Re:NASA clears the air: No evidence that UFOs are aliens
by pvg on Saturday September 16, 2023 @03:01PM
(#37537605)
tptacek is right that invocations of Galileo of that sort are usually a trope but a great thing about the trope (and about Galileo!) is that it almost always falls apart and argues against the point the trope-invoker is making. In your case - Galileo did not 'find the rings of Saturn'. He made some rather anomalous observations of Saturn which he could not explain. He published a 'claim hash' (in the parlance of our times) of his observation.
Galileo was one of the earliest practitioners of what we now call scientific method and even with that disadvantage, he was way better at simply making claims than the UFOlogists we're talking about here.
Re:NASA clears the air: No evidence that UFOs are aliens
by david-gpu on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:40AM
(#37543561)
Let me simplify the idea so that we don't get caught up in historical debates: we won't move beyond anecdotal evidence of UAPs unless our academic institutions start looking for them systematically and/or we reach out to our elected representatives to declassify/release whatever data the DoD has already collected.
Re:NASA clears the air: No evidence that UFOs are aliens
by tptacek on Sunday September 17, 2023 @12:15PM
(#37546633)
That's true of UAPs, but it's also true in the exact same way of Stargates; we'll never dig one up if we don't look for them systematically.
I know that's neither here nor there; it's a critique of a particular argument, but obviously doesn't settle the underlying question.
What I'm trying to say is that I get where you are coming from, and I know you will get over it eventually. Take good care my friend.