News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech workers now doubting decision to move from Californi... by nvm0n2 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @05:35AM (#37389670)
It's not a part of the design or purpose. It's a part of the current status quo but the EU is a very different construct to the USA both legally and culturally.

The USA has the Constitution which at least in theory places hard limits on what the federal government can do, and the Constitution is strongly supported across US culture and society. The Supreme Court for example has recently started returning powers to the states.

The EU's equivalent is the treaties, which begin by saying the goal of the EU is "ever closer union". So the EU's stated goal at the very beginning of its foundational documents is to homogenize the continent's systems of government. Nothing in the EU's institutional philosophy or culture recognizes that it should be limited in scope and that countries should always have local control over some matters. For example the ECJ almost always rules in favor of more EU control, even when the treaties clearly say otherwise. Due to the widespread nature of this cultural mileu amongst the European political class, the EU routinely takes control of policy areas that it was never granted by treaty whilst facing minimal or no resistance.

For example, you talk about government-shopping by companies who set up their HQ in Ireland. The EU hates the possibility of government-shopping because it thinks the entire concept is illegitimate, so they have been attacking Ireland for years to try and force it to stop being so competitive. You can see that culture at work in the language they use:

https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/ATAG/2022/7335...

"Ireland has been criticised for the way in which its tax system has been used by multinationals to set up aggressive tax planning structures and exploit mismatches and gaps in the international tax framework"

Low taxes are "aggressive" and a "mismatch" which gets "exploited". They think of a country competing against others using low taxes as some sort of hack that needs to be shut down, not a natural part of the competition between jurisdictions. In theory the EU has no control over corporation tax, but in practice the treaties let the EU regulate subsidies, so they redefined subsidy to not just mean direct payments from governments but also just charging lower taxes than France/Germany. And then told Ireland to change.

Now in practice the picture is complicated by the fact that the EU treaties do supposedly limit the EU's powers, because the people who signed them recognized the danger of the EU's unlimited ambition and sought to restrict it. And the US federal government has always grown, often working around or just ignoring the constitution in various ways. But this stuff is all downstream of culture. The Americans have the Republicans and its associated culture, which tries to decentralize government at least sometimes, in some ways. Even in cases like military spending where they don't reduce the size of the federal government they do try to spread it around, hence "porkbelly politics".

Mainland Europe doesn't have many similar parties or cultures. They're all very pro EU "integration" (read: passing control to Brussels). The UK had a smaller equivalent in the form of euroskepticism until they succeeded and Brexit rendered it irrelevant. And now Germany has something a bit like that in the form of the AfD, which despite being constantly smeared as Nazis has a relatively decentralized and conservative manifesto that wouldn't look out of place at a Republican convention. But you can tell how different the cultures are by the reaction: there's a very real and serious discussion in Germany about flat-out banning the AfD despite that it polls at about 20%. Nobody is talking about banning the Republicans.

So in practice I'd argue that the EU doesn't have the same design or purpose with respect to government-shopping as the USA does.

Re:Tech workers now doubting decision to move from Californi... by pavlov on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @07:00AM (#37390162)
The EU isn’t the result of a single intent by a single group of people at a single moment in time. There’s a constant push and pull between the statists and the market liberals, for example.

Thatcher was pro-EU (despite the rhetoric) because she saw it as an opportunity both for British exports and to attract businesses. And it did work! Britain practically wrote large sections of the EU free market rules. The massive growth in London’s financial sector since the 1980s is one example of the benefits.

> “the AfD, which despite being constantly smeared as Nazis has a relatively decentralized and conservative manifesto that wouldn't look out of place at a Republican convention”

Honestly, a substantial minority of today’s Republican Party wouldn’t look out of place at a 1930 German National Socialist convention.

At least Germany is having a discussion about whether forces that are against democracy and human rights belong in a democracy. Most Americans, including old-school Republicans, appear to be just closing their eyes and hoping the problem goes away on its own once the nearly 80-year-old populist leader exits the arena.

Re:Tech workers now doubting decision to move from Californi... by nvm0n2 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @07:36AM (#37390365)
> Thatcher was pro-EU

This is an oversimplification bordering on outright deception. She was pro EU in 1975 when it was being advertised as a free trade zone. As it changed to become more of a universal government she recognized the dangers and came to oppose it. That opposition was one of the factors that ended her career as PM, so to describe her as pro-EU is to seriously distort her views.

> The massive growth in London’s financial sector since the 1980s is one example of the benefits.

This has nothing to do with the EU. The EU never created a single market in financial services and the EU has a long history of attacking the City. The UK was constantly fighting rearguard actions to stop Brussels passing laws forcing City business out of the UK. The moment the UK left, the EU immediately tried to do what they'd always wanted, albeit without much success because, to repeat, the success of the UK at finance was in spite of the EU not because of it.

As for "the republicans are actually nazis", I won't even bother addressing that.

Re:Tech workers now doubting decision to move from Californi... by vxNsr on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @07:31AM (#37390325)
> Honestly, a substantial minority of today’s Republican Party wouldn’t look out of place at a 1930 German National Socialist convention.

This is so much FUD and can be said even more strongly about the Democrat Party. Both have authoritarian tendencies, but only the DNC’s platform has veered all the way to super strong federal government, ignore all constitutional protections and rights in favor of what we think is right. Obama started it really with his “I have a pen and can remake the government with my executive orders, congress be damned”. Biden continues it, abusing the HEROs act to forgive student debt, attempting to enforce mask mandates, passing voting bills that the federal gov has literally no right to mandate as per the constitution.

And again comparing Trump to any dictator is laughable, so I’m not gonna even bother really addressing that except to say that you expose and embarrass yourself when you say that. If you’d spend any time outside of your news bubble you’d see how hilariously out of touch you are with reality.

Re:Tech workers now doubting decision to move from Californi... by kasey_junk on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @07:47AM (#37390446)
George W Bush issued more executive orders than Obama and Biden is trending less than Trump.

It’s hard to know how the platforms of the parties compare because the Republican Party hasn’t bothered to publish one for 7 years.

Re:Tech workers now doubting decision to move from Californi... by vxNsr on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @12:48PM (#37394448)
Looking at total executive orders is misleading (and dishonest), EO’s historically were often used for very inconsequential things, like declaring some nation a friend or thanking someone for something. Without looking at the actual order it’s hard to know the impact and any given EO. Please try to argue in good faith.
Re:Tech workers now doubting decision to move from Californi... by kasey_junk on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @04:33PM (#37397316)
You literally said Obama started the problem with executive orders. How would you judge these in a way that is impartial?

For instance George W Bush signed an executive order establishing the homeland security department. He established Afghanistan as a combat zone via executive order. He declared war on the Taliban via EO. He changed classification rules and military pay based on EO. He removed Congressionally approved union protections via executive order.

What precedent was it you think Obama set?