News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by oblio on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:14AM (#37293427)
I actually forgot about that, what did they do? Ask for Patreon contributions?
Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by kbknapp on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:24AM (#37293580)
It was a combination between Patreon and Github Sponsors for solo the lead developer at the time making several thousand USD per month. Those campaigns are still ongoing AFAIK, but the contribution amounts are now private.
Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by amedvednikov on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:55AM (#37294012)
To quote the HN mod: the language is fine, and there's no need in these flame wars:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36816393

It was always at ~$1000, not thousands. There were no outrageous claims.

[dead]
Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by msm_ on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:49PM (#37297869)
>Hint: "I'm sure your language is fine" in no way implies that dang said "the language is fine".

This made me realise how trying to sound polite may completely obfuscate what you want to say.

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by ModernMech on Monday August 28, 2023 @11:32AM (#37295734)
This right here is why people have a problem with you and your language. You did make outrageous claims, and to now say you didn't is gaslighting. Accordingly, people do not trust you.

Here's just one. On an early version of your webpage you said in big bold font:

> V can translate your entire C/C++ project and offer you the safety, simplicity, and up to 200x compilation speed up.

When people called you out, it turned into this small subscript

> C++ to V translation is at an early stage.

And it's been in an "early stage" ever since.

I'm sorry, but when you said "can translate your entire C/C++ project" did you mean "can" or did you mean "one day will be able to". Because those are completely different, and to say one when you mean the other is grossly misleading. To now say that you never said the former outrageous claim is gaslighting. We're not idiots or goldfish.

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by riku_iki on Monday August 28, 2023 @11:57AM (#37296130)
> To now say that you never said the former

wondering if you have any link on where author said this (that he never said the former)?..

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by kaba0 on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:15PM (#37297378)
https://web.archive.org/web/20190304161953/https://vlang.io/...

You can take a look at the progress of claims.

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by riku_iki on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:17PM (#37297413)
my question was not about claims progression on website.
Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by ModernMech on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:37PM (#37297703)
I responded to the post where he said "There were no outrageous claims".

"V can translate your entire C/C++ project" is an outrageous claim because it wasn't true then, it isn't true now, and it doesn't appear it will ever be true.

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by riku_iki on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:46PM (#37297817)
it is typical for experimental/beta/alpha projects that features don't work or/and later found not to be feasible and later dropped from road map, there is nothing "outrageous" here.

From another hand, you clearly tried to manipulate narrative by changing context and specificity.

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by forgotpwd16 on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:26PM (#37299223)
There's one thing having them on a roadmap and another claiming can do it and using it as a selling point. First is acceptable, second is a scam.
Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by riku_iki on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:41PM (#37299421)
everything in early stage not prod-ready experimental project is on roadmap, there is no guarantee anything works or will work, this is only healthy expectations for such projects.

Now, can you tell why you and similar folks follow val author in every post even issue has been resolved long ago?

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by forgotpwd16 on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:47PM (#37299507)
>everything in early stage not prod-ready experimental project is on roadmap

There's an archive link posted in this thread that shows the specific feature mentioned (transpilation) was on main site front page and presented as ready and working.

>can you tell why you

Not sure why this became personal. My comments are public and can easily check this isn't the case.

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by riku_iki on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:21PM (#37299925)
> There's an archive link posted in this thread that shows the specific feature mentioned (transpilation) was on main site front page and presented as ready and working.

my reading of archive is that this was in active work, he had examples of translation, and some now dead link on leveldb translation, and some c++ to val translation implementation but removed it lately: https://web.archive.org/web/20190226163127/https://vlang.io/...

> Not sure why this became personal. My comments are public and can easily check this isn't the case.

You just made a "scam" claim about issue which has been resolved long ago. So, this is the case, and I am wondering what is your motivation.

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by Tozen on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:11AM (#37304038)
Aren't developers and different projects allowed to get or ask for contributions, donations, or sponsors?

To add to the strangeness of the story, is the apparent initial jealousy over the amount of donations that other developers got and being upset over the rapid popularity of a competing language. To the point, as to advocate bashing them and even publicly asking people to give them their money instead.

There is a clear double standard being applied and villainization cover stories, to hide what some are not aware of, which was the jealousy and language war aspect involved in the situation. This all having the purpose of attempting to "kill off" or "knock down" a competitor, to their benefit.

Somehow, it's OK for X to get money and sponsors for their competing language, but it's "wrong" (or at least pretend it is) for Y to get money or have sponsors for their language.

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by Tozen on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:27AM (#37304834)
Developers are allowed to get or ask for contributions, donations, or sponsors.

To add to the strangeness of how its being mischaracterized, was the apparent jealousy (back in 2019) over the amount of donations that other developers got. Then for certain ones to have got so upset at getting less, they started to bash and publicly ask people to give them their money instead.

Somehow, it's OK for X to get money for their competing language, but it's "wrong" for Y to get money for their language.

Re:The V Programming Language 0.4 by oblio on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @06:33AM (#37305625)
I have no horse in this race (and you obviously do).

There were a TON of red flags around V for at least 1 year after the initial announcement. Funding, exaggerated claims, etc.

I wish V the best of luck but the start wasn't something that inspired confidence in neutral observers like me.