News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by xnorswap on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @05:33AM (#37494392)
Individual countries within the EU have their own regulators who make their own enforcement decisions.

The EU isn't a super-state and EU law isn't applied by some overarching entity. On a technical level, each country ratifies and applies their own laws in their own ways.

Given this, other countries could act on this too, but it's the French regulator who has chosen to do so.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by DaiPlusPlus on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @06:05AM (#37494666)
> The EU isn't a super-state and EU law isn't applied by some overarching entity

Yes-and-no: the EU Commission serves as the "executive branch" (Americanisms...) of the EU, and while the EU isn't a true federal superstate union yet, but there's enough similarities that the EU Commission probably does 80% of the work it would be doing if the EU were.

While the majority of EU directives are enforced by member states, the EU can enforce itself via several routes (e.g. there is now an EU public prosecution, and the EU parliament can vote to apply sanctions on its own members for non-compliance (e.g. Hungary).

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by tpm on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @06:20AM (#37494781)
> there is now an EU public prosecution

That only prosecutes the misuse of EU funds (and perhaps the EU VAT border regime?) and even then only with cooperation with local prosecutors. In addition, the EU prosecutors are from the participating member states - several EU members are not yet participating.

> EU Commission probably does 80% of the work it would be doing if the EU were.

It's very far from that; notably health-and-safety enforcement is largely in the jurisdiction of members states.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by oblio on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @06:59AM (#37495077)
> Yes-and-no: the EU Commission serves as the "executive branch" (Americanisms...) of the EU

That's not an "Americanism". It's a principle of the separation of powers and I imagine it dates back to the "Europeanianist" Englightenment.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by DaiPlusPlus on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @07:55AM (#37495517)
EDIT: I'll admit I overlooked the US system's origins origins and concepts in France - but even though these concepts are not American in origin, the US is where all the mentions lead-to today.

---

It is an Americanism because the term implicitly assumes two things:

1. That the government is split into branches, following how the US system evolved.

2. That executive power must be confined to a single branch, also how the US is organized.

Then, consider that other-countries-that-are-not-the-US do exist, many of those are liberal democracies that arguably function better than the US for various scores - and of those very few (if any?) of those are modelled on the US’ system. While some other countries have a US system but score poorly overall (e.g. Liberia).

It is demonstrable that deep separation between the agents of the government - and the state - is unnecessary for a functioning liberal-democracy today: many countries using the Parliamentary system have an executive cabinet and an executive PM role which, under the US system, is considered part of the legislature - and the US is hardly the best example of “separation” of the judiciary when you consider how explicitly political the judge appointment process is - and the volume of politically-motivated and arbitrary SCOTUS rulings over the past 120+ years.

———

I understand that (non-crackpot) political-scientists would agree that judicial independence alone is far more important to a functioning democracy than a system that constantly pits an executive President against the legislature whenever their political party affiliation differs.

Don’t get me wrong: accountability is of paramount importance; I just want to communicate that having “separate but co-equal branches of government”, “separation of powers” (and other thought-terminating-cliches from middle-school civics class) is both unique to the US - and is demonstrably unnecessary for a functioning liberal democracy.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by seszett on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:19AM (#37495742)
> It is an Americanism because the term implicitly assumes two things:

> 1. That the government is split into branches, following how the US system evolved.

> 2. That executive power must be confined to a single branch, also how the US is organized.

I'm pretty sure these principles are originally French. The American system was built around these principles as well, but calling them American is a whole new level of Americentrism.

Separation of powers into three branches is basically a prerequisite for belonging to the EU, as it is considered a basic requirement for a democracy.

For that matter, the US and France are probably two of the modern democracies that have the least separation between these powers (on paper).

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by DaiPlusPlus on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:35AM (#37495905)
> I'm pretty sure these principles are originally French. The American system was built around these principles as well, but calling them American is a whole new level of Americentrism

I'll concede that - certainly.

> Separation of powers into three branches is basically a prerequisite for belonging to the EU, as it is considered a basic requirement for a democracy

The EU is concerned more with judicial independence, not constitutional separation-of-powers: most EU countries (and especially its founding and early members) do not have separation strictly along judicial/legislative/executive boundary lines: The UK, Germany, Spain, and others all have an executive parliament; France and the US are in the minority here.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by tpm on Thursday September 14, 2023 @03:30AM (#37506036)
> most EU countries (and especially its founding and early members) do not have separation strictly along judicial/legislative/executive boundary lines

1. Let's not count the UK because it's the earliest democracy, and also is the messiest one (no written Constitution...) and also it's not the earliest or current member of the EU.

2. What exactly is an 'executive parliament'? My understanding is that in parliamentary democracy, the parliament chooses the executive, but the executive powers lie solely with the executive (government), and the parliament in itself does not have any direct executive function. It can only legislate, not execute. Certainly that's the case for Germany and Central European parliamentary systems I know a little bit more of. Might be different in the US but we are talking about the EU now.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by DaiPlusPlus on Thursday September 14, 2023 @03:52AM (#37506170)
> What exactly is an 'executive parliament'?

Sorry - I was being sloppy and made-up a term that at-the-time made sense to me but I didn't proofread my post...

But I was referring to any parliamentary system where executive power is held by (a subset of) the members of that parliament (i.e. how the PM's cabinet's members are MPs) - basically what Canada and the UK has, for example.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by tpm on Thursday September 14, 2023 @05:01AM (#37506558)
Ah ok now I understand. Don't know about Canada but the UK is certainly an exception in this regard. In Germany and rest of Central Europe the PM and ministers are not required to be MPs, in fact currently in Slovakia we have a interim government without any MPs at all. Also in Slovakia when a MP is made PM or member of government he is temporarily released from the parliament and a substitute from the party list is temporarily taking his MP place. In some other countries sitting MPs while in government still have to take care of their MP duties.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by oblio on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:09AM (#37495645)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separation_of_powers#Montesqui...

The origin of the principle is literally European, but all right, you have an agenda, have fun :-)

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by DaiPlusPlus on Thursday September 14, 2023 @05:43AM (#37506834)
My "agenda" is just that I'm cognizant of how the US has an oversized cultural influence over the RoW that has the effect of US cultural exports (including political theory) gradually replacing and then erasing local culture/concepts/etc with that of the US' own especially when such a replacement isn't warranted by the merits of the US' version. A straightforward hypothetical exmaple is how Starbucks, by virtue of their supply-chains and business acumen could establish itself in a new country and compete with local bougie coffee shops and chains before securing a dominant market position. I'll grant you that for those customers expecting the same consistent Starbucks experience in this new country this is a win, but do those people represent majority of retail coffee consumers in that country? Would you agree that a US-dominated global monoculture might not be a good idea in-the-end?
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by fdfdfdf55 on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:06AM (#37495619)
The day EU claims supremacy over member states we will burn Brussels to the ground
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by toyg on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:24AM (#37495794)
You missed your chance then - treaties already require member countries to defer to European rules where conflicting.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by fdfdfdf55 on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:36AM (#37495920)
My country has a supreme law written in 1978. Any other law that conflicts with this one is illegal and must be repelled. Anyone who wants to overturn our 1978 law is effectively declaring war to us.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by DaiPlusPlus on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:39AM (#37495944)
That sounds more like dogma than democracy.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by toyg on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:47AM (#37496034)
I guess this is why geeks are largely not involved in political processes. People seeing all topics as 1s and 0s are called maximalists and typically laughed out of the room.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by kaba0 on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:54AM (#37496110)
Laws are to be interpreted by the courts.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by gxnxcxcx on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @03:51PM (#37500905)
The first modification to that 1978 document came 14 years later, done for the sole purpose of keeping it in compliance with the Maastricht Treaty. The line in the sand you are fervently defending was crossed a long time ago.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by closewith on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:06AM (#37495621)
The EU is not and never (on human time scales) will be, as there is no appetite for a federal union in many member states and unanimity would be required.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by toyg on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:22AM (#37495771)
Anything can happen in the same way as it happened with Maastricht and the Euro: cooperating countries would just go forward with new entities that inherit the previous institutions, dissolving or mothballing old entities. In the long run, the hard core inevitably wins.

Anything that includes France, Germany, Italy, and Spain, will inevitably drag everyone else one way or another.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by closewith on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:58AM (#37496149)
> Anything that includes France, Germany, Italy, and Spain, will inevitably drag everyone else one way or another.

Maybe so, but whatever it became wouldn't be the EU and wouldn't include most of the current members states. It's obviously still an impossibility, as there is no appetite in any of those four countries for a federal EU.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by toyg on Thursday September 14, 2023 @06:14AM (#37507035)
You're making up your "obvious" reality there. EU federalism was born in France and remains strong in the other three countries I mentioned - it might not be a clear majority at the moment, but it's definitely a popular idea among large swaths of the population. The evolution of EU structures undeniably goes in that direction year after year, with stronger and stronger federal institutions.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by closewith on Thursday September 14, 2023 @07:24AM (#37507491)
> You're making up your "obvious" reality there.

There has never been even a hint of a popular federal movement in any of the countries which you mentioned, so I don't think I am.

> EU federalism was born in France and remains strong in the other three countries I mentioned - it might not be a clear majority at the moment, but it's definitely a popular idea among large swaths of the population.

That's a bold claim that I'm sure you'll be able to back up?

Honestly, I think you've allowed your own preferences and wishful thinking to cloud your judgement here.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by toyg on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:31AM (#37508797)
> There has never been even a hint of a popular federal movement in any of the countries which you mentioned

It depends on your definition of "popular movement", but there have been plenty of popular leaders arguing for federalization, from Briand onwards. Just recently: https://www.euractiv.com/section/politics/short_news/german-...

> a bold claim that I'm sure you'll be able to back up?

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/14651165221101505 - this paper explicitly sets out to find non-federalist views, reporting that 44% hold "traditional" views (federalists and separatists), which would indicate federalism is about 20-25% of the population - that's a "large swath", in my book. And that's pure-federalism; the generic support that can likely be turned is much higher.

I mean, that's just a random source. The news focus on anti-europe trends these days because, for so long, pro-europe ones were the mainstream default.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by closewith on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:31AM (#37510317)
Your source doesn't at all support your claim. Meanwhile, there is no indication in any polling that any of the countries you mention have even single-digit support for federalisation.

As I said, you've either blinded yourself or you're intentionally dishonest.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by toyg on Friday September 15, 2023 @08:37AM (#37522032)
Lol, keep talking. Meanwhile, actual federalists continue doing the work set up by Brand, Schuman, De Gasperi etc, almost a century ago. For example: https://european-union.europa.eu/principles-countries-histor...
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by tpm on Thursday September 14, 2023 @03:34AM (#37506060)
Yet several EU members still don't use the Euro and will not use it for the foreseeable future. So the hard core didn't win?
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by toyg on Thursday September 14, 2023 @06:09AM (#37507000)
Technically, all of them are required to join once their structural problems are solved - it's not that they chose not to adopt but rather that they were left out to avoid compromising the currency. Most of them have a clear political will to join the eurozone. The only real exception is Sweden, which effectively enjoys a de-facto opt-out like Denmark, for historical reasons (although they are increasingly under pressure to join).

Regardless, the hard core has won because the Euro is now a cornerstone of EU policies, whether the non-EZ countries like it or not. Every project, every accounting in the Union is now done in Euros.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by tpm on Thursday September 14, 2023 @06:43AM (#37507239)
> Technically, all of them are required to join once their structural problems are solved - it's not that they chose not to adopt

Denmark has a real opt-out. They chose not to adopt in a referendum.

> Most of them have a clear political will to join the eurozone.

No they absolutely don't have that. Even leaving out Sweden and Denmark - it's a toxic political issue in Czechia even though de facto euro is widely used in the business. And while Hungary has currently no chance to fulfill the technical conditions, there is also no political will to join until Orban is in power (and that will be a long time). The ruling party in Poland (PiS) is also explicitly against the euro, as is majority of the population.

> the hard core has won because the Euro is now a cornerstone of EU policies

The Euro won through merit - it just makes sense to use a common currency in the common market.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by toyg on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:20AM (#37508643)
> Denmark has a real opt-out. They chose not to adopt in a referendum.

I know. My sentence was meant to highlight how Sweden is de-facto in a similar position, if not de-jure.

> it's a toxic political issue in Czechia even though de facto euro is widely used in the business.

Translation: it's happening no matter what.

Hungary and Poland are currently suffering from backwards political headwinds. In the past they would have happily joined (but couldn't). But again, like in Chzechia, it's basically happening de-facto no matter what. Once sanity prevails, governments typically find that having multi-currency systems is a headache.

Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by tpm on Thursday September 14, 2023 @01:42PM (#37512220)
It's not going to happen in any of those countries for the next at least 10 years. If ever.
Re:iPhone 12 withdrawn from French market for non-compliance... by hugoroy on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @06:33AM (#37494883)
> The EU isn't a super-state

True whatever that means :)

> and EU law isn't applied by some overarching entity.

It is. EU law as a whole is ultimately applied by an entity, the Court of Justice of the European Union. It is overarching, over national courts, over national governments, and over EU bodies.

Then within EU law, you have several branches and distribution of who has authority etc. Primary EU law is the foundational basis (some would say a "constitution" effectively even though the word has been a political minefield) and does provide some "overarching entity" in some areas.

Then within Secondaru EU law, you have regulations, orders, directives, etc. Many regulations and orders have an EU overarching entity, and in many cases the European Commission has a central role.

> On a technical level, each country ratifies and applies their own laws in their own ways.

That is a gross mischaracterisation and overgeneralization of EU Directives.

EU Directives as a general rule* don't have "direct effect" in a Member State. They set a goal agreed at the EU level, and the Member State are bound to implement the means in their national laws to reach the goal. That usually (but not always) means at a national level the adoption of a legal act by national Parliament.

*as a general rule because as always there are exceptions.