Re:Grave flaws in BGP Error handling
by LegionMammal978 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:43PM
(#37314533)
> Mind you, these researchers didn't test ANYTHING in a lab environment first "because it's a lot of work to test all the open source BGP implementations in the wild". AKA: I'm lazy.
That's a gross exaggeration: they said that they first tried it "in a controlled environment with different versions of Cisco, BIRD, and Quagga routers" [0] without issue. Presumably, the problem we know about would have been avoided if they had happened to include FRR in their test suite beforehand. But that raises the next question, exactly how many implementations does one need to test before one is no longer "lazy"?
[0] https://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2019-January/09876...
Does any sane person think that 1 week is enough time to both notify every user of FRR in the WORLD, as well as ensure they have upgraded their installations for a "bug" that only is triggered by someone using experimental flags meant for testing purposes only?
Mind you, these researchers didn't test ANYTHING in a lab environment first "because it's a lot of work to test all the open source BGP implementations in the wild". AKA: I'm lazy.