News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Cheq UPI (YC S23) – India's first payments app f... by kylehotchkiss on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @07:43PM (#37578633)
You guys need to try, try, try to figure this out without the passport verification. I've spent a lot of visits to India and having to hand my passport to some local shopkeeper feels like an invitation for identity theft. People who grew up in the USA have been told their whole lives to protect their documents and this is a pretty big leap of faith for little benefit over grabbing cash from the ATM.

Edit: to be more helpful, a system like this would be more exciting for me - Upload the passport in app, the passport is verified only by a salaried and background-checked (you know, like a police clearance certificate) staff that is a employee of your company (not a third party or contractor). Have a clearly written policy about record keeping, security of the storage, pursue legal charges against employees who don't adhere to privacy policy. Etc.

Re:Show HN: Cheq UPI (YC S23) – India's first payments app f... by sudshekhar on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @08:04PM (#37578788)
Hey Kyle,

We have to do the passport verification since we're providing you with a prepaid wallet, which can be used to store funds and make purchases in India.

Companies like Wise power Remittances i.e. you can send money to a person in India from USA using their facilities.

However, this cannot be used to make purchases from merchants. Nor are you guaranteed your money will be delivered within 2 minutes in case of cross-border remittance.

Because Cheq actually opens a new Indian wallet, we must do the passport verification. Regulations are pretty specific in this regard currently.

Rest assured though, when you try to open your Cheq wallet today, your details will only ever be seen by White collared staff on direct Payroll of Transcorp. The agent only takes a photo of your passport for our records (no paper copies of your details are stored).

We'll keep trying to improve the onboarding experience in the coming years for sure.

Re:Show HN: Cheq UPI (YC S23) – India's first payments app f... by wmf on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @08:57PM (#37579164)
There are KYC APIs that can do identity verification for you.
Re:Show HN: Cheq UPI (YC S23) – India's first payments app f... by kobiguru on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @01:27AM (#37580676)
Fintech in India is hard by design. harder still when it involves cross boarder payments. I trust what they are saying about RBI regulations, not following them to the letter means death.
Re:Show HN: Cheq UPI (YC S23) – India's first payments app f... by kylehotchkiss on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @07:50PM (#37578690)
FWIW, you have a competitor who could very well figure out a UPI payments piece shortly (they don't seem to support the QR codes piece yet) (https://wise.com/in/blog/send-money-to-india-with-upi) and they have built in passport verification without the shopkeeper & scanner part. It'd be good to start without the rigidity of that step.
Re:Show HN: Cheq UPI (YC S23) – India's first payments app f... by KomoD on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @07:58PM (#37578749)
Wise supports UPI? Great, way more trustworthy than this
Re:Show HN: Cheq UPI (YC S23) – India's first payments app f... by kylehotchkiss on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @08:04PM (#37578792)
Apple appears to be trying to talk about implementing some form of UPI too! https://techcrunch.com/2023/06/22/apple-looks-to-resume-talk...
Re:Show HN: Cheq UPI (YC S23) – India's first payments app f... by sudshekhar on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @08:05PM (#37578797)
Wise UPI can only be used to send money to third parties.

You cannot use them to make everyday purchases. And there's no guarantee by when the recipient will receive money.