News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Uyghur mother pleaded for her detained son. Now she’s m... by dirtyid on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:39AM (#37292125)
Sure, one can infer via simple math that XJ arrested 220k/12000k uyghurs in 2017 with official numbers, or 2% of total Uyghur pop. Just like you can infer via simple math that in 2017, US arrested 2200k/41000k of Black Americans [0], or 5% of total black pop. Then what? Obviously there aren't 220k ex Uyghur islamic fighters, but 2% of poor, restive, frontier minority population possibly having symphathy / association (funding, consuming extremist material etc) that supported 100s of terrorist attacks that killed 1000s over the past 10 years as region got radicalized? Or support East Turkestan seccessionism. Probably. 10%? Also probably.

The leap in logic is going from that to millions to genocide a few years later without any more solid verifiable numbers. That's when we enter wild extrapolations by attributing feels from sinister sounding quotes from reports, breaking down securization budgets that end up being too small for the levels of internment, or questionable GIS analysis. Pretty soon you get 1M, then "upto" 2M interned, then draw the rest of the owl meme, and now it's magically genocide.

Also NCHRD / Network of Chinese Human Rights Defenders is in the same category as Zenz on the retarded analysis tier list. And it's no surprise they're ideologically aligned / buddy buddy with him. They can do basic inferences if you give them an addition/subtraction problem, extrapolating past that and it's multiplying questionable assumptions with motivated interpretations to fit propaganda narrative. You can trust a propagandist like Zenz or NCHRD to say 1+1=2, but not much beyond that. That said, going to Zenz sources is not terrible. Half the reason people troll is analysis is how much his reasoning does not follow from source.

[0] https://archive.is/vBWUC

There are no comments on this comment yet.