Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by chasontherobot on Friday September 01, 2023 @12:48AM
(#37346904)
#1 matters if you want to own and ride a bike for a few decades, which used to be a relatively common thing.
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by midoridensha on Friday September 01, 2023 @02:22AM
(#37347484)
I've seen no evidence that aluminum bikes don't last a few decades. Frame failure is not a common failure mode in bicycles.
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by wiredfool on Friday September 01, 2023 @06:21AM
(#37348895)
I've had two frames fail with fatigue cracks at ~ 10k miles or less. One steel (at the chainstay bridge weld) and one aluminum (at the seat tube/bottom bracket weld).
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by Xylakant on Friday September 01, 2023 @03:09AM
(#37347699)
Not only can you weld steel, it also is more forgiving in the failure mode. Steel bends and the damage to the frame is better visible (and could be corrected, if you prefer so) while aluminum frames can develop hidden defects and catastrophically fail.
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by Qwertious on Friday September 01, 2023 @03:58AM
(#37347956)
#4: steel bikes have a lower carbon footprint than aluminium bikes.
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by almostnormal on Friday September 01, 2023 @04:21AM
(#37348129)
Frames made of wood do exist, their footprint is probably even lower.
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by prmoustache on Friday September 01, 2023 @07:01AM
(#37349169)
They tend to use a lot of toxic resins though. Same for bamboo made bikes.
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by gambiting on Friday September 01, 2023 @04:05AM
(#37348011)
In like........any measurable way? I'm not being funny, I'm honestly curious.
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by smorrebrod on Friday September 01, 2023 @07:47AM
(#37349559)
The lowtech magazine published this number¹:
> Scientists have calculated the lifetime carbon emissions of a steel bike at 35 kg CO2, compared to 212 kg CO2 for an aluminum bicycle.
[1] https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2023/02/can-we-make-bicycles...
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by gambiting on Friday September 01, 2023 @03:16PM
(#37355035)
That's super interesting - it's a lot more than I would have thought it is. Metal is metal, right? Didn't think the difference would be so large.
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by midoridensha on Sunday September 03, 2023 @09:06PM
(#37376173)
I'm not sure on all the particulars, but metals are not the same: some require more energy to work with or to refine than others.
Steel (IIRC) needs a lot more energy to melt than aluminum, however I think aluminum requires more energy to extract from ore. Also, IIRC, aluminum needs more energy to weld just because it conducts electricity so much better, even though it has a lower melting point.
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by smorrebrod on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @05:38AM
(#37403006)
Contrary to iron, silver or gold, aluminium has to be chemically extracted. The mineral you extract aluminium from is bauxite. This chemical process was mastered so recently that the Washington Monument is tipped with it just to show off. Even then the tip is so small that you can barely see it with your own eyes, but you can see it in Spiderman :)
https://thescienceof.org/spider-man-washington-monument/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPVzP2Jfdgs
Re:VanMoof acquired by e-mobility company Lavoie
by midoridensha on Friday September 08, 2023 @06:08AM
(#37431711)
Yeah, I think Napolean used to show off his wealth by using aluminum silverware at his fancy dinner parties.
These days, I'd say #3 is the only really valid reason for most people. Steel bikes are generally heavier than aluminum however, but it is possible to get them close if you use a high-grade cromoly steel, but then that removes most of the cost advantage.