Re:How the Mac didn’t bring programming to the people
by nuancebydefault on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:36PM
(#37549587)
Indeed I think Jobs approach to software dev was too far ahead of time, Gates pragmatic approach proved to have more leverage for computer/platform sales and growth.
Re:How the Mac didn’t bring programming to the people
by Nevermark on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:07AM
(#37552438)
And greater innovation in the application space.
Not that there wasn’t innovation on the Mac, but not as much, and often in the end, not as successful.
Re:How the Mac didn’t bring programming to the people
by wkat4242 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:57PM
(#37550170)
I don't think closed app stores are the answer. It doesn't actually prevent malware.
Much better is a genuine permissions system that the user controls and the apps can't circumvent.
The reason closed app stores are so popular isn't because of security but because everyone wants a finger in that sweet 30% take pie.
Re:How the Mac didn’t bring programming to the people
by fulladder on Sunday September 17, 2023 @07:10PM
(#37550262)
I agree with you 100%. I think maybe the problem is that the platform vendors think it's too difficult to explain fine-grained access controls to end users, whereas an app store is dead simple to explain. And, as you observe, an app store makes money whereas ACLs do not.
Re:How the Mac didn’t bring programming to the people
by fragmede on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:51PM
(#37562576)
In the present era, running random code is trivial - JavaScript, via a web browser. It runs in a sandbox, which limits what it can do, but it's a really big sandbox and you can do really useful things within it.
As I say in another comment, I think Gates's view was right for that time. The Jobs view was needlessly limiting the potential market for his machines. Gates didn't make the machine, but he was making a thing that was sold with every machine, and he understood that more apps means more reasons why people might want to buy a PC.
One problem with the Gates view today is that if you make it easy for anyone to write and distribute any kind of app, you end up with not only a lot of low-quality software but even negative-quality software like ransomware and malware. It's surprising the so many people want to write that stuff, but apparently they do. Every modern platform, including Windows, has gone to extreme lengths to block this stuff, even though the more laissez-faire approach would be to just ignore it and assume other 3rd parties will write programs to block it. The problem was that malware was an existential threat to the entire Windows platform, and Microsoft couldn't afford to just let the market sort that one out.
I believe the Jobs view is the correct one for the present era. Every platform has app stores, code signing, DRM, and other kinds of security and non-security restrictions. It's certainly easier to run random code on Windows 10 than macOS Ventura (or especially iOS), but no platform vendor is completely app neutral these days.