News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by alexgartrell on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @02:41PM (#3735814)
Linux is subsidized by large players who need an open platform on which to provide other services. This includes companies like Google who provide advertising based upon things that run on linux and companies like IBM who sell proprietary software that runs on Linux and support contracts for those products.

There are very few viable, large-scale open source projects that are run on developer free time alone.

Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by angersock on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @02:51PM (#3735867)
Tell that to the GCC folks, GIMP developers, Blender developers, Tremulous developers, Firefox developers, Mono developers, Rails developers, Python developers...

(we all know GTK is a labor of love, 'cause you couldn't expect people to pay for it.)

Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by davidw on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @03:16PM (#3736042)
The thing you guys are missing is "that which is not seen":

http://bastiat.org/en/twisatwins.html

Just because there is some open source code doesn't mean that there is an "optimal" level of it. In other words, maybe due to the relative lack of funding, there's a lot less open source than there could be if there was a better financial feedback loop between people getting value from the software and those developing it.

This isn't just something I'm making up - I've spent a lot of time around open source, and seen a lot of good people who could have done lots more if they had had more time to dedicate to working on the code, rather than working a "day job".

Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by gcp on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @04:04PM (#3736316)
Quite a few people get paid to work on GCC. Mozilla has paid staff. Rails work was paid for by 37signals, etc. Mono has paid developers, etc...

Just because you're not paying for these products directly, doesn't mean someone else isn't.

Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by zasz on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @02:58PM (#3735922)
Can you prove that those projects wouldn't be healthier if people were happy to pay money for them?
Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by icebraining on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @03:36PM (#3736175)
They could be healthier if we seized 20% of everyone's paychecks to fund them too, but that doesn't mean we should.
Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by kenmazy on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @03:32PM (#3736145)
Can you prove they would be?

How many closed-source, for profit software projects were rescued after the supporting company went under? (I am intentionally conflating closed-source and for profit as the majority of financed projects are closed source).

What you have to consider here is the rate of progress, as well as the length of development time. Open source projects have essentially infinite development time, whereas closed-source, for profit projects have a finite development time (whenever the company decides further development isn't worth it anymore)+. However, open source projects tend to have a slower rate of progress versus financed projects.

After 6 months or 1 year, sure, the financed project will probably be ahead. How about the 5 year mark? 10 year? It becomes much less clear which project will have accumulated more man-hours.

+very rarely, closed-source projects are released as open source (e.g. Doom 3), but I think we can all agree that that is the exception to the norm

Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by gcp on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @04:10PM (#3736342)
very rarely, closed-source projects are released as open source (e.g. Doom 3), but I think we can all agree that that is the exception to the norm

Well, if we compare to the list in the parent, it's much more. At least Firefox, Blender, Rails qualify. These were products that had no future in closed-source form. If they had, it would have been financial madness to open source them.

Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by jerf on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @02:55PM (#3735897)
Do you think you're countering InclinedPlane's point? Because you haven't. You've explained the how to InclinedPlane's what, but that hardly constitutes a disproof.
Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by alexgartrell on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @03:31PM (#3736138)
The thing about proof by contradiction is that you can invalidate it by showing that the contradiction is not, in fact, a contradiction.

Linux is used everywhere, but it's also paid for. If it weren't paid for, it wouldn't be used everywhere.

Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by snowwrestler on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @05:35PM (#3736817)
For those wondering how this translates to the music industry, there are a few analogies.

- Independent bands who sign corporate contracts--see The Roots. - Major labels who create teen brands like Justin Bieber or Selena Gomez. They don't care if you steal the music as long as you buy the t-shirt, buy the book, see the movie, come to the show, etc. - Sync licenses. More and more mid-level bands are depending on getting their songs into movies, commercials, tv shows, etc. to bring in revenue. This is another form of corporate funding.

Re:Paul Graham has lost the plot by notatoad on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @03:42PM (#3736207)
bringing the discussion back to its original topic, the music industry is subsidized by large players as well. every famous musician makes good income from just the fact that they are a celebrity. product endorsements, festival and tour sponsorships, etc. companies pay musicians to produce music in a way that is totally abstracted from the actual sale of music.