News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by phyzome on Saturday September 23, 2023 @02:52PM (#37626224)
Her non-physics videos tend to be a bit off, but not terrible; on the whole, they're still reasonably well-researched and educational.

Where she really gets into trouble is farther out into the social sciences. I think she should be much more careful there. I don't want her to stop, I just want her to be more careful!

An interesting example is one of her two videos on transgenderism. It had an absolutely appalling both-sidesing intro that literally called people who crazy who are just concerned about suicide rates among trans people. The contents of the video were actually pretty reasonable, although she messed up a few key interpretations so that some parts ended up being misleading. I don't think she's transphobic, but on an issue like this I think a bit more care needs to be taken.

More recently she had a piece on capitalism that was incredibly anemic. I think she tried to bite off more than she could chew (for a 20 minute video) and so she kind of missed the entire "what are the problems" side of the topic, even while laying out some reubttals to common statements. I feel like she'd have done better than that on a more close-to-home topic.

(Her physics videos are of course fantastic.)

Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by grebel on Saturday September 23, 2023 @03:28PM (#37626541)
> An interesting example is one of her two videos on transgenderism. It had an absolutely appalling both-sidesing intro that literally called people who crazy who are just concerned about suicide rates among trans people.

This was what she actually said in the introduction to that video:

"Should transgender teens transition? This rather personal question occupies a prominent place in the American culture war. One the one side you have people claiming that it’s a socially contagious fad among the brainwashed woke who want to mutilate your innocent children. On the other side there are those saying that it’s saving the lives of minorities who’ve been forced to stay in the closet for too long. And then there are normal people, like you and I, who think both sides are crazy and could someone please summarise the facts in simple words, which is what I’m here for. So what’s going on?"

What's objectionable about that? Sounds quite fair to me.

Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by s1gnp0st on Saturday September 23, 2023 @03:59PM (#37626897)
The only thing objectionable is the soi-disant left making a religion of erasing gender-nonconforming people with medical interventions that don't work.
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by howinteresting on Saturday September 23, 2023 @04:05PM (#37626947)
[dead]
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by howinteresting on Saturday September 23, 2023 @04:36PM (#37627271)
Better to remain silent, etc.
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by dzhiurgis on Saturday September 23, 2023 @04:00PM (#37626903)
If you are from very polarised place then just about everyone is called crazy because opinions are approaching boolean type.
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by howinteresting on Saturday September 23, 2023 @04:38PM (#37627300)
"On the other side there are those saying that it’s saving the lives of minorities who’ve been forced to stay in the closet for too long. And then there are normal people, like you and I, who think both sides are crazy"

I think this fragment speaks for itself. It is not "crazy" to care about suicide rates or suicidal ideation. It is "crazy" to not care about that.

Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by grebel on Saturday September 23, 2023 @05:29PM (#37627738)
That first sentence is quite euphemistic though. There's a lot more to both sides that she quietly implies (by reference to "normal people" finding it "crazy") but doesn't outright mention.
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by howinteresting on Saturday September 23, 2023 @05:46PM (#37627838)
The difference between the two sides is that one is correct and the other is not, and that what "normal" (uninformed lay) people think is not really relevant.

edit: Your response has no actual content in it.

Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by grebel on Saturday September 23, 2023 @06:14PM (#37628028)
Funnily enough, that's what those on the other side say too.

No matter what the topic, those at either end of strongly polarised collections of views do tend to believe that they are correct and everyone else is wrong and informed.

Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by howinteresting on Sunday September 24, 2023 @03:33PM (#37636408)
Thanks, Captain Obvious.
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by grebel on Sunday September 24, 2023 @07:10PM (#37638062)
There are non-evidenced beliefs on both sides. The reason you think you are correct is because you assume that your beliefs are facts.

Indeed, your comments imply that you are fully immersed in this illusion and are unlikely to accept any suggestion to the contrary.

Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by faeriechangling on Saturday September 23, 2023 @06:36PM (#37628201)
Which side cares about them? Those who are stigmatizing a population with high suicide rates? Or those who have successfully spearheaded a societal shift which has led more people identify as a minority group, which still claims they have high rates of suicidal ideation.

I don’t see any evidence that mental health in the transgender or general population has actually improved, I’ve seen numbers suggesting societal wide mental health is on the decline, and I have seen a pretty large increase in the absolute numbers of people who say their gender dysphoria makes them suicidal. I can find research that suggests transgender people who receive more medical treatment and societal acceptance are less suicidal than those who do not, but that doesn’t actually demonstrate that trans acceptance will lead to less suicidality and better mental health at the societal level. Or even really at the individual level, since correlation is not causation.

On top of all that, most past research can be thrown out as non-reproducible at this point because the trans population has expanded so rapidly, like three times as many trans men started visiting clinics in the course of a decade, that both the patient population and the average quality of a clinic has changed. People treat research on rapidly changing demographics with WAY more respect than is warranted.

So I don’t know, I’m with Hossenfelder and her radical centrism because I think nobody is actually acting scientifically re: trans people and they’re just playing it by ear. What I detest is the unwarranted certainty and lack of scepticism people have on this topic; People are just guessing and are acting like they are not.

Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by howinteresting on Saturday September 23, 2023 @08:53PM (#37629102)
You've strung a lot of words together that are not attached to reality. Plenty of people are acting very scientifically with regard to trans people—there are hundreds of studies in this regard. "Correlation is not causation" is the beginning of the conversation about the relationship between the two, not the end. (Observational data plus a solid theory is a very powerful way to establish causation.)
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by phyzome on Saturday September 23, 2023 @08:40PM (#37629039)
« saving the lives of minorities who’ve been forced to stay in the closet for too long »

I mean, this is literally true, and doesn't sound crazy at all. Why is she saying that normal people think it's crazy? That's not the vibe I get from the general population, who are broadly in support of gender-affirming care. There's a relatively small, very loud contingent on the "mutilating the children" side of things and yeah, some of them sound a little crazy to me (although I suspect most are just uninformed or confused -- or using trans people as a political football, and know exactly what they're doing.) Most people either a) don't give a shit or b) have empathy for people who experience gender dysphoria.

This is classic both-sides-ism, equating two things as "equally wrong" or "equally right" that are pretty obviously on different footings.

Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by grebel on Sunday September 24, 2023 @08:27AM (#37632481)
If one scratches the surface of the "saving lives" claim to see what assumptions and beliefs this is based on, it very quickly gets just as crazy as the other side, if not more so.
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by kiba on Saturday September 23, 2023 @03:06PM (#37626341)
I think it's important to increase our range on our knowledge. You aren't always going to have an expert's opinion to evaluate every piece of information coming at you, and there's only so much that an authoritative source can do for you.

Now, making videos on topics outside of your expertise? That's a dangerous minefield, but there are ways to approach it.

For example, there's whole youtube channels to taking on challenges and learning new stuff.

Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by howinteresting on Saturday September 23, 2023 @04:41PM (#37627340)
This is a plague among high-IQ people. They're good at pattern matching which is rewarding in those fields but think they can just think through areas outside their expertise without engaging with the literature.
Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research... by VirusNewbie on Saturday September 23, 2023 @04:56PM (#37627487)
Well, in terms of Covid-19, data scientists and programmers did a much better job than epidemiologists at predicting spread and infection rate.