News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by josephcsible on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @08:33PM (#37591860)
With the "never break userspace" guarantee, is there ever a reason to want to be on an LTS kernel instead of the latest stable one, other than proprietary kernel modules?
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by craftkiller on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @08:51PM (#37591967)
Yes, ZFS. When new, incompatible kernels are released the dkms build for the ZFS kernel modules will fail. By switching to an LTS kernel, I no longer have to worry because my kernel lags so far behind.

The alternative is using a pre-built package repo which will prevent the kernel from updating to an incompatible version using the package dependencies. I lived that way for years and it is an awful experience.

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by XorNot on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @09:53PM (#37592381)
As a ZFS user, this really isn't a good enough reason IMO. Never break userspace really should be enough for most people.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by phone8675309 on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:52PM (#37593028)
This wouldn't be a problem if OpenZFS didn't have a dogshit license.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by craftkiller on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:55PM (#37593055)
The same could be said for Linux. This isn't a problem on FreeBSD.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by josephcsible on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:04AM (#37593099)
> The same could be said for Linux.

No, because the CDDL was intentionally written to be incompatible with the GPL.

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by craftkiller on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:13AM (#37593141)
The original intent of the license authors is irrelevant. The aspect of the CDDL that makes it incompatible with GPL is present in the GPL too. Neither license is more or less "dogshit" than the other, they are the same. The difference is the CDDL only applies to code written under the CDDL, whereas the GPL spreads to everything it touches.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by ghaff on Thursday September 21, 2023 @01:52AM (#37593692)
And different people remember or choose to interpret the original intent differently.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by xorcist on Thursday September 21, 2023 @04:15AM (#37594679)
If Linux had been under the CDDL, ZFS would have chosen another license. Sun management at the time saw Linux as their primary competitor, and ZFS and DTrace was the crown jewels of Solaris. Just open sourcing was reported to have been a long internal struggle by the people involved, and there's no chance they would have let the Linux distributors use them for free.

Good or bad, it's the result of another era. Still impressive stuff. It's only recently that things like btrfs and eBPF became usable enough, and not in all situations.

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by pabs3 on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:18AM (#37596521)
That aspect of the GPL is what any software end-user should want, all the source code, for every part of what you are using.

It is a shame Oracle hasn't released a CDDLv2 that provides GPL compatibility, they could solve the incompatibility quite easily, since CDDLv1 has an auto-update clause by default. I think some of OpenZFS has CDDLv1-only code, but that could probably be removed or replaced.

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by bananapub on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:59AM (#37596984)
> The original intent of the license authors is irrelevant.

what on earth is that supposed to mean? ZFS is not in the Linux kernel because Sun and then Oracle deliberately decided to do that and continue to want that to be the case. The Linux kernel can't be re-licensed, (the Oracle and Sun code in) ZFS could be relicenced in ten minutes if they cared.

> The aspect of the CDDL that makes it incompatible with GPL is present in the GPL too. Neither license is more or less "dogshit" than the other, they are the same. The difference is the CDDL only applies to code written under the CDDL, whereas the GPL spreads to everything it touches.

lol

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by craftkiller on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:13PM (#37599815)
> what on earth is that supposed to mean?

It means that the original authors could have originally intended to write a recipe for chocolate chip cookies and somehow accidentally wrote the CDDL. That wouldn't change a thing and it wouldn't make the CDDL any better or worse since it would have exactly the same words. The intent is irrelevant, all that matters is the end result.

> ZFS could be relicenced in ten minutes if they cared.

Indeed, I hope that they do. A copyfree license like the BSD licenses would make ZFS significantly more popular and I think would have saved all the effort sunk into btrfs had it been done earlier.

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by kaylynb on Thursday September 21, 2023 @01:56AM (#37593713)
Sometimes breaking changes for ZFS are backported to LTS anyway.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by craftkiller on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:24PM (#37599992)
Oh :-\ Thanks for the warning, I guess I'll have to remain vigilant. Switching to LTS certainly significantly reduces the frequency of incompatibilities, so I'm definitely going to remain on it, but I guess its not the perfect fix I thought it was.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by raverbashing on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:41AM (#37594408)
As opposed to what ZFS users think, very few people care about it

And in mobile, I'd say the amount goes to zero

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by Jhsto on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @09:35PM (#37592280)
GPU applications are often less buggy on LTS (kernel, but also package sets)
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by josephcsible on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:39PM (#37592954)
Isn't the reason for kernel-related bugginess in GPU applications usually the out-of-tree proprietary GPU driver kernel module?
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by baq on Thursday September 21, 2023 @02:46AM (#37593998)
GPU drivers are routinely the biggest chunk of the kernel (both source and runtime) and have the most surface area to have bugs in them regardless of their openness.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by sambazi on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:11AM (#37594174)
came to say the same.

i absolutely despise breakage and random changes in my desktop environment

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by o11c on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:42PM (#37592973)
Some kind of breakage is pretty common in random recent kernels. It might not affect you this time, but do you really want to risk it?

So yes - you do want to be on an LTS kernel. But you only need to stay there for about a year until the next one is released and you can test it for a bit before deploying.

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by josephcsible on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:44AM (#37593306)
> do you really want to risk it?

That question applies to LTS kernels too. Do you really want to risk that a backport of an important fix won't introduce a problem that mainline didn't have? Do you really want to risk that there are no security vulnerabilities in old kernels that won't get noticed by maintainers since they were incidentally fixed by some non-security-related change in mainline?

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by sambazi on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:08AM (#37594148)
so you want to trade in tailored and curated fixes in lts for acccidental and experimental fixes in bleeding-edge.

go ahead

Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by josephcsible on Thursday September 21, 2023 @11:06AM (#37598740)
My work uses "tailored and curated fixes in lts" and at home I use "acccidental and experimental fixes in bleeding-edge". I've had way more stuff break because of the former than because of the latter, and not just with the kernel.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by xorcist on Thursday September 21, 2023 @04:06AM (#37594597)
Lots of third party software hooks the kernel for various things, such as drivers for enterprise RAID or proprietary networking, and whatever it is Nvidia does these days. Those go far beyond the user space interface and are dependent on binaries staying unchanged. This is for them.

If you are running user space applications only on upstream supported hardware, there is no reason to stay with long time supported kernels, just follow the regular stable which is much easier for everyone.