> What sets my brain apart from an LLM though is that I am not typing this because you asked me to do it, nor because I needed to reply to the first comment I saw. I am typing this because it is a thought that has been in my mind for a while and I am interested in expressing it to other human brains, motivated by a mix of arrogant belief that it is insightful and a wish to see others either agreeing or providing reasonable counterpoints—I have an intention behind it.

Maybe the reason you give is actually a post hoc explanation (a hallucination?). When an LLM spits out a poem, it does so because it was directly asked. When I spit out this comment, it’s probably the unavoidable result of a billion tiny factors. The trigger isn’t as obvious or direct, but it’s likely there.