News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by vincentkriek on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:04AM (#37556272)
I think a country can not exist with just big cities, or at least it should not be forced to. Small towns will always be more expensive than cities to maintain, this should not mean that small towns should then get less facilities.

It's the equality vs equity discussion based in geography

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by justin66 on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:37AM (#37556699)
[delayed]
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by dukeyukey on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:11AM (#37556356)
> I think a country can not exist with just big cities

Singapore is just a city. Hong Kong for a long time too. The Netherlands is functionally a very large low-density city with some high-density parts. And in some countries, like Saudi Arabia and the UAE, the small towns are economically non-existent compared to the cities.

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by kalleboo on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:30AM (#37556613)
Singapore relies on Malaysia (hmm wonder when and why Malaya picked up that "sia"); Hong Kong relies on China; the Netherlands relies on the EU.

Which of their neighbors do you think Japan is safe to rely on to feed their population?

edit: Note that China just the other day extended their 9-dash line to a 10-dash line

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by vincentkriek on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:18AM (#37556434)
I live in The Netherlands and it's not functionally a very large low density city. The main part of the country (de randstad [1]), but the rest isn't. And we need to pay to make sure there are facilities there, the government currently is just draining the natural resources and giving nothing in return.

I don't know how a large country functions, but for the Netherlands there is a clear need to invest more in the rest of the country.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randstad

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by Cthulhu_ on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:50AM (#37556905)
I don't live in the Randstad but I'm sure in some years everything will have closed up.

One thing I will say though is that the area outside of it - pick any direction - is idyllic and doesn't seem to be struggling economically. Loads of local businesses, loads of people just going about their day, buying houses, having kids, etc. It's idyllic and I don't really understand why all the activity seems to be in the Randstad.

I mean I do get it, it's a chicken / egg problem; talent travels to the cities because that's where the best jobs are, the best jobs go to the cities because that's where talent is.

But I would like the government to incentivize more "work where you live" schemes; smaller sattelite offices for larger employers, remote work (obviously), extra income and subsidies if you work remotely (because of reduced office costs and to discourage commuting, since our roads and railways are all full up).

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by CalRobert on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:25AM (#37557493)
I think part of the issue is that if you're a couple there's a huge advantage to being within commute distance from multiple cities.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by BytesAndGears on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:38PM (#37559295)
I totally agree about how the lower investment in the non-Randstad parts of the country does not seem to have a negative affect. At least the further-away cities/towns that I’ve visited have been absolutely gorgeous. People are friendly, streets are clean, parks are well-kept, public transportation is world-class even in small towns.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by CalRobert on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:24AM (#37557471)
Bit of devil's advocate here, but would it make more sense to invest heavily in the Randstad so that more people can live there and enjoy the benefits of being in a heavily networked area?

I just moved to the Netherlands (in the Randstad) and it's arguably better for the country that I moved to a place that already is dense and efficient to provide services to. Though it would be nice if it were above sea level.

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by dukeyukey on Monday September 18, 2023 @12:52PM (#37558701)
In this case it's more that almost the entire country is within a couple of hours of the Randstad. The whole country can act as a single economic unit, which isn't doable even in Germany, France, and the UK, let alone Canada or China. You can drive or take the train from Groningen to Eindhoven and back in a single working day with hours to spare; you can't even do that between Toulouse and Marseille, let alone further!

If anything it's a good thing - it means investment in Amsterdam benefits far more people than just those in Amsterdam.

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by anigbrowl on Monday September 18, 2023 @02:41PM (#37560219)
The problem with these examples is they're heavily skewed once a single metric, eg small land area (Singapore, HK, Netherlands) or extreme resource disparity (SA & UAE). Generalizing from outlier examples is rarely a good idea.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by dukeyukey on Monday September 18, 2023 @03:56PM (#37561152)
Pretty much by definition a country with no small towns in gonna be all city. Those are necessarily outliers.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by irrational on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:05AM (#37556285)
Why can a country not exist with just big cities?
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by kalleboo on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:40AM (#37556751)
Outsourcing some things can be an existential threat

edit: Note that China just the other day extended their 9-dash line to a 10-dash line

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by johannes1234321 on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:09AM (#37556330)
Countries can exist with only big cities, but then they are dependant on other countries.

In small cities you among other things have more agriculture and different forms of industry are also commonly pushed out of big cities.

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by 5e92cb50239222b on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:16AM (#37556420)
Because you really don't want heavily polluting industries (oil refineries, chemical plants, steel mills, etc) close to a big city.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by justin66 on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:32AM (#37556640)
Name a big city that doesn't have heavily polluting industries nearby.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by irrational on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:23AM (#37557467)
Portland, Oregon?
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by justin66 on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:46AM (#37557824)
I don't know why you'd pose that as a question, but not having been to Portland I did the obvious thing and spent a minute in google maps. You're welcome. It turns out Portland has a steel mill not just nearby, but within its city limits.

At the risk of stating the obvious, the point of my question wasn't to literally determine whether any big cities exist without heavy industry nearby, although that would be sort of interesting if it were the case. The point is that any such city is going to be an exception to the utterly ludicrous statement of the OP, "Because you really don't want heavily polluting industries (oil refineries, chemical plants, steel mills, etc) close to a big city." Big cities have always had this. The people there do not "want" them there any more or less than people in a small town would "want" them there.

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by claudiulodro on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:08PM (#37558896)
Hopefully not too pedantic, but they do have Precision Castparts, which manufactures all sorts of aerospace, wind turbine, and other giant industrial things: https://www.opb.org/article/2022/03/02/court-approves-225-mi...
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by matheusmoreira on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:19AM (#37556451)
Agriculture.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by ThrowawayR2 on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:03AM (#37557098)
It can but then they are heavily dependent on external sources of food, water, raw materials, manufactured products, etc. that are outside of its control. This gives the outside nations who are supplying those things larger influence on the domestic and foreign policy of the city-state because they can raise costs of imports or even embargo them to pressure the city-state to align with their own foreign policy goals.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by anigbrowl on Monday September 18, 2023 @02:50PM (#37560342)
Why aren't obese people healthy? they have so much (cellular) wealth stored up and such big organs.

Ir's not that different. If you concentrate economic wealth in cites, the periphery starts to suffer economically because it can't exploit local resources effectively, and the population starts selecting for city activity. Over generations, that leaves you vulnerable agriculturally and militarily. If you experience a natural or military disaster that deals a massive blow to one of you key cities, the whole country can collapse.

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by zeroCalories on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:18AM (#37556432)
No one is forcing small towns to stop existing. Young people just don't want to live in them. And yes, I do think they should get fewer facilities because they can't afford them. I'm sure every geriatric town would love a world class cancer treatment center, but they're gonna have to suck it up.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by skhr0680 on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:26AM (#37556550)
> Young people just don't want to live in them.

That's why the hometown tax exists. Small towns use their residence tax money to raise children then none goes back in when the young adult moves to Tokyo and pays residence tax there instead of in their hometown.

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by zeroCalories on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:34AM (#37556661)
Schools are funded by the national government in Japan. These families are not a net-loss on the community, as the parents pay taxes and children are a driver of economic activity.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by kalleboo on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:38AM (#37556729)
Births are funded by local governments though
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by zeroCalories on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:49AM (#37556886)
Isn't that all covered by the national government and parent?
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by innocenat on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:59AM (#37557042)
Contary to the name, Japan National Health Insurance is managed at municipal level.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by zeroCalories on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:13AM (#37557261)
TIL. Seems like it's a mix between national and municipal funding, but that doesn't really change the overall calculation, as the parents will have most likely paid it back through their own municipal taxes.
Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by sokoloff on Monday September 18, 2023 @12:06PM (#37558117)
> Small towns will always be more expensive than cities to maintain, this should not mean that small towns should then get less facilities.

Why not? I think it's a natural conclusion of that fact.

Should every small town have a Tier 1 Hospital? A world-class university? A national sports team & stadium? An international airport? A symphony orchestra?

Don't get me wrong, I grew up in a rural area and have a fondness for it, but I do expect that rural areas should reasonably have less facilities than major cities.

Re:Japan's Hometown Tax by uncletaco on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:38PM (#37559292)
> Should every small town have a Tier 1 Hospital? A world-class university? A national sports team & stadium? An international airport? A symphony orchestra?

This almost describes Alabama.