by the "free to play" games, by the "click/watch ad to keep playing" ads in the FTP games.

Toy adverts push the same buttons. I don't know how you regulate this effectively except (as toy adverts are) retroactively.

> Many of these free to play games, which even cursory experience educates you to a world where "whales" that are paying thousands of dollars a month or more

I think whales are usually adults, though. They're wasting their money, just as they waste it paying for a superchat so an influencer will say 5 words to them, but as far as I know this isn't a kid thing, unlike the other points you make.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by dspillett on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:43AM (#37656812)
> It has been fascinating and demoralizing to watch monetization roll out. To younger generations like my brother, they don't know any different, it's just part if gaming for them.

A step worse too: they are being trained that being bombarded with adverts is acceptable. Genuinely heard (couldn't avoid hearing, the voices were fairly loud) on a train the other week a dad explaining to his charge how he should “watch the adverts all the way through because he'd get an extra coin to spend in the game” and that if he went to a particular screen he could find more adverts to watch. No idea what game it was he was playing.

Pay-to-win is winning, and people are encouraging kids to pay by opening themselves to a little light brainwashing.

[Not a parent myself, intending to never be, before anyone weights in with “you don't know how hard it can be to keep a child entertained”: I know full well, and it is one of the many reasons I'm planning to stay childless, my position on this is an informed one!]

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by bondarchuk on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:30AM (#37657217)
>A step worse too: they are being trained that being bombarded with adverts is acceptable.

We have all been trained that way. The cities in the developed world where you can step outside and walk around for a bit without seeing billboards can be counted on one hand.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by dspillett on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:37AM (#37657784)
Though in the case I heard the viewing was less passive: the kid was being encouraged to seek out adverts for more in-game whatevers.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by MandieD on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:14AM (#37658133)
No, you're right to be horrified, and I'm the mom of a three year old who will look for things to take apart if left to his own devices.

Current screen policy: only "his" laptop, only videos I've picked out for him (currently, he's into Alphablocks and Numberblocks), laptop gets closed and put up for the rest of the day the instant he whines about having to stop watching for whatever reason.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by lacrimacida on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:08AM (#37658728)
Wait, your 3 year old has a laptop already?
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by bigfishrunning on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:37AM (#37659111)
It's a strange world. My school district gave my kindergartner (5) a laptop.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by iFreilicht on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:22AM (#37658914)
Not the person you replied to and don't have kids yet, but with the current state of TV, I'd much rather let my child watch their entertainment on an old laptop (or tablet or whatever) that I control rather than a TV.

They can more easily watch with headphones, they can even watch in private if they're introverted, and I'd feel a lot better knowing they won't switch channels without my knowledge or watch adverts for stupid plastic trash.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by pjlegato on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:31PM (#37663776)
Children don't actually NEED electronic entertainment of any kind. Kids lived that way for a very long time.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by dspillett on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @05:10AM (#37672112)
They do benefit from access to technology to an extent though: they need to know about it in order to fully interact with the world they are to grow up into.

At what point this becomes necessary is a matter of much argument. They certainly don't need it in the first few years, but I'd suggest they need to be at least aware by the time they are going to school.

It is difficult to separate this from entertainment, because being entertained/interested/curious is largely how our brains do some of their best learning at early ages.

> Kids lived that way for a very long time.

Be careful with appeals to tradition.

The world doesn't exactly work the way it did a long time ago, so we are not preparing kids for the same life they were expected to experience back then.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by Workaccount2 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @11:09AM (#37660514)
My sister was ardently opposed to screens for my niece.

She quickly capitulated when she learned that iPads are magical nannies that will totally occupy your child and give you precious time to get other stuff done.

So "screen but only with approved content in moderation" became the norm.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by phone8675309 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:28PM (#37664629)
Why the judgemental attitude?

If I had a child and I wanted to make sure that they could only watch the videos I chose for them then I would have a laptop for them to use, and I could absolutely see myself calling it "their laptop" in casual conversation.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by MandieD on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:49PM (#37665631)
“His” laptop that is locked down to the point that I will be proud if/when he manages to see anything I didn’t put on there, versus all the less-restricted devices in the house.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by MandieD on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:42PM (#37665559)
As soon as he can figure out how to type the password and how to access a browser, it’s his.

For now, it’s a small TV that receives one channel run by a station manager who has a thing for counting and the alphabet.

Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by pesfandiar on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:47PM (#37662044)
I shuddered at that. There are times that parents have to resort to screen time to entertain children (e.g. a long train ride), but there are many other less harmful options than adverts or gambling-adjacent games.
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by malteof on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:08AM (#37657014)
You’re talking about mobile games. I have to kids, 4 and 6, and the only games we’ve introduced them to are 1) board games and 2) Nintendo Switch games. This largely avoids the problem (for now!)
Re:The Casino in Your Pocket by xmcqdpt2 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:54AM (#37657955)
Same.

The thing with content is that it costs money to produce, and so you (generally) have to pay money to get it.

I know some parents who have super strict "screen time" rules but let their kids watch (during the allotted time) any random dumb youtube show, or play those shitty iPad games. Those parents are not tech savvy, and they assume that all digital experiences are shit.

In contrast I pay lots of money for Nintendo first-party games because I know (I play them too!) that they are engaging digital experiences with good screenwriting. I pay recurring subscription to streaming services and apps because real storytelling for children DOES exist on devices with screens!