News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A taste of Coq and correct code by construction by schoen on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:34AM (#37377740)
I've done Logical Foundations and part of Programming Language Foundations, and some of the stuff in your tutorial is new to me (especially dependent types).

Your tutorial is very interesting, but in comparison to the Software Foundations series you have relatively few exercises and they're all at the end of the chapter. I found it helpful to do exercises as I went along, in many cases testing or exercising my knowledge of a new concept or Coq feature right away. So I would suggest writing more exercises and sprinkling them closer to where some of the material is introduced.

Also, some of your exercises in some chapters have a pretty steep ramp-up in difficulty, so again it might be nice to have exercises that gradually build in difficulty.

These are probably important considerations when readers are going to be working through this material entirely on their own and it might be their first exposure to Coq. (I think your tutorial says it was previously presented in-person, which has got to be a lot easier, since people can ask questions!)

Thanks for writing and sharing this material!

Re:A taste of Coq and correct code by construction by stepchowfun on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:36AM (#37378083)
Thanks for your feedback!
Re:A taste of Coq and correct code by construction by schoen on Monday September 04, 2023 @01:37PM (#37382851)
I'd like to add belatedly that I think it's cool that you introduce the Curry-Howard stuff so early on, basically from the very beginning.