Re:What Is an Emotion? William James’s Theory of How Our Bod...
by amelius on Sunday September 10, 2023 @12:52PM
(#37457661)
Only true if collecting "vetted facts" is considered to be just reading and not doing hard, real work.
Re:What Is an Emotion? William James’s Theory of How Our Bod...
by flangola7 on Sunday September 10, 2023 @02:16PM
(#37458472)
Give examples
Re:What Is an Emotion? William James’s Theory of How Our Bod...
by ryanklee on Sunday September 10, 2023 @04:18PM
(#37459614)
Totally wrong.
If the goal is to evaluate a theory's virtues, there's nothing stopping you if you have access to the correct documentation (provided it exists). Not sure what you think is missing.
Re:What Is an Emotion? William James’s Theory of How Our Bod...
by amelius on Sunday September 10, 2023 @09:48PM
(#37461904)
We're talking about new theories here, not well-accepted theories.
If the theory is well-formulated, rests on vetted facts, and you understand the context sufficiently, you can say: "This is a good theory." If it's not well-formulated or does not rest vetted facts, and your understanding is sufficent, you can say: "Bad theory."
There's an entire world of variation between those 2 extremes, but there's no reason implicitly why you can't understand a theory just by reading about it.