The current iteration of the internet (more specifically social media) has used the same rationality for its existence but at a level, society has proven itself too irresponsible and/or lazy to think for itself but be fed by the machine. What makes you think LLMs are going to do anything but make the situation worse? If anything, they’re going to reenforce whatever biases were baked into the training material, of which is now legally dubious.
Yeah, I mean, so can I, as long as you don't care whether the answers you receive are accurate or not. The LLM is just better at pretending it knows quantum mechanics than I am.
The best way to use an LLM for learning is to ask a question, assume it's getting things wrong, and use that to probe your knowledge which you can iteratively use to prove the LLM's knowledge. Human experts don't put up with that and are a much more limited resource.
LLMs (Current-generation and UI/UX ones at least) will tell you all sorts of incorrect "facts" just because "these words go next to each other lots" with a great amount of gusto and implied authority.
Maybe they’re just orders of magnitude more useful at the beginning of a career, when it’s more important to digest and distill readily-available information than to come up with original solutions to edge cases or solve gnarly puzzles?
Maybe I also simply don’t write enough code anymore :)
Just yesterday, I asked if Typescript has the concept of a "late" type, similar to Dart, because I didn't want to annotate a type with "| null" when I knew it would be bound before it was used. Searching for info would have taken me much longer than asking the LLM, and the LLM was able to frame the answer from a Dart perspective.
I would say that that information neither "important to digest" nor "readily available."
For me, it's been able to give very good answers when they were within the first few Google results when searched for using the proper terms (but the value is in giving you these terms in the first place!).
For questions from my field, it's been wildly hallucinating and producing half-truths, outdated information, or complete nonsense. Which is also fair, because the documentation where the answers could be found is often proprietary, and even then it's either outdated or outright wrong half of the time :)
We can generate thoughts that are spatially coherent, time aware, validated for correctness and a whole bunch of other qualities that LLMs cannot do.
Why would LLMs be the model for human thought, when it does not come close to the thoughts humans can do every minute of every day?
Aren't we all just stochastic parrots, is the kind of question that requires answering an awful lot about the universe before you get to an answer.
But sometimes we're more than that: Some types of deep understanding aren't verbal or language-based, and I suspect that these are the ones that LLMs will have the hardest time getting good at. That's not to say that no AI will get there at all, but I think it'll need something fundamentally different from LLMs.
For what it's worth, I've personally changed my mind here: I used to think that the level of language proficiency that LLMs demonstrate easily would only be possible using an AGI. Apparently that's not the case.
The LLM is the most powerful knowledge tool ever to exist. It is both a librarian in your pocket. It is an expert in everything, it has read everything, and can answer your specific questions on any conceivable topic.
Yes it has no concept of human value and the current generation hallucinates and/or is often wrong, but the responsibility for the output should be the user's, not the LLM's.
Do not let these tools be owned, crushed and controlled by the same people who are driving us towards WW3 and cooking the planet for cash. This is the most powerful knowledge tool ever. Democratize it.