Why not? Can't you go to a store and ask to see products? Open an app and see what they have to offer you?
When you seek the products out, it's not advertising, it's information.
Also, without advertising, search engines and the web would be a lot more trustworthy than they are today. When searching I used to get many real websites created by humans, now I see ad-funded AI-generated utterly worthless SEO spam. Advertising is literally the root cause of the enshittification of the web.
I would rather keep advertisements specifically restricted only to those who already have a need, and are interested in choosing a commercial solution for that need.
To take your point further, why not abolish, ban luxury market segment. A $10 shirt does the same job of $500 one. Well Apple created a necessity in making you to buy a $1000 dollar phone, it does the same job as $400 one.
I would allow market place to decide what new ideas should take hold in society. Taking an uber or online dating was frowned upon, not anymore. People can change, society can adapt, better processes can be put in place to avoid hurt sentiments of all parties involved.
Also, congratulations on your surplus income. Many people do not enjoy that luxury.
Consider another area where recommendation results in ecommerce like activity. Food delivery apps. One could say why not visit the restaurant and eat there. Through delivery apps, I come to know about new items / cuisines, restaurants, their reviews and buy them. In fact the situation is far more worse in delivery apps because you can't return a food item once tasted. Not so with other category of products like clothings, etc.
I feel like Benedicts Evans should make a primer on why ads exists and how better ads could serve society.
> Through delivery apps, I come to know about new items / cuisines, restaurants, their reviews and buy them.
I use these store and delivery apps extremely often. I have issues with their tracking of my behavior but I don't consider them to be advertising at all.
I opened the app because I wanted to see the products and offers. That's not advertising, that's information which I specifically requested. Advertising is when the app gets in my face with nonsense I couldn't care less about while I'm trying to do something else.