https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/05/04/1051725/xenotran...
Source: I know people "close to the matter" since my mom started the collaboration with Revivicor while she was at the University of Maryland, Baltimore.
is by far the worst possible response to a thread detailing an extinction event, with the closest equivalent being the mycologist self-immolation in _The Last Of Us_. But… thank you for the reference. I missed that. I'm happy we are not dead.
I do not get how you are arriving at that conclusion. Would the huge genetic variance in humanity not make an extinction event quiet unlikely, for any kind of transmissible disease?
I thik just the % number is pretty meaningless
However all of that is irrelevant since the GP was musing on the “huge genetic diversity of humans” being a barrier to xenomutation of animal viruses to humans.
Thats not the case, because humans are pretty much genetically identical to near a 1000th of a percent - so a particularly virulent virus that mutated from an animal to a human because of an organ transplant has a pretty good chance of causing a major pandemic.
You don’t even have to take my word for it, Covid, swine flu, h1n1 are all examples of animal infections jumping - and that’s without the added long term exposure / selection pressure a transplanted organ would provide.
Caveat: I’m all for this kind of research and development given the lack of transplantable organs in many health departments, but I’m also in favor of r&d for artificial replacements too.
"It kills between 25% and 90% of those infected – about 50% on average."
Even if it was airborne and very infectious it would not render an extinction event. It could possibly destroy civilization, though.
> However all of that is irrelevant since the GP was musing on the “huge genetic diversity of humans” being a barrier to xenomutation of animal viruses to humans.
No, you misunderstood. This was only meant regarding the ability of any virus to cause an extinction event. This was not applied to crossing the human-animal barrier.
How do you go from a very bad flu to an extinction? Well, we haven’t tried to do that at scale yet [That was a dark joke], but presumably with a very low percentage of death, Covid was able to disable our ability to obtain toilet paper, sail the Suez Canal, not drink bleach and horse dewormer, and enrich commercial real estate owners [I’ll stop with the jokes]. More seriously, our logistics were in the ditch for a while, and we realized we had very few factories for a lot of stuff that is essential for critical things—the plastic cap for the tiny glass vials that we put vaccines in? the tiny cardboard sticks used to hold the test to check if meat processing chains are clean? We had a lot of “I never thought that was a thing” moments. There’s a lot more to be had.
More deaths, especially through a slower mechanism, could block our ability to distribute some essential medicine, disinfectant, food, or even water. If some parents believe that their kids could be dying unless they obtain a compound that is in a protected facility, that facility could be breached—even if it’s all a hoax and that’s actually an insufficiently protected bio-security lab with live samples of a worse infection.
If you’ve seen any pandemic horror story, you’ve seen countless errors in judgment, from the billionaire fleeing to the last uninfected island, carrying the virus on board, to the scientist who missed an assumption, etc.
I’m praying that you are right, but *we don’t know* because (back to the sincerity behind that first joke) we have no idea if our genetic diversity protects us against any zoonotic infection. It’s a domain we understand in principle but have no way to acquire relevant scientific knowledge. Hence why this is a *new type of risk*.
Oppenheimer was able to say that the atomic bomb wouldn’t ignite N2 and the whole atmosphere. Imagine they knew this was a risk but couldn’t run the math because of uncertainty in quantum physics. Would the project be threatening in a completely new way?
To answer your question:
> I do not get how you are arriving at that conclusion.
You indeed can’t because I’m not reaching that conclusion, not formally. There are obvious gaps in my speculative reasoning. But those gaps are known unknowables. They currently seem impossible to disprove clearly.
This is why this was explained to me in a class about the philosophy of science, not microbiology.
Many of those pigs were isolated from the rest of humanity for over a hundred years and completely missed out on the globalization of tons of infectious diseases.
A while ago a group of them were picked up and brought to a special protected refuge in New Zealand, where they are being used for artificial organ research (https://nzeno.nz/) basically for the reasons you highlight.
Am I just crazy? Do others not wonder that if pigs and humans have remarkably similar biology, then this increases the chance that pigs and humans might also have similar mental features? (I'm not claiming we're equally intelligent, just that it's well known that pigs are [quite intelligent](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pig#Behavior):
> Pigs are highly intelligent animals,[64] on par with dogs,[65] and according to David DiSalvo's writing in Forbes, they are "widely considered the smartest domesticated animal in the world. Pigs have demonstrated the ability to move a cursor on a video screen with their snouts and understand what is happening onscreen, and have learned to distinguish between the scribbles they had seen before and those they were seeing for the first time."[66][a][70]
But forget about the capacity to process information. How do we expect to improve as a society, in terms of treating other humans in a non-disposable fashion, if we regularly treat animals in a disposable fashion, given that a standard tactic in feeling okay about mistreating humans involves reducing ("de-anthropomorphizing") humans (via comparisons, propaganda, statistics, etc.) to be like "other animals"?
Suppose aliens were to visit us one day, and sci-fi-magically were to give certain animals a voice and a say, and those animals advocated for giving humans what they got from them: putting humans on little islands, where they multiply, and then a few years later, animals/aliens/etc. come by to use them as transplant sources. Clearly, the chances of that happening are next to zero. However, equally clearly, if this were to happen, the fact that humanity is reduced to such a state would be horrific. Yet the animals are giving us tit-for-tat: does it only become horrific for party A, when party B is able to do the same in return?
Damn. My heart goes out to those pigs. Sleep peacefully, this world isn't a nice place anyway.
That said, total extinction of the human race is unlikely since there are small isolated populations in various places around the world. The end of civilization though is a real possibility.
Human-animal barriers are hard to pass for infections (bacteria or virus) because there’s very little material shared between organisms: occasional spittle of saliva, maybe blood drops during butchering, but not much. Therefore, there’s hardly ever an opportunity to mutate in an environment that would select for human compatibility. In a chimera, there’s a life-long tissue-sized opportunity. Even for one individual, hat’s enormous.
If pigs routinely carry a pathogen to which they are immune or that has no apparent symptoms, we wouldn’t know. We know it happens, but we have no more way of knowing than Christopher Columbus did. If any pathogen proves easily transmittable but deadly to humans, it’s over. Every bridging case tells us such infections are likely, numerous even.
Chimeras are the perfect ground to mutate those until it’s too late — not for the individual recipient, but potentially for the entire human population. This is a very easy-to-imagine and, overall, quite likely extinction event.
We don’t know what pigs have that could be it. We could and do raise chimeras in total isolation, hoping they would not catch anything like that. Still, every step of the process, from the circumstances of the pigs’ birth to where the food comes from, is an opportunity for such contamination.
Philosophically, we know, but we don‘t know: we know what it would look like, so if nasty things happen, we would understand; however, we have no sure way to prevent it until it happens. The closest equivalent in fiction would be the opening chapter of _The Last Of Us_ (spoilers): tell every epidemiologist this is it, set yourself on fire, and beg a foreign country to immediately nuke your country out of existence, hoping that will be enough.
I find that new conception of risk interesting, but have been pondering that scenario for decades (one of my professors was the first to suggest that path). I realize that it sounds a lot grimmer than vegans and Muslim people finding the practice “revolting” without nearly as dark a shadow over the practice.