News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by em-bee on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:28AM (#37594306)
what? on the contrary.

every human need must by necessity be a right. ignoring human needs is in itself a human rights violation. since water is needed to survive, unless you want to deny people the right to live, water must be a human right.

Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by Georgelemental on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:09AM (#37596448)
A human right is universal, something that applies to all times and all places, by virtue of the human's existence. People can try to take them away, but not grant them, because they are already granted by default. If you are marooned, alone, on a desert island, you still have a right to free expression, due process, etc.

In contrast, limited resources require active effort to obtain, and even that might not be enough. If you are stuck on the desert island, with no food or fresh water available, no amount of agitation about your ‘rights’ will override the laws of physics to make them appear. Even in a more advanced society, producing enough food and water to ensure everyone's survival may be physically impossible (especially if you insist on a certain level of quality). Therefore, ‘rights’ to limited resources are not universal, they are subordinate to (at minimum) the laws of nature.

Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by TheAceOfHearts on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:15AM (#37596494)
This just seems like petty arguing over the definition of words. Which is resolved quite easily by pointing out that your definition is not the one used by most groups, in particular by the people at the UN who wrote those human rights declarations.
Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by Georgelemental on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:44AM (#37596789)
By confusing true universal rights with fake contingent ‘rights’ full of exceptions and caveats, you weaken the true rights. Naturally, authoritarian leaders and would-be despots at the UN and elsewhere are totally on board with this strategy.
Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by em-bee on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:17AM (#37596516)
i don't think that is relevant.

human rights applies to the relationship between people.

stuck on an island i can do all sorts of things, even illegal ones, because noone is there to stop me. so that's not really useful in determining my right to free expression or due process. both only work if there are others to listen or to charge me with a crime.

however, if i am among other people then those people have the obligation to do everything in their power to keep me alive, because that is my human right. and that would include to share their water, or to cooperate to build a desalination plant, or whatever is needed to survive.

Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by Georgelemental on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:35AM (#37596694)
> However, if i am among other people then those people have the obligation to do everything in their power to keep me alive, because that is my human right.

How far do you take this? If you are dying of a disease, and the only way to prolong your life by one week is a medication that costs $2 trillion in resources to produce one dose, is society obligated to produce the medication to slightly delay your death? What if there is enough to satisfy only 50% of people, how does your ‘rights’-based framework decide who lives and who dies?

Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by em-bee on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:45AM (#37596800)
water is a resource that everyone needs, hence it needs to be shared. a specialized medication that not everyone needs is not the same thing.
Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by Georgelemental on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:59AM (#37596977)
Seems contradictory to your previous comment, but OK. What if there is enough water for only 50% of people? Or what if the water doesn't have an ideal mineral composition, but for 1000 times the expense, society could obtain better water that will extend one's lifespan by an average of 2 months?
Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by em-bee on Thursday September 21, 2023 @09:57AM (#37597692)
when i said "do everything in their power to keep me alive" then that was probably a bit to strong. i meant do everything that is also needed for everyone else. special treatment that takes an unreasonable effort is not the same thing.

if the resource is so limited that it really isn't enough for everyone, then it obviously can not be given to everyone. but if everyone needs it, then they still have a right to it. we then just have to figure out how to deal with those that miss out.

a more practical example: a sinking ship, and the rescue boat can not fit everyone. while it is a human right for everyone to be rescued, some will have to stay behind.

but, that doesn't change that there was a human right violated. in either cases we really do need to do everything in our power to rescue these people or find ways to extend the use of the water.

lack of resources does not abolish our obligation to do the best we can to change that, find alternatives, etc.

a better medicine example: covid. everyone needs that vaccination (ignoring those who don't want it) so it becomes a human right to get access to it. no matter the cost.

we can not abolish a right to something that everyone needs just because there is not enough of it.

Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by Georgelemental on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:22AM (#37598059)
OK, so you define "human right" as "thing you have a moral duty to do your reasonable best to supply fairly to everyone." The reason I feel strongly that we should use a different term for these, versus by-virtue-of-existing rights like free speech, is that using the same term for both weakens the latter. Free expression, fair trials, etc, are not "best-effort", and belong in a different category. Specifically, it makes more sense to discuss food, water, healthcare, etc with words like "duty" and "responsibility", which better take into account the burden imposed.
Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by em-bee on Thursday September 21, 2023 @11:00AM (#37598653)
that's fair. i don't care about the term used as long as we agree on the resulting actions that need to be done, and i agree that there is a difference between those categories.

as far as i understand it the, definition of human rights includes both but that's an extended discussion.

however on your last point, i would argue that despite the difference, free expression or fair trials do also create a duty or responsibility to provide these.

for every right that is given, there exists a duty to provide or enable that right.

it also works the other way around. if it is a duty to send my kids to school, then i have a right to a school within reasonable distance. if it is a duty to work, then i have a right to childcare. etc.

so no matter how you look at it, right and duty are intertwined and can not be separated.

Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by maxerickson on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:04AM (#37597806)
Invoking the laws of nature implies that there is no place for morality when it comes to limited resources. Good stuff.