Bacteria Generate Electricity from Wastewater

Re:Bacteria Generate Electricity from Wastewater by NtochkaNzvanova on Thursday September 14, 2023 @04:22PM (#37514352)

Engineered microbes are almost always far less fit than wild-type. They will survive best in a monoculture, and if they are forced to compete with less hobbled strains they will usually find a way to get rid of the engineered modifications in order to grow faster.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Bacteria Generate Electricity from Wastewater by worik on Thursday September 14, 2023 @04:26PM (#37514394)

> Engineered microbes are almost always far less fit than wild-type. They will survive best in a monoculture

True

But the article did not address this, it should have.

It will be the big question before deployment

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Bacteria Generate Electricity from Wastewater by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday September 14, 2023 @05:42PM (#37515241)

I've always wondered how quickly this effect would ruin the monoculture.

Suppose you're treating the engineered microbes like sourdough starter: Add them to nutrient solution, wait for desired effect, take a small sample, add to next batch.

You'd expect a selective pressure away from the engineered outcome, such that after X batches, your samples are overrun by wild-ish type mutants. But is that a merely academic concern, something that might happen after 500 batches, or are you out of luck by batch three?

[ Parent | on HN ]