Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi...
by eastbound on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @02:58PM
(#37588458)
> Unless you are willing to tolerate false negatives
We tolerate false negative all the time: Terrorism is not eradicated at all in UK. Barring successful results, the police should stop harassing people.
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi...
by hardlianotion on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @03:05PM
(#37588565)
I don't think we do tolerate false negatives, for this class of thing, all the time.
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi...
by sokoloff on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @05:30PM
(#37590472)
Terrorists passed checkpoints today and we tolerated it. Terrorists passed checkpoints yesterday and we tolerated it. Terrorists passed checkpoints the day before that...
The complete elimination of false negatives for rare occurrences is prohibitively expensive to the liberty of non-terrorists.
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi...
by EvgeniyZh on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @09:32PM
(#37592261)
Being unable to eradicate something is not the same as to tolerate it.
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi...
by burnished on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @03:02PM
(#37588524)
Probably important to note that this leads to tests not being performed without good reason because they cause more harm than they do good due to the false positive rate.
Let's say there are 10 million people linked to terrorism in the world and the system is correct 95% of times. Then out of 20000 people, 20 are positives, and 19 will be stopped; out of 19980 negatives, 999 will be stopped.
Compared to disease testing you may argue that FP is more harmful, but that's a different question. The point is that even very non-random system will be dominated by FP.
Edit: in particular, if they stop truly random people and 500 of them are linked to terrorism that implies that 20% of all people passing there are terrorists.