Explain. I see a handful of identical mega corps with a government protected monopoly (regulations + access to airports). Hasn't regulation increased consolidation to share the cost of compliance?
Like the pork barrel shops in the airport, why is this a private business at all?
https://airandspace.si.edu/stories/editorial/airline-deregul...
Big companies have just figured out that scale and vertical integration kills everyone smaller.
I see the opposite: new, brightly-colored airlines seem to pop up every year, each offering substantially the same thing: sub-$100 direct tickets to Florida (and probably other) destinations from low- and mid-tier airports. And they're all catering to the people who these rewards programs are shedding.
Every successful company eventually becomes a bank. See also Apple.
The more successful, the larger the pile of money and more likely to look bankish.
Due to technology, the old use case of banks is mostly obviated. There is no technical reason everyone should not just have an electronic money account at the Fed itself for receiving and sending money. And earn the federal funds rate directly rather than have it go through a middleman who is basically just operating a database.
And lending does not have much to do with receiving people’s cash deposits.
Yet you complete leave out the non-technical reason why that's a terrible idea.
Systemic Single-Point of Failure, extreme vulnerability political exploitation, no robustness or process/partition based discorrelation to stave off or slow down financial contagion.
Robustness is entropic. It uses more energy, but gains in it's ability to remain up in the face of a myriad of quantifiable stimuli instead of falling apart at the slightest touch.
All eggs in one basket is a bad idea. No one makes a good enough basket.
I think you're grossly overestimating the fallout from this. I am the aforementioned business customer. Literally the only way you'd ever hit the dollar amounts they're looking for is flying multiple times across the Atlantic paying full fare business class - which I don't do. But I do fly multiple times a month across the continental US. Previously I would book Delta regardless of price for both business and personal travel due to status. They've made it basically unobtainable unless you're paying full fare first class on every flight AND booking your cars and hotel through them.
Going forward I'll just book the cheapest flight available and drop their card. They will be losing at minimum 10s of thousands a year in profit from my travel and card spend alone.
Even assuming 1%, for an airline to lose $10,000 in profit, you would have to be spending $10,000 / 0.01 = $1M per year on that credit card.
And if you are spending a minimum of $1M on your credit card per year, I doubt you are spending your time optimizing “miles” and “points”.
I assume there are lots of smart people working at airlines that can work out which of their policies earn and lose money, especially now that all the competition is minimal except on the most popular routes.
> especially now that all the competition is minimal except on the most popular routes.
I guess airlines are betting sufficient passengers have no better option, and I would bet that too. I cannot remember the last time I got to pick an airline without heavily inconveniencing myself and wasting tons of hours with extra stops. Even a busy airport like Newark, you are basically flying United for 90% of destinations if you want to get there in the shortest amount of time with the fewest stops.
An airline like Delta will adjust but there will be pain for them in the short term and pain for customers in the medium and long term with fewer, more expensive flights. All of this assumes these changes actually lead to customers changing their behavior rather than simply saying they will.
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/DAL/delta-air-line...
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/UAL/united-airline...
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AAL/american-airli...
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/ALK/alaska-air/pro...
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/LUV/southwest-airl...
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/HA/hawaiian-holdin...
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/JBLU/jetblue-airwa...
https://www.google.com/finance/quote/DAL:NYSE
And again, that doesn't address the fact their net profit margin has literally 0 relation to their profit margin on MY TICKET which is CONSIDERABLY higher than 11.72% on average.
https://s2.q4cdn.com/181345880/files/doc_financials/2022/q4/...
And page 63/64, it seems like Macrotrends is using “net income/loss” row and the “total operating income” row, and Google is also using the same, so not sure why the quarterly figures are different. Macrotrends does look erroneous here.
>And again, that doesn't address the fact their net profit margin has literally 0 relation to their profit margin on MY TICKET which is CONSIDERABLY higher than 11.72% on average.
Yes, the delta bosses are not considering the profit margin from your specific flights, but assuming the vast majority of their business is flights where their airline miles come into play, then I figured it is a good assumption that, on average, losing a flight costs them the around the same profit margin.
Of course it is possible they lose so many flights that it cuts into their fixed costs, but I assume they are smart enough to make those calculations.
The allocation of profits down to specific activities depends on the allocation of revenues and expenses amongst activities, and all such allocations are inherently arbitrary. They depend on the stories we tell.
I think you missed the part where they're losing ALL of my business, including dozens of flights a year.
>I assume there are lots of smart people working at airlines that can work out which of their policies earn and lose money, especially now that all the competition is minimal except on the most popular routes.
I assume they think customers with lots of miles banked won't go through the effort of dropping them entirely. I think they're wrong.
When you're losing customers that have million miler+ status, you've made a pretty poor decision.
Crazy to think JetBlue wanting Spirit. I remember when JetBlue started, their goal was to provide a better experience than all the other airlines. It is really a cutthroat business. Virgin Airlines had to be folded into Alaska too.
https://www.cnbc.com/2017/10/18/branson-says-alaska-air-was-...
I agree with you on this. Nobody who flew Delta did it for the value of SkyPesos anyway. The airline miles on Delta have historically had the lowest value among US major carriers and that hasn't gotten any better, so frankly I have no issue giving up my miles. I flew Delta for better hard product and a better set of co-brand + FF perks. By changing the latter, the difference on the former is mostly ameliorated, and the miles are basically meaningless. At most a skypeso is worth maybe 1 cent. A million skypesos is only worth $1k in EV, and that's being generous. A one-time cost of $1k that isn't even a fully realized loss (I can always use the miles later without seeking status) is nothing compared to the betrayal of the program changes.
Then I moved to New Mexico, and found that Delta was the obvious choice for getting to London from here. And OMFG ... the difference in the product was just spectacular. Seats. Food. Movies. Uniforms. Air quality (not kidding). Probably will still use them when I do this journey.
United domestic routes are disgusting though. Most of the planes are falling apart CRJs without IFE and WiFi, and if they do have WiFi they charge you for it, and the domestic United staffers are not good. I would put United service quality on-par with Spirit or Frontier. Easily the worst in the big 3.
That said, I'd still rather develop status on United, take directs, and then fly Polaris full-fare or Singapore Airlines biz class for my personal / international trips now that Delta has made these changes to the medallion program.
In good times, airlines rarely profit 10%. I'm guessing it averages closer to 5%.
Are you spending $200k+ on flights per year?
Otherwise, they aren't missing $10k+ in profit.
Really, I think if anything I might be underestimating the fallout from this in that I don't see it being an issue at all and I think most airlines will follow with the same changes in the future.
Even the new thresholds are not that high if you're crossing the continental US multiple times per month and are surely less than the flying you're doing on Delta if the loss of your business represents "10s of thousands a year in profit".
Delta's gross margin percentage is roughly 25%. For them to lose just 2 10 thousands in profit on you, you'd be spending $80K with them and doing so would continue to easily qualify for Diamond, whereupon you'd get better upgrades and service from them due to fewer people making Diamond each year.
I can spend $35k on flights, but I can also fly private for about the same amount, excluding most trans-oceanic. So I'm not sure what I'm going to do about next year. I'm not sure if it's really worth it. It's a weird calculus. To hit the number, it's basically buying a bunch of F/J fares. If I'm already doing that, I don't care about upgrades.
No more worrying about upgrades, middle seats, air-ragers, and all it took was a little more money.
Of course now sometimes I fly on airlines I’ve never heard of whereas previously, I had taken exclusively American for my last 200 or so legs. I think the effects of shaking up these programs will be to make consumers like me much, much less brand sensitive.
Air Canada spun out aeroplan, and then years later re-acquired it.
To be honest the whole approach always felt like some form of corruption/kick back to me. You give an incentive to the employee that is dissociated from the interest of their employer.
This is mitigated by the employer setting rates, per-diem, rules on what seats you can purchase, etc. and the employer can't use the points from the frequent flyer program anyway. If there's, say, a $50 fare difference and that causes an employee to choose a more expensive flight (because the comparable flights are comparable) because they get points it's fine and basically an added benefit. In consulting for example that's a stated benefit in employee handbooks.
Of course that's not to say employees of companies can't go against the interest of their employer here, but it's up to the employer to set guidelines and for the employee to follow them.
This isn't always true. Some employers insist you book through their internal travel department or use their corporate FF accounts, which kick all the mileage and hotel night benefits to them. It's not common, fortunately, but it does happen.
There’s indirect benefits to the business as well since they’ll be first to be put on a flight after cancellations, can get guaranteed lodging in areas that sell out often, and can use their points to upgrade making their trip nicer.
So it’s unwise to chase that as an employer. Let them get points and be comfortable and use them to take the family somewhere.
Is this a thing for most people?
Being in an unfamiliar place is one of my greatest joys. I am never more relaxed than my first day in a new city where I know absolutely nothing, and turning each new corner is a revelation.
Wow, okay, big jump here buddy. What happened to being profitable and actually committed to offering a core competent service to customers?
As the joke goes, “how do you become a millionaire? Start with a billion dollars and buy an airline”.
It is only recently the airline business has had steady positive years, due to consolidation, and even then, COVID hit and almost wiped them out were they not bailed out.
Modifying a rewards programs should require a very miniscule portion of ann airline’s available labor hours, and aligning rewards to be proportionate to profitability seems like a common sense business move.
That they should spend more money and lower profit margins even more? Or that they should increase prices so that they can spend more money to improve the things you listed?
Surely, airline employees are more knowledgeable about how much customers are willing to pay than non airline employees.
Shouldn’t
Be
Banks
There is one step, and it is bank (Past a particular threshold).
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/financialization.asp
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carcinisation
https://www.catb.org/jargon/html/Z/Zawinskis-Law.html
Those observations aside, I do agree with your rough rhetorical position.
Have you flown on an airplane in the last 10 years? I'd rather drive 15 hours to Florida than deal with the fucking airlines
I end up paying roughly $50 per hour of flight plus or minus, and it’s been consistent for my adult life (15+ years). Which is surprising considering inflation.
The only problems I have with flying are TSA and airport runway congestion itself.
Easy to say when you have money
I jest, but which airlines have you been on? I've enjoyed my airline experiences more now than in the past flying Delta, American, United.
But yeah I agree, if it's less than 6 hours I'll almost always just drive.
Assuming you're talking about the 1978 deregulation, I don't think that's the cause. Starting around about the same time (maybe under Reagan?) the US basically stopped enforcing the anti-trust laws that are on the books. This has led to mergers across the board, not just for the airlines.
that said, I doubt airlines will ever fully relinquish control over their loyalty programs - they are too critical to the core business and offer a 'secret sauce' of differentiation to what is an otherwise commoditized product (i.e. flying from point A to B).
I am both of those things, have held status with Delta for a number of years along with a co-brand credit card that I run $60k-$100k/yr through. I typically take 15-20 trips per year, and when I'm /not/ flying on business I only fly first class/Delta One. The new program means where formerly I was always PM/DM each year in status, I would be lucky to hit GM without greatly changing my spending habits, and the lounge changes massively devalued even carrying a co-brand card. I live in a competitor's hub (Denver) and chose Delta over the competitors specifically because of better quality of hard product, better on time rates, and a good co-brand program with Amex (who I'm a loyalist for).
I am actively investigating alternatives, and at this point am likely to cancel my Delta Amex (I'm keeping my Amex Plat of course) and switching to the United Club Infinite card as my primary travel card / credit card. Delta makes more money from their co-brand relationship with Amex now than they do from operating flights, and they're losing both of my business because of these changes.
Business travelers almost only get booked into economy/main cabin in the US, because of corporate policies and no health and safety regulations in the US requiring higher tiers of service for long flights (EU residents generally get booked into business for transatlantic flights for healthy and safety reasons, DVT is no joke). Being able to maintain status off a reasonable amount of travel and co-brand spend so I get upgraded into FC on business flights and can buy FC with some perks on personal flights is the core value proposition of airline frequent flyer programs. Delta just killed that for their core customer base. To be clear, I had already bought 6 Delta One tickets for next year, and I haven't even booked my end-year trips yet. I purchased 7 Delta One tickets this year and 6 domestic First Class tickets, I'm also on track to run $90k through my co-brand card this year.
They're losing a not inconsequential amount of business with my departure to United, which when they're finished will have over 100k sqft of lounge space in the Denver airport, plus a Polaris lounge, and offers unlimited lounge access with their top-tier cobrand card and I can attain status even /easier/ than the /current/ medallion program, much less the new one. With this change the only advantage Delta gives me for having to eat a connection on every domestic flight to go through SLC/ATL/LAX/JFK, is that they have free wi-fi on board. That's great, I guess, but I hardly ever even use it, I'd rather unplug and read a book while I'm in the air. The hard product is marginally better on domestic Delta flights, but Polaris is actually better than Delta One anyway, and United has better international partners in Star Alliance, like Singapore Airlines, than Delta does (although I do love KLM).
I find the changes in the medallion program to be incredibly short-sighted, and I am expecting it to backfire horribly. Delta built a lot of brand loyalty with travelers. People like me who will choose Delta over anyone else even though I'm in a non-hub location and it implies always eating a connection, partly because the Sky Clubs were high quality lounges, broadly available even in non-hub sites, and they had a solid FF program w/ good co-brand perks. They've just lost most of their advantage except their operational quality, which also has taken a nosedive post-pandemic. Explain to me why I would choose Delta over United, when I live in a United hub and get can get better perks on the co-brand card, for someone who can afford to pay for multiple full-fare business-class international tickets a year?
Its stunning to me that these changes have managed to alienate so many people across the spectrum. Its not just the higher barrier to entry for the lowest tier that is earning complaints. The value of the miles earned was always much less important to me than the value of the occasional upgrades the status provided, or very occasionally the special support phone lines.
Perhaps the reality for the program really is that only the "whales" matter. We certainly see that play out all over the software industry. But if that's the case, it sure changes my porpoise-sized travel habits. My loyalty will now be to Amex moreso than an individual airline.
I'll enjoy my last year with GM in 2024 I guess.
Of the options I have for BOS <> SFO, Delta still probably has the best hard product offering there. But this is definitely changing my dogged loyalty. I'll be trying Alaska soon enough. Not sure I'll ever do United again...
Isn't this effectively what we have with Chase, Amex, Capital One, and Citi? Each earns points that can be used directly or transferred to airlines and hotels.
And then as further evidence, Avios points can already be used across several airlines (BA, Iberia, Aer Lingus, Qatar, and soon Finnair). Not to mention the ability to book flights on different airlines with miles sometimes (eg booking Delta from KLM).
Not really. Those companies aren't sellers of points, they horse trade the interchange fee. They're basically giving away a portion of their revenue just to stay competitive.
If I have the monopoly of buying miles from airlines at 1c/mile and then sell them to co-branded credit card companies for 1.3-1.5c, what I have is a fucking license to print money.
This is probably how frequent-flier programs should have been run in the first place. Airline don't care that you fly alot, they care that you are a profitable customer.
That means business customers and the wealthy will still be their main clients. This just means they lose the churners and the price sensitive bargain hunters, which almost every airline would be happy to trade away for more business customers.
It's a win for the airline as they keep their core customers happy as their rewards won't change and they'll lose the unprofitable customers who used their rewards programs alot without spending much.
> A 2020 analysis by the Financial Times found that Wall Street lenders valued the major airlines’ mileage programs more highly than the airlines themselves. United’s MileagePlus program, for example, was valued at $22 billion, while the company’s market cap at the time was only $10.6 billion.
This looks alot like car companies whose leasing arms became more profitable than their manufacturing arms for part of the 2000s.
But wallstreet loves companies that they can easily value and this "conglomerate" style business has been out of favour for a while now.
Sooner or later some airlines will spin out their rewards business into a separate company to get the maximum valuation from it. Just like how deregulation lead to the consolidation of airlines, I wouldn't be surprised to see only a couple of rewards programs that every airline uses in a decade.
As usual PE will be the winner. I'd bet Blackstone or Apollo will roll up multiple programs into one or two uber rewards/credit card programs that are spun out into public companies. VISA and Mastercard won't care who owns them. As long as it drives more credit card usage, they'll be on board.