News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD Open-Source GPU Kernel Driver Above 5M Lines, Entire ... by sroussey on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:57PM (#37341189)
There is no business reason to restrict themselves on the ISA, and it would be make their hardware less performant compared to the competition which would not be so bound.
Re:AMD Open-Source GPU Kernel Driver Above 5M Lines, Entire ... by dogma1138 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @03:07PM (#37342216)
The competition is very much bound to a rather narrow ISA which is why CUDA is forward and backwards compatible whilst ROCm isn’t.

ROCm will be pointless until at least forward compatibility will be guaranteed by design.

Re:AMD Open-Source GPU Kernel Driver Above 5M Lines, Entire ... by nimish on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:22PM (#37343182)
CUDA is subsequently compiled to the hardware assembly at runtime isn't it? Like precompiled shaders.

C++ -> PTX -> Hardware ISA

Re:AMD Open-Source GPU Kernel Driver Above 5M Lines, Entire ... by StillBored on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:18PM (#37345243)
How so? One of the ROCm layers is opencl which does runtime target compilation, and there is also the various intermediate language representations.

So, presumably much of this is just lack of sufficient resources to assure that all the different combinations are optimally being compiled down on all the independent HW devices.

This was always the OpenCL problem too back before everyone just started using CUDA rather than trying to use it. It worked in a lot of places but the higher level code needed to be adjusted for individual devices because each vendor would do a reasonable job maintaining optimal code generation for their target given code optimized for their target, but switching vendors (AMD<->nvidia) would result in needing two different versions of the code tuned for the individual vendors ideas of how code should be tuned for their platform.

If that wasn't clear say you wrote and optimized code for vendor A's device X, when vendor A released device Y, things tended to work well, but moving that code to vendor B's devices basically required retuning/rewritting things.

Re:AMD Open-Source GPU Kernel Driver Above 5M Lines, Entire ... by mathisfun123 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:10PM (#37345576)
Someone else already said it but it beats repeating: this is wrong

> The competition is very much bound to a rather narrow ISA which is why CUDA is forward and backwards compatible whilst ROCm isn’t.

PTX isn't an ISA and it goes through another translation step before it hits the real ISA (SASS), which does change internally. Though you are right that PTX as intermediate is part of the reason for CUDA's success in that it makes the code portable across cards.

Re:AMD Open-Source GPU Kernel Driver Above 5M Lines, Entire ... by somat on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:47PM (#37346188)
There is a huge business reason to restrict the isa. simple stable interfaces are very attractive to users(buyers).

Take amd64 as a counter example, not only does it not take 4 million lines of code to interface with an amd64 processor, when something new is added the processor is still compatible with existing code. x86 as an architecture is a bit of a train wreak but much of it's success is the effort to keep the interface stable.

Also for example arm, this is getting better but the hardest part about using arm is the isa is all over the place, every single bloody SBC appears to have a different isa.

Re:AMD Open-Source GPU Kernel Driver Above 5M Lines, Entire ... by sroussey on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:51PM (#37346616)
The only users of the isa are the drivers.

No one currently or in the decades past has done otherwise.