News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Uyghur mother pleaded for her detained son. Now she’s m... by yorwba on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:40AM (#37291384)
> the Uighur people in reeducation camps are the islamic fighters returning from Afghanistan

How many fighters do you think there were?

> he says he just reads official Chinese press statements, but he "reads between the lines". Encouraging.

Yes, it's a great technique. For example, the government didn't publish arrest statistics for 2017, but did publish them for 2013-2017 in aggregate, so by reading between the lines and subtracting the numbers of previous years, one can infer the magnitude of the wave of mass arrests in 2017 in Xinjiang (227882 people, 21% of all arrests in China) https://web.archive.org/web/20180725042225/https://www.nchrd...

(Incidentally, the group of researchers here doesn't include Zenz. Lots of people can do this kind of analysis of public information. But if you want more of the same, reading Zenz' articles and the sources he cites is a good start.)

Re:A Uyghur mother pleaded for her detained son. Now she’s m... by Garvi on Monday August 28, 2023 @05:01AM (#37291503)
Reading between the lines of official Chinese government statements is a great technique for finding secret dirt (like a genocide) on the Chinese government. Do you stand behind this statement you just made?

> How many fighters do you think there were?

I too read Zens stating there are millions in reeducation camps. You're using circular logic.

> the group of researchers here doesn't include Zenz

What group of researchers? If there's so many, you shouldn't have trouble naming someone besides Zens.

Re:A Uyghur mother pleaded for her detained son. Now she’s m... by yorwba on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:31AM (#37292070)
> Do you stand behind this statement you just made?

I stand behind the statements I made and went to the trouble to provide you with an easily checked example, but it seems you ignored it completely? Did you overlook the archive.org link?

> I too read Zens stating there are millions in reeducation camps.

I was asking you how many fighters you think there were. If you believe that everyone arrested was a fighter, and also Zenz' claim that millions were arrested, that implies you think there were millions of fighters. On the other hand, it doesn't seem like you believe him, so you probably think the number of fighters is less. So how many were there?

But my point was that you don't have to believe Zenz, you can just skim his writing for links to citations and read those instead.

> You're using circular logic.

Where is the cycle in my reasoning?

> What group of researchers? If there's so many, you shouldn't have trouble naming someone besides Zens.

If you read the article I linked, you wouldn't have trouble finding the list of names at the end: Renee Xia, Victor Clemens, Frances Eve

Re:A Uyghur mother pleaded for her detained son. Now she’s m... by dirtyid on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:39AM (#37292125)
Sure, one can infer via simple math that XJ arrested 220k/12000k uyghurs in 2017 with official numbers, or 2% of total Uyghur pop. Just like you can infer via simple math that in 2017, US arrested 2200k/41000k of Black Americans [0], or 5% of total black pop. Then what? Obviously there aren't 220k ex Uyghur islamic fighters, but 2% of poor, restive, frontier minority population possibly having symphathy / association (funding, consuming extremist material etc) that supported 100s of terrorist attacks that killed 1000s over the past 10 years as region got radicalized? Or support East Turkestan seccessionism. Probably. 10%? Also probably.

The leap in logic is going from that to millions to genocide a few years later without any more solid verifiable numbers. That's when we enter wild extrapolations by attributing feels from sinister sounding quotes from reports, breaking down securization budgets that end up being too small for the levels of internment, or questionable GIS analysis. Pretty soon you get 1M, then "upto" 2M interned, then draw the rest of the owl meme, and now it's magically genocide.

Also NCHRD / Network of Chinese Human Rights Defenders is in the same category as Zenz on the retarded analysis tier list. And it's no surprise they're ideologically aligned / buddy buddy with him. They can do basic inferences if you give them an addition/subtraction problem, extrapolating past that and it's multiplying questionable assumptions with motivated interpretations to fit propaganda narrative. You can trust a propagandist like Zenz or NCHRD to say 1+1=2, but not much beyond that. That said, going to Zenz sources is not terrible. Half the reason people troll is analysis is how much his reasoning does not follow from source.

[0] https://archive.is/vBWUC