News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by olliej on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:20AM (#37593177)
Most countries consider having users to be equivalent to having a presence, free or otherwise.
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by awei on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:29AM (#37593226)
Would it apply to a website like Wikipedia for example ?
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by I_am_uncreative on Thursday September 21, 2023 @01:36AM (#37593577)
Wikipedia is actually trying to figure that out. Right now WMF legal says no.
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by b800h on Thursday September 21, 2023 @01:48AM (#37593664)
That surprises me. The legislation in the form I last saw it says that they're not allowed to show user generated content to children without an age-gated login.
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by ben_w on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:16AM (#37594217)
Your understanding of the law may be correct, but do remember that law is basically its own language with its own ideas of "common sense" and that if you're not legally trained (and even if you are but you've not read all the other laws that the law in question interacts with) then all sorts of weird misunderstandings can happen.

(As your profile is empty, for all I know you've an actual lawyer in this specific field — NH is this kind of place after all — but most of us aren't, and I've been surprised by legal principles that LegalEagle has described as "law school 101, and I mean literally I taught XYZ in a 101 class").

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by awei on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:36AM (#37598257)
Thanks for your replies.
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by lynx23 on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:33AM (#37593243)
There you go. GDPR already made companies stop providing to users based on their location. This trend will likely continue.
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by jackjeff on Thursday September 21, 2023 @01:48AM (#37593667)
How would these extra territorial laws be enforced?

I mean I break Chinese law all the time; I have a blog without the necessary permits delivered by the PRC bureaucracy.

How is this UK law any different? Unless you have some kind of tie to the UK why should you care? What are they going to do? They can’t fine you nor put you in jail. Are they going to block your sites? Then everybody in the UK will use VPNs (just like China) undermining the ability of the government to enforce such laws even further.

GDPR was a EU law (much bigger than UK), it was not as tedious to comply with, and the PR would have been bad for any company breaching it. None of this is true here. The PR is actually good if you don’t follow this law; you can say you’re defending human rights and stuff.

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by toyg on Thursday September 21, 2023 @02:08AM (#37593802)
If you're not in the UK and not using major services, yes, you don't have to care. The problem is basically that the major services will likely have to comply, because they do have a sizeable UK presence they'll want to maintain, hence they will introduce anti-features that basically ruin it for everyone. And if they do comply, it gives rope for the government to go after smaller players that don't.

As a UK resident, I hope this will go the way of anti-piracy legislation - i.e. enforced against big services only while everyone else just continues to do whatever they want.

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by saithound on Thursday September 21, 2023 @02:16AM (#37593852)
How was Saudi law enforced on Jamal Khasogghi? How was Indian law enforced on Hardeep Nijjar?

If the law won't be enforced on you in particular, it's because the UK government does not care enough to enforce it on you in particular. It has very little to do with where you live or what courts have "jurisdiction" over you.

I doubt that social media execs would avoid traveling to the UK of all places in order to not piss off the handful (and I say this as a long-time EFF member) of people who really care about this law. To make things worse, major services tend to have presence in almost every country, especially the UK, and leadership tend to have personal connections and property in these places. They will just comply (as long as not offering their service in certain locations is an acceptabpe form of compliance, they might opt to do that if the financial calculus works out, but it's not necessarily an option at all). They don't even have to go straight to physical or financial punishment: if a service accept any kind of payment, they can get compliance by ezerting influence through various international card networks as well. If they don't have to comply, and can keep offering their service anyway, it's only because the UK didn't squeeze hard enough: but they could, and if they do, there'll be nothing your government or geographical location will do to protect you.

There is no such thing as a sovereign entity "not having jurisdiction" over you: that wpuld be a complete oxymoron. If they don't make you comply with their orders, it's only because some economic factor prevents them from doing so.

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by b800h on Thursday September 21, 2023 @02:05AM (#37593779)
All it'll do is kill off small businesses and hobby projects in the UK. I'm furious about it; the idiots just made BBSes, MUDs, Git and Telnet illegal. The big companies get regulatory capture of all social communications.
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by alphager on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:03AM (#37594119)
The same way the US prevents me from buying cuban cigars here in Germany over the internet:

* execs are liable for breaches of the law if/when they travel to the US. * companies in the US are forbidden to do business with companies in Germany that breach the US law

There are a handful of small companies doing direct sales that are small enough that they do not have US partners. The rest complies because doing otherwise is financially disadvantageous.

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by baloki on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:40AM (#37594395)
They block your site at the ISP level. They’ve been doing that for years.

They’d fine you as well but that’s probably less enforceable.

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by corobo on Thursday September 21, 2023 @07:24AM (#37596040)
Honestly I'm considering blocking UK users to avoid this hassle, and I live here.

I'm on board with GDPR, this one's just a waste of time.

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by jauntywundrkind on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:47AM (#37593328)
There's zero justification for this other than petty shitty overly-grandiose images of national self importance. And ultimately this will be crushed.

Your citizens do not carry all their national laws with them wherever they go. They have to obey other nation's laws if they travel.

I have choice words for nations that think they can legislate afar as they please when it's over the internet (authoritarian loser prats, to get started). Zero compunctions about it, but if your citizens are travelling over the internet afar: that does not make services on the other side subject to your law. Your people have left your national network & gone to other nations. Your jurisdiction is over; get over it.

The Manifesto of Independence of Cyberspace seems ever increasingly likely to be buttressed & supported by some 101 level common sense, by the basic idea that not every nation can or should be able to bully every other entity anywhere in earth as their unilateral legislature says so. It's sad to me that nations are in a race to reductio ad absurdum prove how incompetent authoritarian useless & unable-to-recognize-any-limit they are, as if in a mad quest to force the Independence of Cyberspace merely by way of being such utter preposterous useless tool bags they are. But here we are and here the UK and dozens of other nations are pretending like they can tell everyone else on the internet what they have to do. Pathetic.

You're wrong and well disconnect you. And you deserve no better. Your self inflated Idiocracy deserves no treating with; get over yourself. Or you merely get yourself off the internet & so sadly be it. Please don't.

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by dang on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:51AM (#37593355)
Please make your substantive points without fulminating. It's always possible, and it's in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by jauntywundrkind on Thursday September 21, 2023 @02:11AM (#37593812)
I think I made a clear & great case. You've flagged & silenced 4 counter replies (edit: ok, 2/4 were new account shills). You are wrong & silencing, again, as usual.

Why do you disagree? Stake in. Disagree specifically, in accordance with your own rules. Your complaints are generic & boring. And my point is real & argued sides. This seems obviously true & real & 900% pertinent. Piss on this. Don't insult me like this, with zero effort. To describe a bad situation accurately should not drag like this.

These people & their actions are abominable & over stretched. They have zero willingness to respect any limitations to how far they can legislate & that's the core of what I said & is necessary & real commentary, is the heart of this disaster. If that commentary isnt welcome here's be honest about it. Dissembling is shit.

It seems self evident what is say. Nations keep expecting they can make laws that apply wherever their citizens travel online. That's the headline. It's 100% accurate & entirely the topic of discussion. That's the insanity here. This isn't fulminating. How dare you try to bleep this out? What gross bias. Damn you dan g. This is a hell. I can't remotely see how you can protest that. Get a grip dude.

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by dang on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:40AM (#37594387)
Users flagged those comments; mods didn't touch them.
Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by jauntywundrkind on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:02PM (#37602414)
Understood. I will work harder to try to insure my behavior always/consistently remains acceptable.

It grates on me that discussions on national issues seems to be extra heavily shut down, and the yolk of moderation & being rate limited is an unceasing aggravation. But I will try to up my expectation of myself at all points, including my weakest.

I wish there was some credit gained for being a good community poster, which I think I generally am. The only presence I see or feel is negative actions, is presence when things go bad. It's a one way relationship over only bad things.

Re:The UK Parliament Undermined the Privacy, Security, and F... by dang on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:29PM (#37602888)
Yes, that's true - moderation is mostly about the worst things users do, and the good things don't generally outweigh the bad. To put it in a silly way, no number of old ladies helped across the street makes it ok to rob a bank or run someone else over.

You raise a good question though - if there were nice feedback for doing good things, maybe it would encourage more good things.