News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Impending Crypto Monoculture (2016) by Animats on Friday September 15, 2023 @02:31PM (#37527310)
Demonstrably, the most secure cryptosystems today are the one that secures Bitcoin. If that could be cracked, or even work-reduced, someone would be a multi-billionaire, and the transfers would be noticed. Since that hasn't happened, we can have some confidence in those cryptosystems.
Re:On the Impending Crypto Monoculture (2016) by pvg on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:06PM (#37528486)
Why would that be the case specifically for bitcoin? Lots of cryptography secures things far more valuable than bitcoin and breaks in bitcoin would reduce its value to zero unlike many of the other things protected by cryptography.
Re:On the Impending Crypto Monoculture (2016) by tptacek on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:12PM (#37528564)
I assume that the argument is that a break in secp256k1 has an especially straightforward monetization, where breaking the cryptography in TLS, while much more destabilizing to the Internet and the things running on it, wouldn't immediately net you a bunch of cash, but rather would just enable further attacks that might get you that.
Re:On the Impending Crypto Monoculture (2016) by pvg on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:40PM (#37528830)
Ah, I see, thanks. Somewhat reminiscent of 'why waste 0-days stealing WoW gold'. Still feels like the argument is complicated up by things like Very Lorge or State Actors (to whomst money is not even money, as you like to point out) and that the value they seek to derive is also not necessarily financial or at least not immediately so. Like, surely more effort has been spent trying to break TLS than secp256k1 specifically.
Re:On the Impending Crypto Monoculture (2016) by Animats on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:34PM (#37528777)
> I assume that the argument is that a break in secp256k1 has an especially straightforward monetization

Exactly. Considering the sheer effort put into Bitcoin, including volume manufacture of custom ICs, if this was possible, someone would have done it by now. It wouldn't even be illegal.

Re:On the Impending Crypto Monoculture (2016) by tptacek on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:41PM (#37528850)
What I think your analysis misses is that the security of a cryptosystem isn't an absolute thing. All sorts of cryptosystems exist that haven't been broken, and may never be broken, but would likely get someone else broken if emulated in a different setting. So the reason cryptography engineers probably wouldn't use ECDSA in a modern signing system, if they had a choice, is that ECDSA includes a bunch of footguns that better signing systems avoid.
Re:On the Impending Crypto Monoculture (2016) by tptacek on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:11PM (#37528549)
I think you'll find most cryptography engineers wouldn't reach first for secp256k1, or for the ECDSA signing system, regardless of their success in Bitcoin.