News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by ThePowerOfFuet on Sunday September 10, 2023 @04:27PM (#37459710)
>In a cubic mile of seawater, the weight of the salt (as sodium chloride) would be about 120 million tons. A cubic mile of seawater can also contain up to 25 pounds of gold and up to 45 pounds of silver! But before you go out and try alchemy on seawater, just think about how big a cubic mile is: 1 cubic mile contains 1,101,117,147,000 gallons of water!

This is one of the best sales pitches for the metric system that I've ever seen.

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by VoodooJuJu on Sunday September 10, 2023 @04:36PM (#37459806)
The original and best sales pitch for the metric system is that a bunch of champagne socialists are going to literally chop off your head if you don't submit to using the more rational "one ten-millionth of the distance between the North Pole and the Equator through Paris" as your fundamental unit of measurement.

Never mind that the old system was more personally intuitive and relatable (pound = amount I can cup in my hands, mile = 1000 paces), keeping my head was simply a better reason to switch.

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by kibwen on Sunday September 10, 2023 @04:42PM (#37459868)
While I could talk at length about the intuitive advantages of customary units (and how that alone isn't enough to outweigh the advantages of the metric system), pounds aren't intuitive (humans are pretty bad at intuiting weight in general) and neither are miles (humans are decent at intuiting human-scale lengths, but miles are just too long).
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by emodendroket on Sunday September 10, 2023 @04:57PM (#37459997)
Once we start getting into large units the argument seems ridiculous. Especially with stuff like a hogshead that is a slightly different amount depending on what is being measured.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by emodendroket on Sunday September 10, 2023 @04:39PM (#37459838)
Yet regimes all over Europe adapted it anyway. The reason the US retained its system has less to do with the units being so intuitive and more to do with having industrialized early enough that switching would have been expensive.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by spookie on Sunday September 10, 2023 @04:58PM (#37460012)
The metric system came about around the same time as the U.S. Either way, that intuitive understanding of the imperial system may just come about due to one's growing up with it.

I have the same (I assume), innate understanding of the various metric units, given that I was exposed to it all my life. It's easy for me to glance at something and know if it's as big as a centimeter, a couple, perhaps a decimeter or even a meter. The same goes for the volume of something. I think it has more to do with your education, and experience in life, than it's with... the arbitrary way someone came about with those units.

Nothing against the imperial system, I understand how difficult it is to leave it now, and no-one could predict if the metric system were to take off at the time. I wish all of us would use only one though.

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by emodendroket on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:39PM (#37460345)
It seems likely, yeah. Also, these customary units had all kinds of variations (technically they still do in countries using the UK-derived units though in practice the US ones are the ones people care about).
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by CapitalistCartr on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:02PM (#37460053)
Western Europe was more industrialized than we were at the creation of the Metric System, yet they managed. The longer we waited, the more expensive it got. Now here we are, the last holdout.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by emodendroket on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:37PM (#37460321)
Still, industrialization happened before serious metrification drives and that’s what caused the problem. This video discusses it. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1OeoBbjwEFg

In practice though it’s not as though metric is not used to a significant extent in some contexts even in the US. Your medications do not list the contents of their active ingredients in drams.

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by avar on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:26PM (#37460240)

    > Western Europe was more
    > industrialized than we were[...]
One reason for this is that weights and measures in Europe were less standardized at the time.

While the US (mostly) used a consistent system, different countries, or even different cities and towns in Europe had incompatible systems when metric was introduced.

    > Now here we are, the last
    > holdout.
Don't forget Liberia and Myanmar!
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by zzzoom on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:09PM (#37460098)
I live in a country that uses the metric system. Water and gas pipe diameters are in inches. Nothing breaks because there aren't any competing standards.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by emodendroket on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:41PM (#37460357)
The huge size of the US market has led to internationalization of the inch to some extent. In Japan televisions are sold with a size in inches even though inches aren’t really used for anything else I’m aware of.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by avar on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:35PM (#37460307)
What country is that? Here in The Netherlands there's at least 3 entirely different standards for household water and gas pipes (and I know Germany's much the same).

There's BSP (imperial), but be careful, it's not the diameter that's in inches, it's the inner diameter.

Then there's the common 15mm and 22mm copper water and gas pipes, and Alpex 16mm and 20mm.

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by zzzoom on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:46PM (#37460398)
Argentina. I'm pretty sure that gas installations wouldn't pass inspection with non-standard pipes. You could probably use whatever you want for water pipes.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by avar on Sunday September 10, 2023 @06:14PM (#37460658)
I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but some quick searching seems to suggest that it's just as much of mess in Argentina as here ;-)

https://www.totaline.com.ar/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/17-Ca...

My Spanish is rather bad, but I think this:

> Los tubos son producidos según los estándares establecidos por la norma internacional ASTM B88 y B88M.

Says that ASTM B88 and it's metric equivalent are accepted. As you'll see from the listed dimensions the latter is truly metric, while the former is imperial.

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by zzzoom on Monday September 11, 2023 @08:12AM (#37466074)
The regulations [1] list national standard NAG E-209 [2] for copper gas pipes, which is metric based on ASTM B88M.

[1] https://www.enargas.gob.ar/secciones/normativa/pdf/normas-di... [2] https://www.enargas.gob.ar/secciones/normativa/pdf/normas-te...

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by mardifoufs on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:15PM (#37460151)
Europe adopting something does not mean it's good or intuitive. I like metric but that's just a non argument. It's just like saying the US manages to uses imperial just fine, so imperial is just fine too
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by vhcr on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:40PM (#37460352)
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by emodendroket on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:33PM (#37460295)
It is an argument against the idea that it’s an insane idea from socialists gone mad since conservative regimes found it equally useful.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by crtified on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:03PM (#37460064)
Any system of regular measurement can be adapted to various real world equivalences.

The argument that one division system is inherently superior to the other would be a long one indeed.

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by swampthinker on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:30PM (#37460268)
Hard to understand unless it’s converted to football fields.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by mchaver on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:09AM (#37463489)
American or metric football fields?
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by crazygringo on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:43PM (#37460372)
To be honest, such numbers in the millions and trillions are totally incomprehensible to human experience regardless of which units are used.

It's equally silly to try to convey the size of a cubic mile of water in gallons, just as much as it is to convey the size of a cubic kilometer in liters. The numbers are just round in the latter case.

In other words, both:

  1,101,117,147,000
and liters in 1 km^3:

  1,000,000,000,000
are equally meaninglessly large to any lay reader.
Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by avar on Sunday September 10, 2023 @06:32PM (#37460792)

    > are equally meaninglessly
    > large to any lay reader.
No, because a cubic kilometer of ocean does not contain a nice round number of liters of water.

It contains however many liters of water are in that cubic kilometer after you subtract everything else in the ocean, it'll be close to a trillion liters, but not quite.

Of course the article may be using "water" in the loose sense.

But if it's not the metric version would implicitly provide you with an easily inferred percentage of how much of a cubic kilometer of ocean is made up of other stuff.

Whereas in imperial units you won't know that at a glance, you'll need to either repeat the calculation, or memorize various conversions.

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by HPsquared on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:55PM (#37460487)
You can have an idea of orders of magnitude though, say a billion is a cube 1000 units on each side. That is, a meter cubed with units of 1mm. Actually you could have such a thing on the kitchen table.

Edit: now a trillion, that's getting beyond comprehension. Just multiply each side by 10.

Edit edit: that "1 billion" would make for a good conversation piece. Or, easier, a container with 1 billion small grains in it.

Re:Why Is the Ocean Salty? by verve_rat on Sunday September 10, 2023 @05:58PM (#37460508)
A cubic km of sea water would weigh a bit north of a billion tonnes.

You're right that large numbers are hard to comprehend, but being able to summarise them and convert to other measures easily helps convey meaningful information.

Saying you want to process a billion tonnes of something is immediately grokable as vastly different to wanting to process a million tonnes.

Being able to immediately convert that into a conversation about processing a trillion litres vs a billion litres is similarly valuable.

If I can process 1 tonne of water per unit time, then I know that the cubic km will take 1000 times longer than a billion litres / million tonnes.