The sentimental value of a diamond is its rarity. And natural diamonds with few imperfections are rare. And a big diamond, useless for anything else, is the only way to show how much the marriage is worth. This is what is being sold to us.
Synthetic diamonds are destroying 50 years of marketing.
And I can't believe males and females of 21st century still fall for this. Literally any use of this money could have been better.
*In the USA.
Seems pretty narrow minded. Of course engagements rings are symbolic. The best symbols are deeply rooted in cultural context anyway.
If diamonds aren’t the best symbol for you that’s fine, but try not to fool yourself into thinking you’re being more rational. You might have different priorities or values.
You might also just be a 2 dimensional NPC with nothing to share and therefore no need for symbolism. /jk
The irony here is that diamonds as engagement gifts given by males to females (why not the other way round btw?) have very shallow and well-documented roots. Moreover, given the exploitation around it, it's really bad to found your marriage on if you really think about it.
It's not even just synthetic diamonds, natural diamond scarcity is artificial as well.
I suspect we'll be seeing an increase in branding in the diamond business. That's really the only way they can control prices since it's now possible to create man made ones. Given enough time the prices will collapse to the point of cost of producing them plus a small premium. Competition will make sure that happens. There's no way mined diamonds will be able to compete.
Diamonds aren't going away they are just making a marketing transition.
Why not just destroy money? And record this as a memento if needed. May be less wasteful than making the diamond.
See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K_Foundation_Burn_a_Million_Qu...
We hear about families selling their jewelry to escape the country or when they're short on funds, but did they actually get a good price for it?
It’s used as a store of wealth that is likely to appreciate. Doesn’t matter if the currency goes bust, ownership is recognized by the government in all but the most extreme examples.
We’re spoiled in the developed countries where you have thing like government bonds and equities (where public companies are vetted to some standard) and courts that can reliably protect ownership of an otherwise intangible asset.
This was in a country with high inflation that's just gone through a regime change. Did he get a good price for the watch? Yes, at that moment, the truck was more valuable than the watch.
Three trucks full of wet concrete have value too, but they're a helluva lot less convenient to bring with you in a bag on the run.
Jewelry is (a) small, (b) valuable, (c) widely exchangeable for currency or goods.
Sure, you're going to take a haircut on the price, depending on how screwed up your immediate environment is, but there will be some buyers at some non-zero price.
The jewelry sellers pretend their product is like precious metals: a store of value.
In fact, it's much more like collectable trading cards: popularity contributes more value than component materials.
I.e. why heritage Tiffany or Rolex pieces still have substantial value
https://www.visualcapitalist.com/sp/chart-how-much-gold-is-i...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_gold_pr...
At current rate, China will have mined all its reserves in under 6 years.
Another "weird" market where this holds true is the dating market. In general it seems similar to how we evaluate other humans or forms of life in general. If another person is too perfect they either seem fake or trigger a weird uncanny valley effect.
I say all of this as one that has made a living with various modes of image capture with a camera.
My opinion: Diamonds are hotpockets: there is a lot of money going into advertising an otherwise unhealthy thing (for you and global society as a whole).
Industrial diamonds have been important for much longer than synthetic gem-quality diamonds have. Abrasive tools need diamonds, but they don't need to be attractive, so they aren't.
There's a business idea, figure out how to sell jewelry at a markup low enough that it makes sense as a store of value and then actually participate in both buying and selling.
I've heard of people making that sort of thing on a limited basis, but the market isn't there. There aren't enough people aware enough of the issue, and the temptation to just go ahead and charge the jewelry premium as a result is pretty overwhelming.
Diamonds have the unfortunate (for diamond sellers) property that they have a very simple chemical structure. So what DeBeers is trying to do is create a mental category for "natural diamonds" vs. "lab grown diamonds". The last thing they want is for diamonds (the investment / luxury good) to be defined by the diamond crystal structure.
Consumers are very happy to pay extra for these mental categories when they know the belief in the category is widespread. Let's say you know your significant other will be disappointed if you buy her a lab grown diamond. Well, you have no choice but to buy a natural diamond I guess. A social fiction like this is self reinforcing once it reaches a critical mass. That's what they're driving for
> Diamonds have the unfortunate (for diamond sellers) property that they have a very simple chemical structure.
On the bright side (for diamond sellers) they're known to originate from a certain location. So they could in theory be protected by Champagne style trademarks and extract higher pricing that way.
The way you measure how valuable a diamond is? Purity. The way you tell a lab made diamond from a “real” diamond? Purity.
If it’s too pure it’s fake. There is this weird market where you want the purist diamond you can find, but not too pure. So you want some imperfections, just the perfect number of imperfections.
Too many imperfections and it’s low quality.
Too few imperfections and it’s worthless enough to grind to dust and use on consumable parts for power tools.
The modern jewelry market is also substantially different than what past generations taught me jewelry was. To them, jewelry was meant to be a value store. You purchase a valuable ring, the stone and metal held their value and you or your heirs could sell it later if times were tough.
Now jewelry seems more like buying a new car. It loses half its value when you drive it off the lot.