News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by jauntywundrkind on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:14AM (#37332387)
Makes me think of the 2 people (Bruce Friedman and Vicky Baggett) in Florida who have gotten hundreds of books removed from libraries. https://www.tampabay.com/news/education/2023/08/24/florida-s...

I detest that so few people can hold the system in such terror, can have such outsized horrible impact on the world.

Then again, it's not always a small force. America has voted for a party that has promised again and again to do everything they can to outlaw abortion as broadly as possible. And now, in 2023, that age has come. At least it was heralded in with really great ads though! https://news.yahoo.com/elon-musk-twitter-bans-ad-201139304.h...

It's with great regret that I find it seem like civilization has to armor up, has to really defend it's tolerance & getting along against what feels like rabid anti-tolerant extremism. The fringe has just made itself so vocal, so petulant, and the question of how the world copes with these strident folks looms: it seems so confounding, so difficult. We dont have the spare capacity to be dealing with the worst, letting them suck up our energy & roadblock the governance & progress this world needs to be making some headway on.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by CryptoDollar on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:31AM (#37332476)
Most restrictions on abortion are in line with all of Europe (where almost no country allows it up to the moment of birth)
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by smt88 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:33AM (#37332494)
This is absolutely false and easy to disprove.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/07/roe-overtu...

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by jdkee on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:38AM (#37332530)
When the article opens, "Stripping millions of American women of their constitutional right to decide whether to bear a child has potentially serious consequences for the political party that made it happen."

The U.S. Constitution is silent on abortion, so the issue is left to the states. This article is already propaganda.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by ttfkam on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:49AM (#37332592)
It is not however silent on the notions of privacy and bodily autonomy.

http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/rightof...

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by jdkee on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:09PM (#37341401)
Privacy and bodily autonomy are nowhere mentioned in the Constitution. The "penumbra of privacy" is a judicially created notion and the aforementioned rights are not explicitly enumerated. They were created out of thin air by the Warren Court.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by ttfkam on Thursday August 31, 2023 @03:20PM (#37342370)
First off, let's take a remedial look at the 9th Amendment:

    The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.
The assertion that it wasn't explicitly enumerated holds no sway in this argument even among the Founding Fathers.

Second, I purposefully linked to A LAW SCHOOL examining the issue under the auspices of CONSTITUTIONAL LAW. But sure, random guy on an open web forum, I'll take your thoughts on the matter over literal experts in the field.

For my next trick, I'll go ask my plumber what stud configuration will perform best for me as a rugby full-back.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by jdkee on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:12PM (#37343068)
You would have to be delusional to think that the 9th Amendment supports the purported right to an abortion. Abortion has been outlawed at various state levels since the late 18th century and has certainly never been recognized at the federal level.

Your linking this line of cases indicates that you have no idea what you are talking about. The notion of privacy and contraceptive rights and abortion are all judicially made rights. They have no basis in any state or the federal constitution. That is why the current court is curtailing these made up rights that have no legal basis. It is because the majority can read what the constitution says, not what various judges read into it.

As for your ad hominem attack, that is the refuge for those who cannot argue coherently. That’s on you bud.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:29AM (#37335543)
That article mixes up the moral and legal principles of the abortion law, and access in practice. In terms of moral and legal principles, Roe was indeed an outlier. The European Court of Human Rights has repeatedly declined to find a “right” to abortion, leaving it to member nations legislatures. In that sense, Dobbs is consistent with the law in the US. Moreover, only a small minority of countries allow elective abortions in the second trimester. Most draw the line for elective abortions at the end of the first trimester (at which point the baby has a face and looks like a baby).
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by tptacek on Thursday August 31, 2023 @03:06PM (#37342198)
What's deceptive about this comment (whether you intended that or not) is that later-term abortions are rare, expensive, and almost exclusively performed because of grave health concerns, most often because of detected fetal abnormality.

The term "elective" is slippery: in ordinary medical usage, "elective" means "not time sensitive" (as we all learned during COVID, when a wide variety of surgeries nobody realized were "elective" turned out to be). In the context of abortion, the term often (but not always) means "when not required to save the life of the mother".

At any rate: it is not the case that mainstream European abortion limitations prevent later-term abortions in cases of fetal abnormality (or, for that matter, to protect maternal health). But that's exactly what many of the restrictions you're defending in the US do.

You once wrote a post about how neither pole of US politics trusts the other to resolve hot-button political questions; gun control can't happen because Republicans don't trust Democrats not to grab all the guns, and an abortion compromise can't happen because Democrats don't trust Republicans to force women to carry gravely abnormal fetuses to term. That was a problem for you then, and isn't now.

At any rate, it is not acceptable to call in bomb threats to my local library (as happened a week or two ago) because of your culture-war concerns about abortion.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:58PM (#37343586)
The frequency of elective second+ term abortions is immaterial, because the issue is the immorality of the act. They’re also not rare. There are over 60,000 abortions annually after the first trimester.

And while third trimester abortions seem to be performed for medical reasons, that does not appear to be the case for second trimester abortions. In Denmark, the abortion rate after 12 weeks is around 4%: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6579506 (Figure 3). In Canada, with especially liberal abortion laws, the rate is 17%. If the rate were driven by medical reasons, it should be similar in Denmark and Canada.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by camgunz on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:52PM (#37344138)
I don't mean to bird dog you on this (well that's not true, I totally do) but you keep making these arguments and not engaging when the facts. I've lost count of the number of times I've pasted these stats to you. But hey, I'll do it again!

Providing elective abortion access is crucial as so many things can go wrong--especially in the 2nd and 3rd trimesters [3]--and you really can't enumerate them all.

> If the rate were driven by medical reasons, it should be similar in Denmark and Canada.

But let's try! Why do people have second trimester abortions? Ironically, it's mostly an access issue [4], but there are other reasons [5] [6]:

- microcephaly and other fetal anomalies are typically only detectable in the 2nd trimester

- many people can't get the time off or can't get the funds (abortion is expensive for many people)

- waiting periods can force people into the 2nd trimester

- delayed recognition of pregnancy and delayed confirmation of pregnancy with a pregnancy test

- logistical delays occurred in arranging insurance to pay for the abortion

- problems locating a provider and time lost due to an inappropriate initial referral (abortion clinics are busy)

In truth, we already mostly have what Americans want [7]:

- 79.3% of abortions were performed at ≤9 weeks’ gestation

- nearly all (92.7%) were performed at ≤13 weeks’ gestation

And the other 7.3% aren't due to evil or cruelty, they're the result of the US' restrictive abortion regime and intense tragedy.

So we don't have to speculate about why people have 2nd trimester abortions; we know. And it turns out it's mostly just an access issue.

> There are over 60,000 abortions annually after the first trimester.

There are at least 3.5m pregnancies [8] annually in the US, plus between 650k-900k abortions [9], so this is < 2% of pregnancies. And again, there are lots of reasons for it.

[3]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10426234/

[4]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22176796/

[5]: https://www.self.com/story/why-people-get-second-trimester-a...

[6]: https://journals.openedition.org/eces/248

[7]: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/ss/ss7009a1.htm

[8]: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db442.pdf

[9]: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/01/11/what-the-...

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:49PM (#37344616)
Nothing you wrote addresses a “factual” disagreement between you and me. The distinction is a moral one: is a fetus that’s more than 12-14 weeks old sufficiently developed that it cannot be killed unless it has a developmental abnormality, or the pregnancy jeopardizes the health of the mother?

If you accept as true the premise that a healthy > 12 week fetus with a healthy mother is a human life that must be protected, it’s very difficult to say we should be able to kill it because the mother couldn’t afford the abortion earlier or couldn’t recognize the pregnancy earlier.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by camgunz on Friday September 01, 2023 @05:00AM (#37348376)
> a healthy > 12 week fetus with a healthy mother is a human life that must be protected

I respect this position, though I don't myself hold it, because pregnancy is a huge risk and can change you forever, and it's not always your choice (assault, etc.)

> The distinction is a moral one: is a fetus that’s more than 12-14 weeks old sufficiently developed that it cannot be killed unless it has a developmental abnormality, or the pregnancy jeopardizes the health of the mother?

I think we do have a factual disagreement though, because this is really rare and is largely an access issue. Most people don't know how hard it is to get an abortion in the US, especially for girls or poor women. Here's some info from Planned Parenthood [0]:

- A 2005 survey of U.S. abortion providers found that among women who have non-hospital abortions, approximately 19 percent travel 50 to 100 miles for services, and an additional eight percent travel more than 100 miles

- As of 2011, 89 percent of U.S. counties had no known abortion provider; these counties are home to 38 percent of all women of reproductive age. (Jones and Jerman, 2014). Furthermore, in 2008, 97 percent of non-metropolitan counties have no abortion services, and 92 percent of non-metropolitan women live in these unserved counties.

- In 2000, the average cost of a first-trimester, in-clinic, non-hospital abortion with local anesthesia was $372 (Henshaw & Finer, 2003). In 2009 this cost was $451. The median cost of medication abortion, which can be done in the first 63 days of pregnancy, was $490 (Jones and Kooistra, 2011). For low-income and younger women, gathering the necessary funds for the procedure often causes delays. A recent study found that women at or under 100 percent of the federal poverty level were more likely than women at higher income levels to have second-trimester abortions (Jones and Finer, 2012). Compounding the problem is the fact that the cost of abortion rises with gestational age: in 2009, non- hospital facilities charged an average of $1,500 for abortion at 20 weeks (Jones and Kooistra, 2011). Most women are forced to pay for abortions out-of-pocket.

- Causing additional delays are state laws that mandate parental consent, notification, or court-authorized bypass for minors, and laws that impose required waiting periods. For example, after Mississippi passed a parental consent requirement, the ratio of minors to adults obtaining abortions after 12 weeks increased by 19 percent.

- Adolescents are more likely than older women to obtain abortions later in pregnancy... [c]ommon reasons why adolescents delay abortion until after the first trimester include fear of parents’ reaction, denial of pregnancy, and prolonged fantasies that having a baby will result in a stable relationship with their partners (Paul et al., 2009). In addition, adolescents may have irregular periods (Friedman et al., 1998), making it difficult for them to detect pregnancy.

This is why women's health organizations are pushing so hard for telemedicine and medication abortions, because various pro-life policies have tragically upped the rate of abortions after the 1st trimester. If the pro-life community really wanted to push down that last 7.3%, they should campaign for more funding for abortion clinics, medicaid coverage of abortions, repeal of parental consent and waiting period laws, more access to mifepristone, and so on.

Whenever I find myself in conversation with members of the pro-life community I'm just depressed by the amount of misinformation they labor under, in particular the prevailing belief that there are significant numbers of women having abortions in the 2nd and 3rd trimesters "for no good reason". You're even trying to show here that it is the case by pointing out a discrepancy between Canada and Denmark and inferring, but we have clear evidence it isn't. It just isn't true. This is our factual disagreement.

IME there are two major parts of the pro-life community: those who are fine w/ 1st trimester abortions and those who aren't. The 2nd group is thrilled with Dobbs and is actively pushing for state and national abortion bans. The 1st group is having a hard time coming to grips with the fact that we actually had the regime we wanted pre-Dobbs: 92.7% of abortions occur in the 1st trimester, and the overwhelming majority of those that don't are for "good" reasons. They hear these bonkers stories of teen girls forced to give birth or receiving jail time for trying to get mifepristone, or women forced to go septic before they're allowed to have an abortion, and they can't square it with what they were told by the pro-life movement. My hope is that they realize they were led down the garden path by a craven political party's compulsive demagoguery, and they continue to make the GOP pay at the ballot box.

[0]: https://cdn.plannedparenthood.org/uploads/filer_public/99/41...

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Friday September 01, 2023 @05:46AM (#37348668)
> I think we do have a factual disagreement though, because this is really rare and is largely an access issue.

No, it’s a moral dispute because the factual issue is immaterial under the other side’s moral view. The fact that it’s hard or expensive to get an abortion doesn’t justify killing a fetus that has a face and can feel pain. Likewise, it doesn’t matter how rare it is. Infanticide in general is rare, that’s not a reason to legalize it at the discretion of the mother.

When it comes to ending human life, we just don’t entertain the kinds of arguments you’re making about “access.” It doesn’t matter. So the crux of the dispute is what you think about the act of killing a fetus at different stages of development. The weight of any reasons for doing so looks completely different depending on that starting point.

> Whenever I find myself in conversation with members of the pro-life community I'm just depressed by the amount of misinformation they labor under

I find myself in the same position when talking with pro-abortion people who think a fetus is a “clump of cells.” I was floored when my wife got pregnant with our first child and I realized how many weeks there were between when the fetus looks human and when Roe allowed states to stop doctors from killing it. Growing up in a pro-abortion area I had never been taught that information.

> in particular the prevailing belief that there are significant numbers of women having abortions in the 2nd and 3rd trimesters "for no good reason".

No, the fundamental issue is that we disagree about what constitutes a “good reason” for a killing a fetus at an advanced stage of development.

> You're even trying to show here that it is the case by pointing out a discrepancy between Canada and Denmark and inferring, but we have clear evidence it isn't.

If you think that the only “good reason” to kill a fetus in the second or third trimester is that the mother’s health is in jeopardy, or that the baby will not live, then the comparison of Denmark and Canada is extremely illuminating. Both countries have widespread abortion access in the first trimester, and both countries allow abortions after 12 weeks for medical reasons. But Canada allows abortions after the first trimester because the woman no longer wishes to be pregnant, while Denmark does not. Canada this has 17% of abortions occurring after the first trimester, while in Denmark it’s just 4%. From the perspective of Danish law, most of the second and third trimester abortions in Canada are not happening for “good reasons” (assuming the probability of later stage medical issues is similar in both countries).

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by camgunz on Friday September 01, 2023 @06:42AM (#37349028)
You're saying it's immoral to abort a fetus after the 1st trimester outside of the typical exceptions (assault, life of the birthing person, etc.). I'm saying that almost never happens, and you're saying even so it should still be illegal.

I think what you're missing is that it's probably impossible to craft such a prohibition bill that still protects the birthing person, because again the cases where abortions occur after the 1st trimester are innumerable. You can say you don't care, or that you value the fetus more than the birthing person, but I don't think it's useful to equate it with "infanticide... at the discretion of the mother". That's wildly out of bounds here. It's an extremely high stakes, complex issue and both sides deserve respect.

I think you need to think through exactly what that regime would look like because, and I'll say it again, we already had it. For some reason you really want there to be a law, but that law wouldn't change the numbers, and it wouldn't have many important exceptions. As a result, women would still seek abortions in unexempted cases (both "good" and "bad"), the same number of overall abortions would happen, all that would change is that more desperate women/girls and caregivers would go to prison, and more desperate women/girls would hurt themselves seeking unsafe abortions.

> When it comes to ending human life, we just don’t entertain the kinds of arguments you’re making about “access.”

You're missing my point. If you're serious about your position ("we want as many abortions as possible to happen only in the 1st trimester") then you need to dramatically increase the access to abortion in the 1st trimester. That's what you should be all over HN posting about. A draconian abortion ban won't do what you want.

> From the perspective of Danish law, most of the second and third trimester abortions in Canada are not happening for “good reasons”

Again you're not responding to the facts I've laid out for you. There are lots of other potential reasons for this (access, primarily), and your only evidence for this is your inference, which is no evidence at all. This is a classic post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy, which you're stubbornly making even in the face of other more parsimonious explanations. I don't know why you insist on believing there's a significant population of women out there that are doing this, but you've yet to show any evidence for it.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by camgunz on Saturday September 02, 2023 @04:35AM (#37359565)
> It’s not something the GOP ginned up to get votes FFS.

You're wrong on this one. The GOP is unbelievably craven and corrupt. Paul Weyrich (founder of the super successful conservative think tank The Heritage Foundation) explicitly demagogued the abortion issue to activate evangelical voters and create a large conservative voting bloc (with the ultimate end of creating segregated Christian schools) [0]. He wrote about it himself; he's proud of it.

[0]: https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/05/religious-ri...

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by selimthegrim on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @12:28AM (#37401339)
Hanafi jurisprudence is not against it for an early time period.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by dctoedt on Friday September 01, 2023 @10:11AM (#37351088)
> If you accept as true the premise that a healthy > 12 week fetus with a healthy mother is a human life that must be protected

I'd be curious about your basis for that premise:

+ If the premise is axiomatic, then it seems to be purely a personal metaphysical- or religious belief, so it would seem hard to justify imposing that belief on others except from a might-makes-right worldview.

+ If the premise is based on the hypothesized mental capacity of such a fetus, do you hold the same belief about killing, say, already-born chimpanzees and other primates — whose mental capacity I would imagine is far superior to that of a >12-week fetus?

+ If the premise is based on the potential of a fetus, unlike a chimpanzee, to develop into a full-fledged human, then why not ban all abortions and post-fertilization contraceptives, e.g., Plan B and IUDs?

+ If (with a nod to Blackmun in Roe) the fetus's potential for further development must be balanced with the impact of pregnancy and motherhood on the mother, then why draw a one-size-fits-all line at 12 weeks, or for that matter any time before viability?

+ Finally: Before viability, it seems like the best idea to give the responsibility for making the decision to the mother who is "on the scene" — much as when a front-line squad leader in combat, not the general in the rear, must decide which of his- or her troops to send to attack a machine gun and likely be killed in the process. (I've long thought the "pro-choice" people should frame their arguments not as the woman's right to choose but as her terrible duty to choose.)

+ Relatedly, as a bad analogy that should strike a chord with you from your clerking stint: Appellate judges generally don't second-guess trial judges about how the latter run their cases except for abuse of discretion, on the theory that the trial judge is closest to the scene and in the best position to make judgment calls. Before viability, the same could be said about the mother.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by tptacek on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:57PM (#37344181)
I'll add to my excellent sibling comment that you just composed a rebuttal that ignored the substance of my comment. You say "we should be able to agree to ban them like they do in civilized countries". But the point of my comment is they don't ban those abortions. To support your argument, you composed another deceptive comparison, between Denmark and Canada. Both allow the abortions we're discussing. But several US states do not.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:43PM (#37344569)
I think it’s fairly clear from my post I’m using “elective abortions” to refer to abortions performed for reasons other than medical reasons (health of mother, fetal abnormality). As you note, Denmark does allow abortions for both of those conditions after 12 weeks, but generally prohibits abortions after 12 weeks for other reasons. It has a second+ trimester abortion rate of 4%. By contrast, Canada allows abortions after 12 weeks for non-health reasons. It has a second+ trimester abortion rate of 17%. Since both countries allow second trimester abortions for health reasons, it stands to reason that a large fraction of later abortions in Canada are for other reasons that don’t justify an abortion in Denmark.

Guttmacher acknowledges that “data suggest that most women seeking later terminations are not doing so for reasons of fetal anomaly or life endangerment.“ (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1363/4521013). That is consistent with the Denmark-Canada statistics above.

I haven’t mentioned any specific US abortion laws, so I’m not sure how you can say I’m “defending” them. I’m talking about the moral principle that’s accepted in Denmark and Germany and France that a second trimester fetus is sufficiently developed that it cannot be killed simply because the woman does not wish to be pregnant. That’s a principle that (1) American liberals aren’t willing to accept; and (2) which does not depend on the frequency of that outcome.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by tptacek on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:27PM (#37345311)
Then you're using the term differently than the GOP is.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Friday September 01, 2023 @02:01AM (#37347344)
My post is expressly about “Roe” being an “outlier” in terms of requiring that abortion be available for non-medical reasons into the second trimester.

I’m not sure how you could interpret my post as being about the official “GOP” policy plank, since that’s long been a total ban which is obviously more restrictive than the laws in Europe. It that doesn’t change the fact that the European laws embody a meaningfully different moral judgment than does Roe about when the fetus is sufficiently developed that you shouldn’t be able to kill it without a heightened showing.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by viraptor on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:37AM (#37332525)
This is largely incorrect. Not even worth pointing out specifics, just search for the actual info if you want to know the actual restrictions in different countries.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by MandieD on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:02AM (#37333037)
In Germany, it’s 12 weeks for any reason, with counseling, which you can get from the churches or various secular organizations including a German equivalent of Planned Parenthood (ProFamilia).

But after that, birth defects (spotted thanks to the detailed ultrasound and testing everyone gets as part of free maternity care) and of course life/health of the pregnant person are grounds. No fear that getting medical treatment for a miscarriage might get you in legal trouble. No fear that your doctor won’t intervene immediately if your wanted pregnancy starts killing you. No fear that you’re going to be forced to give birth to a child just to watch it die.

A whole lot of women from Poland denied care at home receive it in Germany, which does not tell their oppressive home country on them.

Along with a whole lot of other mitigations, like inexpensive and ubiquitous birth control, free maternity care, a year of partially-paid parental leave, and subsidized daycare, as well as more reliable lifelong assistance for people with physical or intellectual disabilities.

Put more concretely: I was unafraid to go through with a surprise but long-wanted pregnancy at 40 in Germany, knowing that if I needed to end it, I’d be able to.

I take precautions not to be pregnant while visiting my home state because of a rise in maternal deaths and a reasonable hesitation of obstetricians to get involved in high-risk pregnancies (which includes any after 40).

So not really.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by tastyfreeze on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:18AM (#37332414)
Like it or not, abortion is not a federal concern. It just isn't something the Constitution gives power over.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by idontwantthis on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:23AM (#37332445)
Last year, this statement would have been factually incorrect. This year, this statement is factually correct. Like it or not.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:35AM (#37332508)
It was always correct, which is why by the end the defense of Roe was reduced to stare decisis.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by anonymousab on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:06AM (#37332687)
The constitution - or rather, judicial interpretation of the constitution - is constantly in flux. The kinda things that were seen as constitutionally valid by SCOTUS less than a century ago are completely off the wall compared to today. And today's views will likely be very different from a future court's interpretation.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by kiba on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:34AM (#37332864)
It's in flux because it's really difficult for us to change the constitution. So, we basically live patch the constitution with the supreme court.

A proper fix would let the constitution change over time.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by skissane on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:41AM (#37332896)
That statement ("abortion is not a federal concern. It just isn't something the Constitution gives power over") was factually incorrect last year and is still factually correct this year – insofar as one accepts SCOTUS as the ultimate authority on what the US Constitution says.

The Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003 [0] is a federal law prohibiting certain abortion procedures. SCOTUS upheld its constitutionality in the 2007 case of Gonzales v. Carhart, holding that the Commerce Clause gives Congress the power to regulate abortion, and that the regulation in question was not contrary to Roe or Casey. Dobbs did nothing to overturn either the 2003 Act nor that 2007 decision, so abortion remains a federal concern, within Congress' power to regulate. (Thomas wrote a concurrence, joined by Scalia, casting doubt on whether such an expansive reading of the Commerce Clause is correct, but said this particular case was not the right vehicle for revisiting that issue.)

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partial-Birth_Abortion_Ban_Act

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gonzales_v._Carhart

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by mikem170 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:44AM (#37332568)
Tell that to the Republicans who want a federal ban.

p.s. It's a shame when so many people loose the right to their own bodies, despite the 13th amendment.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by littlestymaar on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:24AM (#37332796)
Not really. SCOTUS just ruled that constitution isn't responsible of enforcing that right, and noted that there's currently no federal law on the topic. But if congress passed a bill about guaranteeing abortion, it would become “federal concern”.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:22AM (#37332433)
I’m pretty sure the “fringe” is the folks promoting drag shows in public libraries. (That’s consistent with the popular vote from the 2022 election where these issues were all aired.)
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by hackermatic on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:41AM (#37332548)
Actually, the anti-trans candidates have lost most of the recent elections where they made trans rights the main focus, and most people polled either do not care or object to restricting those rights.

1. https://www.ettingermentum.news/p/the-continuing-electoral-h...

2. https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/new-poll-shows-massive-ba...

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:05AM (#37332679)
Drag is a form of self expression, while gender identity conforming presentation is a medical treatment. Completely different (and frankly offensive to suggest the two are related).
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by hackermatic on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:26AM (#37332809)
I find that the people who want to restrict one usually want to restrict the other, and more or less conflate them. Regardless, the articles I referenced above, and the campaigns and polling they discuss, cover the gamut from drag to books to sports to medical treatments, so they do pertain to your original comment.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:43AM (#37332910)
Who conflates the right of adults to dress consistent with their gender identity with drag shows in libraries?
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by smt88 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:38AM (#37332532)
> That’s consistent with the popular vote from the 2022 election where these issues were all aired.

The only people who thought "drag shows in public libraries" was a major issue in 2022 were lunatics who believe everything they see on TV.

If you ask specifically about that issue, most Americans don't support restrictions on drag shows[1]. Why? Because drag shows are an incredibly niche issue that only a small group of people on Twitter care about. Most Americans (correctly) believe that the government's opinion on them should be "live and let live".

1. https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/3924115-most-in...

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:00AM (#37332646)
We have drag shows in public libraries in my supposedly Republican county. And it’s not a niche issue at all. The impact of teaching non-conformity to children has society-wide repercussions. Far more than the capital gains tax rate.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by smt88 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:24AM (#37337624)
Out of all the things kids are exposed to and can access at a library or online, drag shows are basically a non-issue for two reasons: 1) they are, again, a very small niche that parents don't have to try very hard to avoid; 2) not teaching kids anything about conformity.

But taking your position in good faith, what else should we ban from public. Do clowns teach kids non-conformity? A kid in my elementary school wore a clown wig and cape to school every day for some reason, and kids bullied him.

What about Donald Trump? He repeatedly cheated on his wives, talks about how sexy his daughter is, got involved in fraudulent businesses, and then was elected president. Should we ban him from speaking publicly? That's a lot of non-conformity for kids to learn!

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by viraptor on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:34AM (#37332502)
This is not mentioned as any of the cases in the article. How did you end up going to that example?
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by jauntywundrkind on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:39AM (#37332537)
Classic Hannah Arendt, on Origins of Totalitarianism here:

> totalitarianism has discovered a means of dominating and terrorizing human beings from within

These are intolerant views. They don't actually hurt anyone, but the population lets itself be gripped by a mania, let's itself become polarized by a pointless absurd fear, that causes a huge rift. People become dominated by these symbols, let themselves be controlled; these absurd acting outs against books we don't like, against people that don't look like us, against people who believe other things are a terror we let fester within, are a wrerched dad weakness.

There's just no viable long term course for such sad intolerance. We have to be able to tolerate each other.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:07AM (#37332694)
Why should society tolerate drag shows? People aren’t born that way, right?
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by raverbashing on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:18AM (#37332761)
"people are not born this way"

This way how?! wanting to dress up?

Maybe pick up a history book (or just look around) instead of getting an "education" from pragerU

I share some concerns about "social contagion" but the way this is usually discusses is completely polarized and ignorant

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:48AM (#37332943)
Correct—drag is about people’s “wants” not their biological immutabilities. Why is society obliged to tolerate that?

I suspect a history book will show me that nearly every society in history, and our own society until 5 minutes ago, has concerned voluntary non-conformity with gender roles, especially in front of children. What lesson am I supposed to draw from history?

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by raverbashing on Thursday August 31, 2023 @02:13AM (#37333129)
> has concerned voluntary non-conformity with gender roles, especially in front of children

Glorifying gun violence in front of children and making children follow active shooter drills seems curiously fine with you

> Why is society obliged to tolerate that?

Why is society obligated to tolerate right-wingers throwing a fit and causing moral panic about every minor progressive issue?

Why is society obligated to tolerate the alleged "christian morality" (which is anything but) being pushed by right wingers?

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:24AM (#37335490)
> Glorifying gun violence in front of children and making children follow active shooter drills seems curiously fine with you

Banning violent performances in public libraries is fine with me.

> Why is society obligated to tolerate right-wingers throwing a fit and causing moral panic about every minor progressive issue?

What state institutions sanction with their imprimatur of authority to children is no minor issue.

> Why is society obligated to tolerate the alleged "christian morality" (which is anything but) being pushed by right wingers?

To be clear, it’s not limited to “Christians” or “right-wingers.” Public institutions sanctioning flagrant violation of that society’s gender norms would be extremely controversial in most of the world. In fact, of the 7 billion people in the world, the people who think drag shows in libraries are mostly in Christian or formerly Christian countries.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by defrost on Thursday August 31, 2023 @03:56AM (#37333864)
> I suspect a history book will show me that nearly every society in history,

Don't suspect, read a book (unless your local library has been burnt to the ground or blown up by hyper ventilating pearl clutchers).

You do realise (I hope) that significant chunks of western theatre history (ie. popular entertainmant, including for children) has been rife with men in drag playing the part of ladies?

Quick, go check your history books, subsection theatre.

While you're there look up Onnagata in Kubuki theatre in Japan for a bit of Eastern cultural history .. and for goodness sake don't look up Bugis culture in Sulawesi as they've recognised five genders for centuries.

You have some pretty blinkered preconceptions. Home school?

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by rayiner on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:16AM (#37336002)
Do either of those examples convey to kids that it’s okay for them to transgress social expectations and norms? Or are they practical responses to exclusion of women from theater professions?

> You have some pretty blinkered preconceptions. Home school.

Nope, just a normal person (very liberal by global standards).

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by sofixa on Thursday August 31, 2023 @03:17AM (#37333585)
Why should society tolerate computers or phones or solid foods? People aren't born being able to use them!!
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by CryptoDollar on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:31AM (#37332481)
Trans-Maoism
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by frob on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:37AM (#37332520)
I see random right-wing gibberish has moved on from "Social Marxism."
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by anigbrowl on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:46AM (#37332579)
Let me get this straight Rayiner, you're arguing that 'drag queen story hours' (not drag shows) are more fringy than making bomb threats?
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by raverbashing on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:59AM (#37332642)
Truth is the "traditional american values" people are totally scared of some people in costumes, they're so afraid of everything they can't even go to starbucks without a gun

Now, teaching kids violence is all fine and great it seems

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by foolz on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:49AM (#37332588)
It's fascinating that you consider promoting drag shows as "fringe" behavior, considering that drag has been a well known form of entertainment for decades. It seems you've missed the memo that drag has entered cultural mainstream. Your perspective is either shockingly outdated or deliberately disingenuous.
Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by johnnyanmac on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:59AM (#37333004)
>I detest that so few people can hold the system in such terror, can have such outsized horrible impact on the world.

People should remember this whenever they feel "voting doesn't work" or "government ignores us". Look at it in another light; these are government institutions and two seemingly normal people made a huge change by being persistent.

Now imagine if we had a dozen people that persistent defending that content. I know the ability to be that persistent is in itself a sign of priveledge (or simply age. being retired gives a lot of time to lobby), but it also suggests that a lot of people in a few meetings can fight back.

Re:There have been several public library bomb threats this ... by raverbashing on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:08AM (#37333952)
I could write pages and pages of all the dumb crap that progressives do, but I guess "not voting for their candidate because "they're not vegan enough" or "has a more centered position in some fringe topic" to be at the top items of the list