News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Deep dive into the UK air traffic control meltdown by darkclouds on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:21AM (#37463571)
Interesting to see that flight plans over the UK have to be filed 4 hours in advance.

No mention of plane, pilot, passenger and cargo manifests. So why the 4 hour lead time, is this the time it takes UK Authorities to look people up or workout if the cargo could be dangerous in an airborne Anthrax (Gruinard) Island [1] or Japanese subway Sarin [2], or an IRA favourite, fertilizer bomb thats bypassed the usual purchase reporting regulations used by people like Jeremy Clarkson and Harry Metcalfe as their store of wealth[3]?

It makes me wonder just how much more surveillance of the population exists, knowing I cant even step out of the front door without attracting surveillance of the type that followed Dr David Kelly.

Sure its not a cyber attack per se, carried out over the internet like a DDOS attack or a brute force password guessing attack with port knocking mitigation, but how would one carry out a cyber attack on this system if the only attack vector is from people submitting flight plans?

There sure is a constant playing down of the cyber attack angle to this which makes me think someone wants to Blurred Lines!

One point on the lack of uniquely named global way points, which is the main crux of the problem falling over if some are to be believed.

The USA demonstrates a disproportionate number of similar names, by virtue of Europeans migrating to the US [4]. So has this situation arisen with this system in other parts of the world like in the US? How can a country that created the globe spanning British Empire become so insular with regards to air travel in this way?

I'd agree with the initial assessment that there appears to be a lack of testing, but are the specifications simply not fit for purpose? I'm sure various pilots could speak out here, because some of the regulations require planes to be minimally distanced from each other when transiting across the UK.

On the point of ICAO and other bodies to eradicate non-unique waypoint names, its clear there is some legacy constraint still impeding the safety of air travellers, perhaps caused by poor audio quality analogue radio, so perhaps its time for the unambiguous and globally recognised What 3 Words form of location identifier, to come into effect?

The UK police already prefer it to speed up response times [4]. And although the same location can create 3 different words, suggesting drift with GPS [5], even if What 3 Words could not be used for a global system, having something a bit longer to create an easily recognisable human globally unique identifier is needed for these flight plans and perhaps maritime situations.

Obviously global coordination will be like herding cats, and if such a fixed size global network of cells were introduced, some area's like transiting over the Atlantic or Pacific could command bigger cells, but transiting over built up areas like London would require smaller sized identifiable cells. But IF ever there was a time for the New World Order to step up to the plate and assert itself, to create a Globally Unique Place ID (GUPID) for the whole planet, now is the time.

On the point of humans were kept safe, only by the sheer common sense of the pilots and traffic control tower staff, its not something NATS did or should claim, their systems were down, so everyone had to resort back to pen and paper and blocks in queues, and apart from Silverstone when the F1 British Grand Prix is on, is air space ever that densely populated.

NATS were caught with their pants down at so many levels of altitude, is this laissez faire UK management style that saw the Govt having to step in to bail out the banks during the financial crisis, still infecting other parts of UK life and still coming to light?

It's beginning to look a lot like Christmas!

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8Zr0IPtx80

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTr1lquCQMg

[3] https://youtu.be/LS54AJSadT4?t=279

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._places_named_afte...

[5] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-03-21/u-k-polic...

[6] https://support.what3words.com/en/articles/2212837-why-do-i-...

Re:Deep dive into the UK air traffic control meltdown by amiga386 on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:15PM (#37471268)
> so why the 4 hour lead time

To answer your question without conspiracy drivel, let's look up CAP 694: The UK Flight Planning Guide [0]

Chapter 1

> 6.1 The general ICAO requirement is that FPLs should be filed on the ground at least 60 minutes before clearance to start-up or taxi is requested. The "Estimated Off Block Time" (EOBT) is used as the planned departure time in flight planning, not the planned airborne time.

> 6.3 IFR flights on the North Atlantic and on routes subject to Air Traffic Flow Management, should be filed a minimum of 3 hours before EOBT (see Chapter 4).

Chapter 4

> 1.1 The UK is a participating State in the Integrated Initial Flight Plan Processing System (IFPS), which is an integral part of the Eurocontrol centralised Air Traffic Flow Management (ATFM) system.

> 4.1 FPLs should be filed a minimum of 3 hours before Estimated Off Block Time (EOBT) for North Atlantic flights and those subject to ATFM measures, and a minimum of 60 minutes before EOBT for all other flights.

So the answer is because the UK is part of a Europe-wide air traffic control system, which hands out full flight plans to all the relevant authorities for each airspace, and they decided 3 hours is needed so that all possible participants can get their shit together and tell you if they accept the plan or not.

An entirely separate system exists to share Advanced Passenger Information, i.e. passenger manifests [1], and it goes even further that airlines share your overall identity with each other, known as a Passenger Name Record [2], and a variety of countries, led by the USA, insist on this information in advance before the plane is allowed to take off [3]

If you're going to be paranoid, please work with known facts instead of speculating.

[0] https://publicapps.caa.co.uk/docs/33/CAP%20694.pdf

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advance_Passenger_Information_...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passenger_name_record

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States%E2%80%93European...

Re:Deep dive into the UK air traffic control meltdown by darkclouds on Monday September 11, 2023 @08:54PM (#37475703)
So on point 3 then, why do countries, turn people away at the destination and not before take off, if their visa or passport is not in order?

Are their systems not joined up, or does the state just like making examples of peoples once on the destination country? I can watch this stuff happening to people at airport border controls on TV all the time so which is it? Their systems are not joined up or they just like making examples of people?

Re:Deep dive into the UK air traffic control meltdown by amiga386 on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:27PM (#37476390)
Most countries do not have prescreening or data sharing treaties. Even in the case where two countries do have it, not all entrance criteria can be determined by electronic records. Countries reserve the right to check the traveller themselves before they permit entry.

Here's a list of common reasons for the UK to refuse entry on arrival: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/suitability-refus...

Some examples:

* Your valid travel document (as communicated digitally) turns out to be invalid when you actually present it

* You got a tourist visa, not a work visa, so why do you have work tools in your luggage?

* You turn up infected with Ebola

Re:Deep dive into the UK air traffic control meltdown by splonk on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @12:45AM (#37477018)
Airline employees routinely turn people away at the departure airport due to visa/passport paperwork not being in order. Timatic is the usual system that most airlines subscribe to for this kind of thing. Airlines are highly incented to avoid letting a passenger board who won't be admitted, because they're on the hook for returning that passenger. But an airline employee in at the departure airport is never going to be able to be a perfect proxy for an immigration officer in every country they fly to, and immigration officers generally have wide latitude in who they accept/reject. It is extremely possible that all your paperwork is in order but the immigration control officer rejects you for other reasons.
Re:Deep dive into the UK air traffic control meltdown by darkclouds on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @04:10AM (#37478100)
So how do they spot the fake passports then?

And is this a legal on the hook for returning passengers that are not allowed in the destination country?

I've got caught in the US when Hurricane Katrina was landing, and whilst we were flown out by our carrier, other carriers in this situation would also honour our ticket and fly us back to the UK.

It seemed like an exodus where all the carriers just got people out of the country as quickly as possible. We were on the last flight out of the airport, but this isnt a legal thing is it?