News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using the Wrong Dictionary (2014) by dmvdoug on Sunday September 03, 2023 @09:25AM (#37370237)
The critique of dictionaries made by “teams” of people, as against a single person, is odd. Like the writer expects lexicography to be just an art form where word lovers can explore and display their idiolects or something.

If a dictionary is supposed to state the meanings of words as those words are used, you have to go out and look at how they’re used, not toil in isolation at your desk, tracing in your mind the lines of force emanating from words. Going out and looking means lexicography is something of an observational science (N.B.: “something of”).

Yes, it’s delightful to plumb the depths of something like the OED. But obsolete or antiquated meanings of words are not necessarily somehow latent in the words as used presently. Language changes; meanings change.

You see the same issue more often with etymologies. Some people seem to think that etymology necessarily sheds light on how the word is used today. Like you’re supposed to go “ah-ha!” when someone shows you the meanings of root words or something. Etymology, too, is delightful to play with, but it, too, has a more rigorous face. But thinking you’ve discovered something deep about the present use of a word because you’ve run across a peculiar or otherwise interesting etymology just reveals a basic misunderstanding of what an etymology is for.

All that said, as a somewhat hyperverbal person myself, I completely understand and appreciate the real delight you can experience in word exploration and wordplay. So I throw no shade at it. But the idea that “you are using the wrong dictionary” or even “using the dictionary wrong” because you are looking for the basic descriptive fact(s) about word usage in the present is asinine. From it wafts the odor of one who spends too much time smelling their own farts.

Re:Using the Wrong Dictionary (2014) by Kamq on Sunday September 03, 2023 @11:09AM (#37371025)
> But obsolete or antiquated meanings of words are not necessarily somehow latent in the words as used presently. Language changes; meanings change.

I think you're ignoring that, if enough of us do this, they can also change back.

Re:Using the Wrong Dictionary (2014) by dmvdoug on Sunday September 03, 2023 @11:49AM (#37371347)
Nah, that’s just not how language tends to evolve, except perhaps for specialized vocabularies that are created to denote specific, technical things for the purpose of agreement among those involved.
Re:Using the Wrong Dictionary (2014) by mdp2021 on Sunday September 03, 2023 @02:58PM (#37373230)
> evolve

Develop.

Awareness, as I mentioned nearby, we could say is required for language to "evolve". Out of entropy, a natural occurrence, language can devolve.

Re:Using the Wrong Dictionary (2014) by dmvdoug on Monday September 04, 2023 @11:32AM (#37381464)
Why would awareness be necessary for language evolution? Was it necessary for human evolution?
Re:Using the Wrong Dictionary (2014) by mdp2021 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @02:35AM (#37388565)
> Why

Competence → evolution; incompetence → devolution (increased introduction of randomness).

Re:Using the Wrong Dictionary (2014) by mdp2021 on Sunday September 03, 2023 @02:50PM (#37373149)
> Some people seem to think that etymology necessarily sheds light on how the word is used today

More precisely, we think that an etymological analysis is needed to shed light on why the word is used in some ways today, and to basically reveal its core ideal meaning that allows (or contributes explaining) its uses.

It's awareness.

You have your tools, you should know them adequately well. Language is worth special attention.

Re:Using the Wrong Dictionary (2014) by dmvdoug on Monday September 04, 2023 @11:31AM (#37381449)
> we think that an etymological analysis is needed to shed light on why the word is used in some ways today

I doubt this very much. Words are used the ways they are today because people, at some time, adopted that use. That’s it. That’s the story. Now, something like the OED is wonderful for investigating when/where word uses emerged. Why they emerged when/where they did suggests some deeper reason than “people started using the words those ways.” Except for technical or official vocabulary, I doubt such a deeper reason exists.

> and to basically reveal its core ideal meaning

I don’t know why you’d think an etymology reveals that. “Core ideal meaning” sounds too purposive, like someone somewhere innovated the word you’re studying to capture just that meaning. Suppose a language‘s etymology for “car” (the language’s equivalent I mean) is “fire wagon” because that was what people happened to start calling it and it caught on and spread. That doesn’t give you any deep insight into cars, fire or wagons. Nor does it give you any deep insight into word formation (semantically), nor about the range of possible extensions of “car” in that language (e.g., if they invented a car powered by water and introduced the term “water car,” they wouldn’t then find it somehow forbidden because etymologically it’s a water fire wagon).

> You have your tools, you should know them adequately well. Language is worth special attention.

No disagreement here. But we don’t study the origin and history of hammers simply because we want to be careful, excellent craftspeople in the present. (But, as I say, language and its history are interesting topics in themselves.)

Re:Using the Wrong Dictionary (2014) by mdp2021 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @02:50AM (#37388670)
> doubt; suppose

You may have to study the matter a bit instead of looking it from the outside then.

> car

If 'car' comes from 'cart', and 'cart' could be descendant from an idea of "basket" and/or from an idea of "runner" ex carrus, then this notion should be one you gained, for awareness and competence, present when you use the term, and a notion you should gain to have a proper insight of the term.