Seems to me that at some point we need to start focusing on parents and families instead of the schools themselves.
Clearly the educational system works reasonably well if the students have certain characteristics (wealthy, well-educated parents for one). So maybe we should be asking how can we "fake" those attributes for the students who don't have them?
It's not an easy problem to solve either way, of course. But after you've retooled the school system over and over for decades, trying a different approach seems only logical...
For the record, I went to school in a 3rd world country, where many of my classmate's parents could neither read nor write, and that did not seem to adversely affect their performances, because our teachers actually taught.
I agree that the vitriolic "blame the parents" rhetoric is just as harmful as the "blame the teachers", "blame the unions", "blame the evolutionists" and all the other misguided rhetoric out there.
That being said, when you take two schools that do the same things, one where the kids come from affluent and well-educated families and the other where the kids aren't sure if they'll get dinner each night, the differences are obvious. The rich(er) kids almost always do better.
I don't think we need to "blame" anyone. In fact, I don't even know if there is anyone to blame. What I meant by my comment was that we've fiddled with the curriculum and the schools constantly for decades and it doesn't really seem to matter much, so perhaps we ought to start looking at other options. Let the teachers teach and see if we can solve some of the performance issues at the other end.
For example, maybe college-educated parents are able to help their kids with homework more effectively. Then we should provide more tutoring outside of school.
Or, maybe wealthier families are more likely to be able to provide kids with a quiet place to do their homework and study. Then we ought to be building libraries in poor neighborhoods.
Heck, I've even read that where you build the school buildings can make a difference. Building them in town, rather than out in a corn field somewhere outside of town being better for community cohesion. This could certainly be a salient issue in rural areas.
I really don't know what the problem is, or how to fix it, but it seems pretty clear to me that we should be looking beyond just the schools themselves when we talk about "fixing" the education system.
P.S. The school lunch program and Head Start were actually intended to target these sorts of issues. Not sure how successful they were. I seem to recall reading that Head Start ended up being a failure overall.
They have to decide between being lying about their losses or fire a bunch of people and possibly have their hedge funds shut down.
I'm not a trader, but I have heard a few traders talk about this. I think it's sort of like what happens quite often between an investor and his fund: he makes some proclamations that are impractical and the market doesn't cooperate, and some significant portion of the employees just smile and nod but ignore it and keep collecting their base/bonus. So in this case, they feel they are forced to commit fraud and hide their losses.
I think that probably there are some desks in well-run firms where profits are high and traders don't run into these issues that they consider moral dilemmas. The managers and traders in those firms may say the other traders deserved to be fired based on their losses, but those privileged traders aren't aware of the disadvantages that the other traders are working against and don't realize the market simply moved against them.
Just thought I'd apply the same logic to another profession, albeit a profession for which most people hold few positive feelings.
The standards schools are being measured against (and rewarded or punished for their performance relative to) are far less objective than "made or lost money". You have not applied the same logic to a different profession, because it misses out on the fundamental point of the comment you are parodying - that the standard is, in many cases, judging the schools wrongly.
The dilemma is not whether or not to lie about failing. The dilemma is whether or not to lie about a shitty metric that _says_ you are failing when you can see clearly that you are not.
I'm not going to make a claim one way or another about what I think of that argument. I'm just pointing out that the argument you are parodying is not the one you appear to think it is.
And yes, there is a "subculture of traders who feel that the policies enforced by Risk are hurting profits and unfair to traders." Actually it's not so much a subculture as the dominant culture.
To reflect back across the metaphor, in the education world the "risk guys" are a single group of people at a national entity most people already don't trust to manage money, and they are unilaterally declaring the standards for _everyone's_ risk.
Also, rather than saying well-run firm which would imply an equivalence with school, it would make more sense to say that the internet coming into the firm only works part of the day in some places versus perfectly in others.
Also teachers are being measured on the basis of their students' performance, not the stock market. Students aren't like a stock market. Teachers can't pick their students, for one thing. Also, students are people.
Hedge funds are sort of a betting game designed to make money from money or gaming strategy rather than actual contribution to society. Teaching is about creating the next generation of minds.
Also, this situation is more like one guy at the SEC or something deciding exactly what formulas can be used to change the portfolios for all of the funds in the United States and then firing people if they don't perform. Its ludicrous.
That said, cheating is terrible. It will create even more unrealistic expectations and the more unrealistic things become, the more honest people will be weeded out.
I would guess that there is a subculture of school administrators who feel that No Child Left Behind etc. are hurting curriculum and unfair to teachers and schools.
They have to decide between being honest about their scores or firing a bunch of teachers and/or possibly having their schools shut down, and/or having class sizes they can't cope with due to the need to hold back huge numbers of students.
I'm not a teacher but I have heard a few teachers talk about this. I think its sort like what happens quite often between a manager and his employees: the manager makes some proclamations that are impractical and often unrealistic, and some significant portion of the employees decide they just have to smile and nod, but basically they are ignoring it as invalid. So in this case they feel they are forced to falsify the results.
I think that probably there are some schools in well-off neighborhoods where kids are advantaged and the administrators don't run into these issues that they consider moral dilemmas. The administrators and teachers in those schools may say that the other teachers deserved to be fired based on the poor performance of their students, but those privileged teachers aren't aware of the disadvantages that the other students are working against and therefore don't realize that students' failure to meet objectives often isn't their teacher's fault.
Personally I think that national measurements and guidelines are very important, but fine-grained command centralized control over an entire system has been proven time and again to be repressive and result in failure.
This goes for all sorts of systems, not just education. It is good to try to come up with standards, do holistic analysis, have common data formats and an egalitarian shared perspective and goals. But a system needs to be highly localized and non-homogeneous to be efficient, robust, and have the freedom to evolve and adapt to local conditions.