I feel for people who don't get this or perhaps never contemplated it, but the system is designed to breed good workers and sort them into bins. And its not a bad thing either. Sure there are non-economic self contained benefits, but those are perks, not purposes.
> It absolutely, unequivocally is. People can romanticize it anyway they want, but formal education is very different than religion camp, painting class, or spiritual retreat training.
No it isn't "absolutely, unequivocally." What specific formal education are you talking about?
Especially in the past, but continuing somewhat into the present-day, formal education has mainly been about enculturation, and not "labor preparation." That can seen clearly by the former emphasis on dead languages and the continued emphasis on literature.
However, I do see a modern trend where many people are so degraded by economics that they have trouble perceiving or thinking about anything except through the lens of economics or some economics-adjacent subject.
There is zero labor prep value in learning to extract information from text (that you possibly have no interest in reading)?
But those are the fringes of the education system. The core focus is on producing high value citizens that will produce far more than they take. This is abundantly clear if you look at the social valuations of high caliber students with fruitful degrees.
That said, the discussion is about the purpose of classrooms in a world of AI, and I think it’s a good time to remember the less economic purposes of education that have always been there under the surface. I think few teachers are more driven by bringing economic benefits to their students than enriching/exciting/interesting them, and secondary and post secondary education has always had a huge variety of non-occupational courses, from ancient history to obscure languages to nice math.
Overall, I imagine we agree on the most important thing: if education does end up changing immensely as AGI gains footing, we should change it to be less economic
The students want to learn things and socialize with peers.
Teachers want to teach, earn a living, get respect of society.
Parents want their children to be taught, but also want their kids to be taken care of by other adults so they can go to work in peace. Poorer parents in particular also need their kids to be fed and sometimes schools have to do that too.
Governments want an educated citizenry that is productive, pays taxes, knows the basics of law, civics and so on. They also want to monitor and protect unfortunate children who have bad parents.
If schools only had one purpose you wouldn't see the stakeholders fight each other so often. But in reality parents fight governments over the curriculum, students fight teachers over the amount of work, teachers fight government/parents over their wage and so on.
No. Students want to socialize with peers or play sports/video games. Not learn.
> Teachers want to teach, earn a living, get respect of society.
This is correct
> Parents want their children to be taught, but also want their kids to be taken care of by other adults so they can go to work in peace. Poorer parents in particular also need their kids to be fed and sometimes schools have to do that too.
Also correct. Parents want schools to be daycare, or for elite families, schools are networking opportunities
> Governments want an educated citizenry that is productive, pays taxes, knows the basics of law, civics and so on. They also want to monitor and protect unfortunate children who have bad parents.
Correct. But a population can be productive while being largely uneducated (see China)
But despite the different priorities of the groups, “the student learning”, is not one of them
China's a terrible example in trying to support your point. If the pitch is "education makes better workers" then you shouldn't be looking at GDP, you should be looking at GDP per capita, aka "Are the workers more productive in more educated countries?". And China has a terrible GDP per capita. It ranks 64th in the world to the US's 7th. Applying slightly more rigorous comparison across the world, there's a clear correlation between GDP/capita and average educational attainment.
And you have a very dismal view of students. In my area, at least at the honors level, students were pretty well engaged in learning. Now, that was mostly in order to get into good colleges and appease their parents' desire for them to learn, but they definitely were eager to have the knowledge that was being taught. By the time you get to college, a fair fraction of the students are truly engaged with the material for the material's sake. Even moreso in degrees that aren't glorified trade school programs.
This is frightfully incorrect. Students definitely love to learn. They do not like to be stuffed in a chair and lectured at and forced to do rote activities. But who does?
No, because you've forgotten one of the important stakeholders here, which is society at large, which has a interest in ensuring a general level of shared education. Which once again results in fighting, as parents who are teaching their own children run up against government requirements that they may not agree with.
First, a functional democracy requires that the citizenship be well informed and capable of critical thinking: "A republican form of government, without intelligence in the people, must be, on a vast scale, what a mad-house, without superintendent or keepers, would be on a small one."
He also saw the economic side, saying that education was an equalizer for people in terms of helping them to reach their full potential.
I quite agree with his assessment. In a system where everyone has a vote, it becomes quite important that everyone have a sense of things that extends beyond their career vocation. His imagery of an uneducated republic being a madhouse makes much sense from this perspective.
Insofar as we have given up any optimism about the democratic enterprise, then certainly we could look at education as purely to put people into economic bins, but at least in my own public school education in the US, every student did get significant doses of math, history, science, etc., outside of their expected career direction.
This to me suggests that there is a tension, not fully resolved and HOPEFULLY never fully resolved, between education-for-economics and education-for-democracy. I think it's quite pessimistic though to give up the ghost on the education-for-democracy aspect.
This is a category error. You're talking about the education system as though it was designed from accurate first principles towards a specific intended outcome. Like, you can say that the absolute unequivocal purpose of a nuclear reactor is to heat water. But when we're looking at sociopolitical organizations, that have been codified through various political forces over tens of generations, through the demands of ever-shifting stakeholders, etc this is not a useful framing.
> but the system is designed to breed good workers and sort them into bins. And its not a bad thing either. Sure there are non-economic self contained benefits, but those are perks, not purposes.
I think a more accurate framing is that the system is currently evolved into strongly emphasizing this mode of behavior.
Where the mundane is keeping young people out of the streets, maybe teach them arithmetic and some grammar. And the leaders, that is, the teachers, want, most of the time, just to bring home a salary, not funnel the masses from schools to office desks or assembly lines.
But it is not the only reason, or (in my view) even the most important reason.
Maybe before assuming people haven't contemplated what you're saying, you could try to contemplate what else general education might be buying us. Maybe by imagining how it would look if school was actually just job training starting in elementary school, rather than covering all these other things.
"Purpose" in an entirely subjective thing.
To me it means "the reason why <person> does <thing>", so the phrase "purpose of a system" doesn't make sense without a particular human subject who's interacting with the system.
"Much of this education, however, was not technical in nature but social and moral. Workers who had always spent their working days in a domestic setting, had to be taught to follow orders, to respect the space and property rights of others, be punctual, docile, and sober. The early industrial capitalists spent a great deal of effort and time in the social conditioning of their labor force, especially in Sunday schools which were designed to inculcate middle class values and attitudes, so as to make the workers more susceptible to the incentives that the factory needed."
From the Marxist paper backing that article:
England initiated a sequence of reforms in its education system since the 1830s and literacy rates gradually increased. The process was _initially motivated by a variety of reasons_ such as religion, enlightenment, social control, moral conformity, socio-political stability, and military efficiency, as was the case in other European countries (e.g., Germany, France, Holland, Switzerland) that had supported public education much earlier.15 However, in light of the modest demand for skills and literacy by the capitalists, the level of governmental support was rather small.16
In the second phase of the Industrial Revolution, consistent with the proposed hypothesis, the demand for skilled labor in the growing industrial sector markedly increased (Cipolla 1969 and Kirby 2003) and the proportion of children aged 5 to 14 in primary schools increased from 11% in 1855 to 25% in 1870 (Flora et al. (1983)).17
Sorry if I sound challenging or rude - just hurts my soul to imagine people giving in to the capitalist’s desire for us to interpret our prison as a fact of natureWhat are we really educating kids for these days? To have advantage over other kids because we have no fair meritocratic way to allocate resources or meaning in society?
Won’t AI just make this infinitely worse.
Like, one vision is more teachers and more students learning better, and another is less teachers and more baby sitters and lower government budgets for education leaving students with the equivalent of an automated telephone answering service menu instead of a real human call centre?
- Make kids show their work (outlines, revision histories)
- Retool to focus on the things where the tools can't do all the work (proofs, diagrams, word problems for math; research, note gathering, synthesizing for writing)
- After kids learn the basics, incorporate the tools into the class in a semi-realistic way (using a TI-whatever in the last years of high school math education)
Of course this would possibly exclude using SaaS-based LLMs like ChatGPT in places like schools, and as such it might make sense to require students to utilize open ones. Or maybe, if OpenAI provided a verification service whereby a prompt could be checked against the output it supposedly produced in the past at some point (even if the behavior of the chatbot had since changed).
I mostly disagree (and I used WolframAlpha thoroughly during my engineering education). Wolfram can solve well encapsulated tasks (solve for X, find the integral, etc). Even then often it gives you a huge expression, whereas doing it by hand you can achieve a much simpler expression.
It doesn't really handle complex problems, at least like the ones you'd find in a college level math or physics course. It can be a tool for solving certain steps within those problems (like a calculator), but you can't plug the whole thing into Wolfram and get an answer.
GPT4 is kinda OK at this, like 50%+ success rate probably, highly dependent on how common the problem is.
Those complex problems are taught and asked in college level classes because of Wolfram Alpha. Like the parent commenter mentioned, classes had to adapt to new technology and since Wolfram Alpha could solve the straightforward questions, college classes started asking more complex ones with multiple steps and where the problem needs to be reframed in order to actually solve it.
I don't like this. It seems to me that this would lead to teachers forcing formulaic approaches to writing on children (even more than they already do). No uniform process is going to work on everyone and having students write using a process like that produces bland, uninspired and unmotivated essays.
Furthermore, outlines and revision histories also seem easy enough to fake with a GPT-like AI: you can just ask the AI to write an outline and then have it iterate on that.
That's your utilitarian take that would eliminate many things you would consider superfluous. Social sciences, history, art, useful personal skills that might not be directly to the economy (like home related stuff or questioning authority)
It should be about empowering citizens in many ways regardless of how much they'll end up contributing to society. As for historical examples, women and wealthy people who studied and couldn't or didn't need to work still studied.
If you subscribe to the purely resource exploitation view, you end up on the road to optimize for the elites in power through lobbying and corporate manipulation.
Having a population that thinks for themselves may actually lead to more unrest and economic uncertainty of all the KPIs that corporations usually love.
Of course, corps will want education to be a specialized training ground for future human resource exploitation and govs might want to create voters for their party (or nation build through ideology and principles) but just because either might get their way to a hig degree doesn't mean that "the primary purpose" is what they get away with.
I see zero evidence that this is true. This is not the stated nor revealed preference of a significant portion of the population.
What more evidence than that do you need?
I see your point though, I was thinking about school, not university.
I think understanding how to work well with AI and what its limitations are will be helpful regardless of what the outcome is.
Even if silicon brains achieve AGI or super-intelligence, I think it's highly unlikely that they will supersede biological brains along every dimension. Biological brains use physical processes that we have very little understanding of, and so they will likely not be possible to fully mimic in the foreseeable future even with AGI. We don't know exactly how we'll fit in and be able to continue being useful in the hypothetical AGI/super-intelligence scenario, but I think it's almost certain there will be gaps of various kinds that will require human brains to be in the loop to get the best results.
And even if we do assume that humans get superseded in every conceivable way, AGI does not imply infinite capacity, and work is not zero sum. Even if AI completely takes over for all the most important problems (for some definition of important), there will always be problems left over.
Right now, just because you aren't the best gardener in the world (or even if you're one of the worst), that doesn't mean you couldn't make the area around where you live greener and more beautiful if you spent a few months on it. There is always some contribution you can make to making life better.
It's al very tricky to figure out what foundational knowledge will be useful in 15 years (that's why we pay educators the big bucks ... oh wait ...), but just because it's hard and uncertain doesn't mean it isn't valuable to try to figure it out.
[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/AutoGPT/comments/13z5z3a/autogpt_is...
Relatively high fidelity and public data for some domains does exist, however (think all github commits, issues, discussions and pull requests as a whole). For those domains, it indeed might be only a matter of time.
If a coach assigns someone to repeatedly lift heavy weights in order to become stronger, lifting them with a forklift doesn't achieve the goal, because in real life that strength is intended for situations where you won't use a forklift. The same goes for exercising various "mental muscles".
We need to start valuing human intellect more otherwise it will simply become a thing we have outsourced to machines like washing clothes and transporting our bodies.
We are going to use powerful AI to teach kids to do jobs that AI will almost certainly do better in 10-20 years?
Like I get that there is a notion of "What else are we supposed to do?", but it still just feels so silly and futile to go along with. Like "Lets use AI to teach kids how to program!"....uhhh, the writing is on the wall