News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MapReduce, TensorFlow, Vertex: Google's bet to avoid repe... by Animats on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:26AM (#37318384)
MapReduce helped solve a huge internal problem for Google - how to update the index dynamically. Originally, index updates were batch jobs that took days to run. But MapReduce isn't the solution to that problem. It's just the orchestration for the algorithm. It was figuring out how to partition that matrix inversion that was the hard part.

Most of Google's problems in B2B reflect that the organization has little concept of customer service, in the sense of serving customers. It's not the technology.

The current problem with AI for Google is that the good stuff costs a bit too much to give away with search. That problem may be solved, or evaded. Most searches or questions don't need a large language model. I expect to see systems where you ask a question, and if it's hard, you get something like "That's a hard question. Give me a minute to work on that. Meanwhile, here's a word from our sponsor."

Re:MapReduce, TensorFlow, Vertex: Google's bet to avoid repe... by spinningslate on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @03:58AM (#37318949)
> Most of Google's problems in B2B reflect that the organization has little concept of customer service, in the sense of serving customers. It's not the technology.

This, exactly. Google is fantastic at research, great at development. It's terrible at product. Or, specifically, all the bits of product that aren't R&D. MapReduce, Tensorflow and Kubernetes are all examples of technical successes that Google has spawned. None is a product. You can't buy them, buy support, or, you know, actually talk to someone if something goes wrong.

That's why Google cloud has failed so far. It's not the tech; big G can go toe to toe with Amazon and MS on that. It's that enterprises want contracts and support and relationship managers and all that stuff. That just doesn't seem to be in Google's DNA. Unless they can adress that, they're not going to win with big org customers.

They might win the startups - where the customers are themselves techies who are OK with self supporting, looking up Stackoverflow, asking ChatGPT, etc. But unless they can address the people angle, I don't see Vertex gaining meaningful traction against Amazon or OpenAI/MS.

Re:MapReduce, TensorFlow, Vertex: Google's bet to avoid repe... by ctippett on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:21AM (#37319094)
Make no mistake, Google has a legion of Account Managers, Customer Engineers, TAMs – you name it – working with large enterprises in most/all major cities... Thomas Kurian's Google Cloud absolutely has sales and contracts in their DNA.
Re:MapReduce, TensorFlow, Vertex: Google's bet to avoid repe... by danpalmer on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:12AM (#37319366)
> The current problem with AI for Google is that the good stuff costs a bit too much to give away with search.

Perhaps, but they seem to be in a better position than many to get that cost to a reasonable level.

They've got the scale, the research side, lots of experience with models of different sizes, they own TensorFlow, they produce and deploy their own Tensor chips (so I would guess are not dependent on Nvidia's tech at 10x markup), and have lots of experience in datacenter power efficiency.

This is all just based on what I've read in tech news. I happen to work at Google but don't have any insider info here. I'm biased, but they seem to be in a good place.