News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'How Do You Know When Your Art Is Good?' by throwaway14356 on Friday September 08, 2023 @10:21PM (#37441580)
your art is good when it triggers emotions in those who consume it.

your art is excellent if you can capture your emotions in it

your art is masterwork if you can design your emotions for capture.

Re:'How Do You Know When Your Art Is Good?' by hmm37 on Friday September 08, 2023 @11:35PM (#37442030)
It can't be just any emotion. Or at least not according to Clive Bell's theory. If it just requires emotional response many things could create emotional responses but not necessarily be art, e.g. reading a simple newspaper article, or some news broadcast.

Bell states that there needs to be an "aesthetics experience" produce by "significant form". My understanding of "significant form" is that if you were to look at the piece, with no knowledge whatsoever what it is, you would still feel a sense of "aesthetic emotion" due to the form of the object, and how it's put together. That's what he considered art. E.g. people can look at a Mondrian piece devoid of meaning, but yet get an "aesthetics experience" from it.