Here's a bit of personal disclosure. I did a business degree (marketing major) from a mediocre institution. Immediately after graduation, I started a company. It failed miserably, but I learned significantly more about business killing a company over the course of a year than I learned studying business in a university. My business degree armed me with a dubious credential, a less dubious 'network', and ummm, let me check with a recruiter and get back to you...:)
At first, I thought, "I went to a pretty crappy university, of course I didn't learn much." But, through conversations with friends (some of whom went to 'elite' business schools), I came to realize that business schools in general are pretty crappy.
Perhaps this scholastic incubator is the future of business school? If so, it is a welcome development!
Knowing that you went to the top ranked program not opens many doors (bankers were impressed when I had to borrow money) but also gives you the confidence that extends well beyond education.
In a way it's similar to driving up to high school being the quarterback and driving a fancy new car (was not me but I can only imagine). You feel good about yourself (in your own mind) and that confidence affects others as well.
As far as learning about business and how to run one? I didn't learn that from the business program. I learned that working during high school and college and from having a family business and other companies that I worked for.
I learned a ton from my last failed startup. So much, in fact, that it took a six-month vacation afterwards to really digest the experience, and I don't think that I'm boasting when I say that one failed startup, one where you pour everything into it, is equivalent or better to an MBA.
What I didn't get, and I had to work for, was the credential.
The only people that recognize one of my schools (Waseda) as being anything special are all in either Japan or China.
So when I go to meet a client or a banker, I don't have the credential card in my hand, and have to rely on my network, history, and general ability to get along with pretty much everybody.
While these have gotten me along pretty well, I do regret making the naïve assumption that schools were about education, rather than about the people you meet.
Aren't you just reading into it what you want to read? I don't think that was the point of the article at all.
Anyway, I think that school-like institutions for entrepreneurship with a formal process that you need to go though are destined to fail. They go against everything that entrepreneurship stands for. As soon as they become successful, they will start attracting people, who just go there for credentials, but don't have the actual passion it takes to start a company. The guy in the OP is the best example.
Quite a few YC startups have already failed to build solid, growing businesses. Most startups do, after all. The good news is that former YC founders generally find other work, sometimes immediately via a talent acquisition of their former YC company. In other words, they cash in on their credentials, some of which obviously come from having been through YC.
So this "problem" of people seeking credentials by applying to YC has evidently been around for years by now. Fortunately, it's a feature, not a bug. At least until the day that YC starts accepting bribes, or selling spots in YC classes to the highest bidder.
As for folks like the OP's friend, who appears to be applying to YC not because he even wants to try to build a company but because he wants to collect a shiny gold star on his resume: He's as welcome to apply as anyone else. The question is whether or not he will be accepted.
Touche
Don't you mean the long-standing hostility of business towards research academia? It goes both ways, bro, and I've seen a lot more hostility from "entrepreneurs" towards the prospect of looking at academic research material than I have from academics towards the prospect of making money.
(Caricatured) Businesses think most of academics is useless in the sense of not creating profits or anything actionable. They don't have any opinion of its merit in a Platonic sense. They've just done an ROI calculation and said "ROI is zero or negative"
(Caricatured) Academics think that most of business is beneath them because it is not a dignified pursuit for powerful minds. Academics believe business is, in a Platonic sense, worse than academic pursuits.
Obviously, as I indicated, this is a caricature. But I think that business is not interested in academia, whereas academia is "too good for" business.
I'd be interested to hear your take on it though :)
A lot of business people (and people in tech) have strongly negative views of academics that seem to verge on animosity, not just lack of interest; sentiment along the lines of "those who can't do, teach" and "ivory-tower wankery". And a lot of academics have moderate-to-positive views of industry, especially in tech; collaborations with industry are pretty common, especially in certain areas of research like systems and storage.
I guess I always interpreted it as a dismissive (rather than hostile) attitude, but you make a good point. There's a strong case to be made that deep in its soul business believes it does all the "real work" whereas academics merely speculate about what work someone might do some day.
Businesses think academia generates nothing useful. Not ideas, not programs, just a bunch of papers. Businesses, unfortunately, mostly don't read or follow these papers and dissertations.
Academics mostly don't want to "waste time" implementing anything that is, from their point of view, 25-40 years behind the times.
For a nice example of the dichotomy at work, look at Golang. It's an act of pure, truest industry stupidity: they built a programming language by ignoring the entire academic field of programming languages. The result has been universally panned by PL experts.
For an example of the academics going to make money in the same field, look at Martin Ordersky, Scala, and TypeSafe.
Business often seems to think it knows technology, when in fact it knows the small subset of technology that is fashionable or just plain old enough to pass into the industrial mainstream. Academia just doesn't care to re-solve a "solved" problem, even if by "re-solve" we mean make usable for common people and capture heaps of cash. Admittedly, each of these biases arises from how each group gets paid: entrepreneurs by staying on the "business frontier", but academics by staying on the technological research frontier.
So oftentimes, academia will invent something in the first place, but a full generation later, entrepreneurs will finally get rich off it.
http://www.exratione.com/2012/01/the-future-of-the-venture-c...
The present direction of some incubators is towards the concept of schools, in the older sense of the word. To some eyes present experiments look like an early stage in the development of a new scholastic institution of practical business development. With well tuned entry requirements such an entity might serve as a filter that allows venture investment in all graduates with comparatively little detailed due diligence, trusting to the quality of the school (the filter) to raise the expectation value of these blanket investments. Experiments in this sort of model are already taking place at Y Combinator, and others will no doubt follow. If they see success, expect to see more rapid movement towards formalized schools of practical entrepreneurship, which will orbit established venture funds to act as feeder mechanisms. You might look on this as a structured, industrial manifestation of the informal process of apprenticeship and networking that always existed in the startup community - and either like it or loathe it for exactly that reason, depending on your tastes.
It is worth remembering that while venture capitalists and organized groups of angel investors can enter the space of incubators-as-schools from one side, existing scholastic institutions can just as well enter it from their side. I can't image that the traditional schools will be any good at this if they do try, given long-standing academic hostilities towards the business of being in business, but some of the younger less hidebound institutions might well be successful. Consider the present University of Phoenix, a future Khan Academy, and a range of other entities establishing their own early stage venture funds, or partnering with venture funds to do something new in this space - it isn't so far fetched an idea.
Note that a more scholastic form of incubator is, to my mind, a very different concept from what I'll call Vingean Scholastics. This is the vision put forward by Vernor Vinge in Fast Times at Fairmont High in which building startups is a part of the curriculum for all young people and at least ramen-level economic success is necessary for graduation at a high school level. Building a business, or at the least a short-term economic success, is how the students pay for school and how the schools earn their keep as businesses themselves. In that fictional near future, this is all a part of teaching young adults how to live in a world of constant, enormously rapid change driven by computational technology, in which the idea of holding down a job doing roughly the same sort of thing for five years is laughable, and everyone must know how to be an entrepreneur in order to flow with the pace of change.
But this too will come to pass, I think, with Vingean Scholastic organizations as another sort of filter to build and channel groups of startup founders - with, collectively, a positive expectation value on investment - towards future forms of venture fund.